Issue Two

A Safe Place to Be

by Ceri Black and Lauren Black

We are Ceri and Lauren Black, two lesbians living in Ireland. Our separate and shared experiences have given us a lot to talk about and to discover about ourselves and each other. In this conversation, we touch on dysphoria, butch/femme dynamics, our own 17-year marriage, lesbian visibility, and our fears for young lesbians coming up now. 

Lauren

I grew up in Northern Ireland in the 1980s and 1990s, in the midst of the Troubles. For as long as I’ve had memories, they’ve involved some sort of strife — political, or personal. In the middle of all that, I was protecting a shameful secret.

I am a lesbian.

I did not know what a lesbian was when I was a child or a young adolescent. I was an innocent, really — nothing worldly about me. But I knew I was different from the other girls. I felt, from the youngest age, that I was ‘wrong.’ I didn’t behave like ‘normal’ girls. I didn’t like the things my sister, or my female cousins, or my female friends liked. I was a tomboy. 

I was interested in dirt, bugs, trees, climbing, exploring, the beach, skateboarding and BMX bikes. I watched as people complimented my sister for her pretty dresses and her pretty hair, but when it came time to talk to me, they would often find it more difficult to relate. I was different and I occupied a space outside of gender norms. My mum and my family accepted me just as I was. I felt their love, but I kept my secret. I felt like if they knew me, they would reject me. 

By the age of ten, I knew from the media and from talk in the street, or talk in my school, that there was a thing called ‘being gay.’ People would bring up examples of gay people they knew, usually men, and talk about these people as though they had some sort of disease. It was a sin, they said. It was disgusting, they also said. If boys at school were suspected of being gay, they got horribly bullied and people talked about them in the hallways and behind their backs. 

As a child, I began to suspect that I might be gay too, and by the time I was a young teenager I knew it to be true. The feelings that the other girls had for their boyfriends were feelings that I knew I would never have for any boy, or man. I felt those feelings for girls, but I couldn’t paint a picture of my future at all. I thought that a wife, a life with a woman, a happy family, marriage and children were so far beyond me that I didn’t dare dream about them. 

I was deeply confused and alone. As a result of how I felt, I spent my teenage years gaining physical strength. I entered all the sports that I was good at; I trained, I cycled, I lifted weights. I might be in a girl’s body, I would say, but I refused to be weak.

I wish I had known someone back then, someone who could have helped me name my feelings. I wish I had known women who loved other women and were unafraid; I wish there had been a community. I wish I had known what a lesbian was and that it is okay to be one. 

If I didn’t have breasts or periods, if I had a man’s voice and a masculine body, if I identified as a man, then maybe I could have identified my way out of my problems and out of those thoughts and feelings. I didn’t ever think of this as a possibility. Being trans wasn’t a thing, and if it had been, I wouldn’t have had the resources or the money to go through with any of it. In hindsight, I am so grateful for that. 

I was alone in my thoughts and feelings. I carried a shameful secret about myself, and this left me vulnerable. With the introduction of dial-up internet, I found a new way to do research about being a lesbian. I found myself in the chat rooms of Gaydargirls and on any other thread where I might learn about other girls like me. What I did not anticipate was being groomed and later abused as a result of this exploration. My shame for myself deepened, only now I trusted no one and I told not a single soul about it.

Ceri

That loneliness you describe, growing up knowing you are different, I felt too. I wasn’t quite a tomboy. I was always feminine, but also tough. I wore dresses, but I ripped them climbing trees. I painted myself a pirate beard but wore it with a floral skirt. My hands, knees and elbows were always mucky. I had long, golden hair, but it was a mess, and there were usually twigs in it.

I never really identified as a lesbian, as such. I saw the lesbian kiss on Brookside in 1994, when I was 14, and rather than saying, “Oh, I am a lesbian,” I thought, “I would like to do that.” That single kiss, that little bit of lesbian representation, led me to search out the LGB community. I found the address of a gay bar in the back of a newspaper at my local youth centre. That Saturday, I got the number 11 bus into the nearest town and sat in the corner of the bar, eyes wide, looking all around me. It took me about a year of Saturdays to find the courage to talk to anybody.

I remember what it was like, the community, the way it used to be. I’m so sorry that you missed out on all that. It might have protected you from what happened to you.

