by Allie Rogers
When I was coming out, in the UK of the late 1980s, lesbian style tended towards the butch. Wherever lesbians gathered in number, you found yourself in a sea of cropped hair and Doc Martens. For me, this was an easy shift from largely boyish clothes in childhood—I slipped comfortably into the style that was mainstream in the sapphic spaces I inhabited and it’s a style I’ve hung on to ever since.
Jesus, I have spent so long agonizing over those first sentences of this piece of writing. The language of butch, as with the language of gender generally these days, is fraught with potential to offend. Where we stand in this thorny linguistic landscape, the words we are entitled to use, the words that are forbidden, seems to shift weekly, if not daily.
I could find you half a dozen lesbians who would roll their eyes at my using the label ‘butch’ for myself. Those women might suggest that I’m far too ‘soft’ in my style: no good at sports, not very physically strong, too comfortable being seen as a woman. Having birthed and breastfed a baby might raise eyebrows. They might even ask me about the women I’m attracted to and, when I confess to a terrain of attraction that includes butch women, rule me out on those grounds.
But I could find you half a dozen others who would casually apply it to me without a second thought. Do I ever wear skirts, dresses or makeup? No. Have I ever grown my hair longer than collar length in my adult life? No. And for those people that would be enough.
Some lesbians would take the question as a bit of amusing banter. They might declare me ‘futch’ — not butch and not femme. Others would be angered at such flippancy around terms that they respect very deeply. They might even scoff at the idea that butch is about clothes, hair and style at all, claiming it to be something deeply embedded in the body and the way of being in it.
So, do I use the label for myself? Yes, with varying levels of sincerity. Sometimes with a smirk — when I’ve just opened a jar or drilled a hole in the wall. Sometimes with anger — when I want to demand space for my life in a society that suggests there is no such thing as me. Sometimes with a shrug.
Anyway, the fact is that this crew-cut persona has been so comfortable that I have never much questioned it as a personal choice. I know that it distances me from much of what society associates with womanhood. I like that, since a lot of that stuff just looks like nonsense to me. I slip my eyes happily past the sea of pink, body-shaming, infantilizing, impoverishing propaganda that society sells to the female sex.
What does it mean, though? Really, what is butch? Start to question the concept and the field of enquiry bursts open, ranging from sexuality to politics, to contemporary lesbian culture and back into sapphic history. Here are just a few of the questions that arise.
Is butch inherently linked to lesbianism or can it include women of all sexual orientations? Is it specific to certain cultures and countries? If so, what is its relationship to its sister or sibling categories across the world?
Is it reactionary, anti-feminist, pandering to or even venerating gender stereotypes? Does butch require the existence of a femme woman as a contrast and mate? Do those roles imply differences between those women in the bedroom, in the home, in the world? If so, are those differences somehow akin to man and woman?
Are butch and femme a treasured link to the history of same-sex pairings at a time when they had no recognition in wider society? If so, do they have relevance in today’s world?
Is butch, in particular, a precious space right now, when many gender-non-conforming girls are feeling that such a life is not possible and they should better understand themselves as men?
Since I’m touching on transition, is butch woman a category that blurs into trans man, perhaps with non-binary in the middle there somewhere? Certainly, many butch women have transitioned in recent decades, and others have shifted to non-binary identities and they/them pronouns. What are the cultural issues around this idea of a spectrum? What are the political ones?
Is butch an in-born trait, perhaps visible from childhood in gender-non-conforming behaviour? Is such a suggestion a source of strength for butch women or an essentialist dead end?
Or, is butch simply a rational, feminist rejection of the painful and restrictive aspects of femininity, such as high heels, lingerie, make-up, and body-hair removal? Would we do best not to make too much of it?
In personal terms, my butchness can be hard to consider analytically, since it feels so natural to me. I experience it as a largely empowering aspect of myself, giving me a life made richer through the breaking of boundaries around appearance and behaviour. But without the existence of those boundaries, would it, could it, exist at all?
Underpinning the idea of butch is, of course, the idea of gender. In the feminist utopia of my dreams, gender will be dismantled. It will be recognized as part of patriarchy’s war against women and, indeed, the whole planet, and so discarded.
I hate it that human babies, lovely little mammals, inherit a big box of shit called gender that operates to sustain a hierarchical system that harms us all. As well as being a global mechanism that oppresses girls and women, gender works to undermine the wholeness of each person on the planet. Almost every aspect of human life is gendered, from our socks to our emotions. Gender falls like a net of limitations over the developing child, allowing some things and disallowing others. None of us can escape it.
For those of us who are same-sex attracted, there is an inevitable conflict with gender stereotypes, since one of the gender rules is that female people are only sexually attracted to male people and vice versa.
Lesbians break that rule and we know we do. We pay a price for the transgression, no matter where we live in the world, in terms of both social censure and male rage and violence directed towards us. How to make our lives in the shadow of those dangers has always been a challenge of lesbian life. I believe that, for many women, being butch is part of that ‘how to,’ albeit an often-unconscious part that we experience as instinctual.