The gay men outnumbered the lesbians, of course. The gay men were sometimes misogynistic, particularly the drag queens, and there was always an undercurrent of dysfunction, ‘hook-up’ culture, but there were other undercurrents too.

There was the politics, the sense of shared experience and shared community. All of us knew from first-hand experience what it is to grow up feeling ‘different’ and to negotiate the ongoing, and often dangerous, process of ‘coming out’ to friends, family, work colleagues, new acquaintances.

Most of us wanted equality under the law — the legalization of gay marriage, protection from discrimination on the grounds of our sexuality, and so on.

Many of us had no expectation of help from the police. Some were old enough to remember policemen shutting down gay bars and breaking into hotel rooms to arrest gay men having consensual sex. My own experience was when I was in my early 20s. A woman hit on me in a straight pub. I turned her down. She, and three of her friends, followed me up the road in her car at closing time, and tried to drive me off a cliff, shouting homophobic slurs out of the window.

I didn’t have a mobile phone, but the next day I went to the police station. The officer, who knew I was a lesbian, asked me whether I’d done anything to provoke it, and refused to record the incident. Everybody knew what that was like, and if we didn’t know it first-hand, we knew what the risk was, we knew somebody with those experiences. It gave us a sense of togetherness, mutual protectiveness.

Many of the people in the community remembered the AIDS crisis. The gay men who lived through it had seen their friends dying around them and lived in fear that they would be next. Many of the older lesbian women, in an atmosphere of fear, and at a time where there was almost no widely trusted information about the transmissibility of this new disease, had nursed their gay brothers, whose family and friends deserted them.

As a result, there was a level of respect, particularly for older lesbians, that I’ve never seen replicated anywhere. The butch women used to ‘hold’ the space, with dignity and grace and power, addressing the worst excesses of misogyny in the men, making sure that the occasional transwoman who appeared was respectful of the women. Showing troublemakers firmly but gently to the door. Telling the drag queens that talking about women’s genitals as “sopping clams” was a step too far and they could tone it down or just stop, please and thanks. It was a space full of men, but one held, and made safe, by women.

I loved those women, I loved them so much. There were only ever a few butch women, and a whole flock of femmes vying for their attention. I spent a lot of my teenage years in gay bars, trying to persuade butch women to take a second look at me. It tells you something about butch women that, despite all my efforts, and despite being a pretty girl, I was almost always unsuccessful. Butch women don’t want little girls, they want women.

That community was a place that taught butch lesbians that who they are should not be a shameful secret, but a thing to be proud of. A thing worth having. A thing worthy of respect — even adoration and hero worship.

Lauren

I didn’t have any of that. I didn’t have representation or a community. It made me very vulnerable. I want to go back in time and rescue little Lauren from all that. It makes me want to build a community and build representation for the young lesbians coming up now. When you think about the invisible and disappearing lesbians, and then all the trans representation in the media now, it is unsurprising to me that young lesbians are increasingly choosing to transition. I’m very glad I didn’t get caught up in that, at any rate.

Ceri

By the time you were reaching out over the internet in 2001, I was starting to see the community disintegrate around me. I couldn’t tell you the exact year it became a ‘thing’ that straight women started going to gay bars because it was ‘safer,’ and men didn’t hit on them. They very quickly started to outnumber lesbians. Dismayingly, where there are straight women and drink, there also go the straight men; LGB bars went from being places where I could be pretty sure that I wouldn’t get hit on by a man to places that were as bad as, if not worse than, straight bars. And the lesbians, who would have told them to rein it in, were gone. We felt under threat and under fire.

Unicorn hunting in gay bars became a thing.1 Predatory heterosexual couples started turning up in bars. Invariably, it would be the woman who would come over first and try to hook up with a random lesbian, often not mentioning the man she was with until late in the conversation. And if it wasn’t unicorn hunters, it was straight men, preying on lesbian couples. “Can I watch?” or “Are you sure you are lesbians? You are so pretty.” Then when they were rebuffed, they turned very quickly misogynistic. And the butch lesbians, those beautiful women, were gone.

Back then, it was a kind of joke that a man would say, “I’m a butch lesbian trapped in a man’s body.” We just used to laugh and leave him be. But now, it has stopped being a joke. Now, men who say they are butch lesbians slide into my DMs, despite my being married, and so very obviously in love with you. Some of them try to do it ‘stealth,’ but it’s never not obvious. I can’t imagine being a single lesbian now and having half the dating profiles on apps be of transwomen. There’s even lesbians kicked off dating apps for saying they are same-sex attracted. It’s relentless pressure on young lesbians, who have a hard enough time coming to terms with themselves.

Lauren

The pressure for me is from another direction. I see young, butch lesbian women identifying their way out of the category ‘butch’ and into ‘he/him lesbians,’ ‘non-binary lesbians,’ or transitioning. Think about it. If you grew up how I did, it is understandable that you would take any action to opt out of womanhood.

From the youngest age, I knew that if I had been a man, loving women would not be a problem for me at all. Why wasn’t I a man, then? It was fine for men to want wives, children, and so on. Why couldn’t I want those things?

These questions and many more overshadowed my life and gave me a hatred for myself and my body, my body that felt like it was betraying me. I wasn’t equipped to deal with it, there was nobody to help me, and I just couldn’t understand what was happening to me. I had my period at ten years old, and every month I felt it was a trauma to have a woman’s body, bleeding beyond my control. I felt weak and powerless against it, and I wished I could make it stop. I didn’t want to be a woman — I didn’t want a woman’s body. I didn’t want breasts, periods, long hair, girly clothes.

I didn’t want sexual attention from men, I didn’t want their eyes on me. I wanted those parts of me that made me female gone.

People seeking transition often talk about suicidality and self-harm. Sometimes, I did want to kill myself. Sometimes I wanted to hurt myself. Sometimes I did hurt myself. I didn’t really know what those feelings were related to. I was lost. It’s only in hindsight that I understand what was going on. Self-hatred and being female go hand in hand.

But I knew I would always be classed as outside of the male sphere, so I don’t think I wanted to be a man — I just wanted what the men around me had. Wives. Children. Freedom. Existing outside of judgement. Not being sexualized by the men around them, when they were too young to know what sex was.

Ceri

I feel like you’re saying that the origins of that dysphoria are, to a huge degree, not in you but in the world around you. If you, for example, moved to Women’s Land, and didn’t have to encounter men growing up, that would reduce your dysphoria a good deal. If you lived in a society where there was no homophobia and instead lesbians were visible and celebrated, you wouldn’t have rejected the idea of marriage and children for yourself. If you lived in a world that didn’t discriminate against women and letch over little girls, you might have felt more comfortable in your skin.

Lauren

You’re right. It’s internalized homophobia and internalized misogyny. The answer to those is not to take hormones and have surgeries, disciplining my body to avoid problems that are not mine. The answer is in feminism, and in an LGB community, one which I’m trying, with you and the rest of the LGB Alliance Ireland, and internationally, to build. But we were going to talk about butch/femme dynamics. I know we’ve been challenged to show how dysphoria can be managed through this dynamic.

Ceri

Yes! It’s worth going into some background and approaching that topic obliquely, I feel. The night I met you, you bowled me over. It took us some time to work things out between us, but I knew the day I met you that I would marry you, even if you took a bit longer to persuade. You aren’t any kind of princess; if anything you are the blacksmith’s daughter, clever with your hands, trapped in an iron prison of your own making. I rescued you, and I guess you rescued me right back.

There is nothing in the world I need so much as a safe place to be. Happiness is not a flower I can pick in other people’s gardens. I have to grow it around my own front door. But I never stayed anywhere long enough to do that before. Family never felt like a safe place for me to be; I couldn’t trust that the ground wouldn’t shift. 

But you love me so completely and with such appreciation, gratitude, enthusiasm and joy that, even 17 years later, it can pull me up short. You put your arms around me and tell me I’m safe, and somehow, at long last, after so much wandering, I believe you. You’re my rock, the ground beneath, my harbour, my safe place, my home. After 17 years, you can still melt me with a grin. 

Your dysphoria makes you the most generous lover that I have ever had, and to be centred, worshipped, adored so thoroughly has transformed me utterly. It has given me my confidence and lifted up my head. I sometimes think, am I being selfish? I can open my own doors, I can do my own dirty jobs, I can buy my own things, but it is so nice not to have to. 

Lauren

Selfish? You talk like you think you get all the benefits. You know about my past. You know how I feel about my body. You don’t judge me, you accept me. If I get brave enough to tell you ten percent of my feelings, you are intuitive enough to work out the rest. You carry so much of the emotional weight of our relationship. I couldn’t do that.