One of the positive aspects of being butch is that it makes it easier to find other lesbians. On my first evening in the student union bar at Leeds Uni in 1989, I saw a woman in a leather jacket, with her hair styled in a red Mohican and a pint in her hand. I got closer and saw her boots, no make-up … A group of lads were just asking her, “Are you a lesbian?” as I got within earshot. I smiled at her and said, “Well, I am.” She smiled back (fantastic dimples, btw) and replied, “Thought you were.” There was my lesbian best mate for the next three years.
Of course, the downside of being visibly lesbian is that it attracts the attention of homophobes. Verbal abuse, physical attacks, and the need to defend against them have occasionally impacted my life in ways that have hurt me. The particular disdain men have sometimes directed my way has ranged from mockery to assault, always including words that made it clear that they knew what I was ‘underneath.’
But sometimes butch lesbian attire has literally been a disguise. I’ve passed through groups of drunk men harassing women, holding my breath as I realized that they were seeing a teenage boy, and hoping the misperception would last long enough for me to get away. I’ve walked at night, alone, careful to put my shoulders back, lengthen my stride, hoping that the rapist I was imagining in the shadows would misread me too.
As a young woman, the pride I felt in my style helped me navigate a world that often seemed intent on undermining my self-confidence. Boots and jeans didn’t make me a foot taller or give me broader shoulders, but they enabled me to move my body easily — to run, climb and take up space by spreading my legs or putting my feet up on chairs or tables. The right jacket, just butch enough, would give me the confidence to lift my chin at the bar, even if I was perched on the rail on my tiptoes.
As I write that, I’m aware that the whole business is a tangle of material, practical issues and symbols. It is a tightly knotted tangle. The clothes were comfortable and empowering because they were masculine. Men get clothes that enable them to use their bodies because patriarchy has allowed their bodies to be sovereign, purposeful and active. But the clothes made me feel more powerful not just because of these practical things. It was also because they were coded male. I felt that they entitled me to take more space, demand to be served at the bar, and so on.
But what does that imply? Is it, in some sense, capitulation to the assumption that men are entitled to these things and women are not? If I access my self-confidence through the prism of ‘male clothing’ is that a sign of internalized misogyny? Or is male clothing on my unapologetically female body a raid on the power stores of the patriarchy, enabling me to find my own strength as a woman?
These questions are part of my personal dance with the devil that is gender. As a feminist, I believe that devil has been working against my interests since I was in my cradle. As a butch lesbian, I take its tropes and symbols and subvert them, by claiming the masculine to empower my life as a woman.
From the age of 15 or so, I have lived in social space that is woman, but ‘woman slant’ (with apologies to Emily Dickinson). Here I am, as woman as any, but at first glance, perhaps not, at some angles, perhaps not — always pushing at the assumptions and limitations that gender imposes, and so, perhaps, revealing myself more fully than I otherwise might.
Being a butch lesbian has never been irrelevant in my life as a woman. Being a daughter and sister; how and where I have earned a living; my experiences of pregnancy, mothering and family; my relationship with my body and my experiences of sex: all have been coloured by it. As I approach old age, I feel its significance still, in both my horror at the prospect of a Crimplene dress in a nursing home one day and my determination not to let this ground be lost for the young women to come.
I love the butch lesbian space that I call my home. I love it. It has brought me power and delight, warmth, comfort and belonging. It has enabled me to survive the beast that is gender and feel myself to be largely whole. Yet it can only really be understood with reference to the structures, the categories, the symbols of gender itself. That’s something of a paradox—both challenging to the oppressive structure, and dependent on it.
At this moment in history, I think butch lesbian has plainly been my best bet. There is no way for any of us to avoid some sort of personal relationship with gender, since there is no way to live outside of this global, patriarchal system. I have characterized this relationship as a dance with the devil, a phrase that implies a certain reckless immorality. But the truth is that we simply must find our way along the path of life as best we can. Women can use only what is available to us where we find ourselves. To simply be intelligible to others, we have to employ the language, the signs and symbols, the meanings of our society.
In the world of my imagination, other lives are possible. When I sit in nature, I like to remind myself that I am just a mammal in a tree or beside a stream — just a human creature, the female version, alive for a moment on this planet. What I might have made of that existence in a world without gender, I can never really know. I can dream, I suppose. But, for now, I hold this tension, this reality, and I live it to the full in a space called butch lesbian woman.
Allie Rogers is a Brighton-based writer of novels and short fiction. Her first book, Little Gold, published by Legend Press in 2017, was longlisted for the Author’s Club Best First Novel Award and shortlisted for the Polari First Book Prize. Her second novel, Tale of a Tooth, was published by Legend Press in 2018. Allie’s short fiction has appeared in a number of anthologies and magazines, including Bare Fiction, Queer in Brighton and the Salt Anthology of New Writing. She tweets as @alliewhowrites.