You don’t love me despite who I am, you love me because of it. You don’t try to change me. You don’t judge me. You are proud, not ashamed, to be on my arm. You accept me. You make me feel safe to express myself and be who I am. You love the skin I’m in, and that helps me to love it too. Loving you, then, is uncomplicated for me.

Also, you’re hot, let’s be honest. You are the kind of woman who I always wanted and never thought I could have. You remind me of the women in the old black-and-white movies that I would watch when I was a kid. I loved them. I didn’t think they existed any more. 

You’re so beautiful, feminine, free to express yourself, but at the same time, you’re tough to the core, badass, confident. And you love me, you choose me, every day. I used to think that my female body meant I could never have a woman like you. But you fell in love with me because of it. That makes me feel much better about being a woman. 

My body has never stopped being complicated for me. The feeling of discomfort and disconnect around my own body has always stayed with me, no matter how many therapists I’ve seen about it. So, when I make love to you, I get to experience sex, intimacy, love. We have a deep connection; we enrich our relationship. I love touching you. I get to see you happy, fulfilled. Sometimes, I feel your pleasure in my own body, and there’s something satisfying about it for me. There’s maybe a bit of ego in there as well. 

I don’t often want to be touched. Being touched when I’m not in the right emotional place feels like a trauma to me. It reminds me that I have breasts and all those parts of me that make me female. You do reciprocate when I’m in the right headspace, but that’s why it’s so important that you understand me. That you respect my boundaries, instead of thinking I’m weird. I found it so difficult to get my head around your radical acceptance of my weirdness. It has changed my life completely. 

I don’t need you to touch me every time we have sex. It would ruin something for me if you did. It would cut a part of me off. I want to be whole. I want you, but on my own terms. I like sex, but I have to do it in ways that make me happy and comfortable and that let me give you the best of me. 

Besides, you are amazing. It is in my interest to make sure you are happy. It is an absolute privilege even to be near you, so you’re damn right I’m going to honour that privilege and treat you in the way you deserve. 

Ceri

I’ve loved this conversation, but it makes me so sad that there just isn’t a place for these observations and conversations to happen now. A piece in a feminist quarterly is brilliant, but it’s not the same as finding a community. It breaks my heart for the young women coming up. Where are all the lesbian role models? And yet at every turn, there’s another trans one. It is even going into schools: there was Irish guidance for post-primary that had 47 mentions of the word ‘trans’ and only four mentions of ‘lesbian,’ and it defined a lesbian as “primarily attracted” to the “same gender.”

Lauren

This is where we start. We have to rebuild those communities, win back those captured institutions, and get safeguards back in place for young women like I was. 

My heart went out to Keira Bell. She was a lesbian, just like me, she was a baby butch, but instead of meeting a warm and supportive LGB community like you did, she was met with doctors and hormones and surgeries. She said in her evidence, “I made a brash decision as a teenager, (as a lot of teenagers do) trying to find confidence and happiness, except now the rest of my life will be negatively affected.” Her fertility may be affected; her appearance and her voice are permanently altered. She has to face the consequences of a decision that no child is competent to make. We have to win this for all the Keiras of the world. For all the girls like you and me who just need space and time, to find themselves, to find each other, as we did.

Ceri Black did her PhD in sociology, in which she used Butler, Derrida and Foucault to ‘problematize’ biological sex and other concepts. In her role as LGB Officer at university, she campaigned successfully to change the group from an LGB to an LGBT, against considerable opposition. She taught on undergraduate courses in postmodernism and poststructuralism. Her personal experiences led her to re-evaluate her pro-trans stance. She now is a gender-critical feminist, a lesbian, one of the founding members of the LGB Alliance Ireland. Her article in the Irish Independent was the first time a gender-critical Irish group ever had a right to reply in a national paper. Ceri is, and always has been, a passionate advocate for freedom of conscience, rationality and open debate.

 

Lauren Black is a professional photographer and wood worker. She was introduced to the gender-critical movement in Ireland (2019) when she was asked to talk and write about her perspective of gender ideology. Lauren is a butch lesbian who lives with dysphoria and does not believe that transition is the only, or even the best, option for people suffering from the condition. She campaigns weekly for Lesbian Visibility on Twitter under #MascGirlMondays and her motto is “Love the skin you are in.” Lauren is a founding member of the LGB Alliance Ireland.

1 A unicorn is a bisexual, feminine woman who is willing to have a no-strings-attached sexual relationship with both members of a heterosexual couple.