by SolAura
A culture that decides that it can do whatever it wants to a human body without any fear of consequence will inevitably devolve into transhumanism.
As a black woman raised outside of the context of whiteness, it took me the better part of 15 years living in the United States to figure out the cognitive schema underlying the bizarre mentality that is whiteness.
My confusion crystallized into complete clarity once I learned about the ‘uncanny valley’ theory of perception. In an instant, I was able to figure out why the network of associations within the white mind as it relates to black people exists as it does, and why they therefore act as they do.
For those who do not know what the uncanny valley theory is, here’s the graph:
In a nutshell, the uncanny valley refers to a strong feeling of revulsion one experiences when something which is supposed to be artificial starts to look increasingly real/life-like, and in particular, when a non-human object begins to resemble a human being. The negative feelings are a response to the person’s inability to resolve the cognitive dissonance created by what the brain perceives as a visual distortion.
In 2014, a study by the University of Virginia found that, between the ages of seven and ten, white children internalize the belief that black people experience less pain.1 This notion that black people experience less pain is a frighteningly common one that is held by both white and black Americans alike.2 What this study revealed is how incredibly early this belief is internalized by white children in particular, while previous studies with African American children, particularly the black doll/white doll test, have shown that black American children start to internalize negative beliefs about black people as early as four years of age.3
Being able to empathize with another human in pain is a key part of understanding that that person has a mind similar to one’s own, and a similar experience of the world to oneself. My claim here is that the white mind’s lack of empathic response to a black person in pain is an index of the failure to perceive a black person as properly human.4 Without the cognition of black people as really human, the normal subjectivity response (i.e. the empathic response) is replaced by the objectivity response. That is, the white mind perceives the black person not as a fellow subject, but as an object, and specifically, following the uncanny valley schema, as a humanoid robot. It’s crucial to remember here that the precursor to industrialization in the Americas was a slave-economy, based on the enslavement of Africans. Africans were not viewed as or treated as human beings, rather they were regarded as a kind of organic industrial humanoid robot.
Because of its central role in the founding of the United States, the cognitive schema of slavery is deeply embedded in American culture and consciousness. This is readily apparent in America’s toxic culture of overwork and lack of care, both of which emerge from the fact that the enslaved African is the prototype for the ‘hard worker’ under white supremacy, an idea mythologized in the legend of John Henry.5 This is manifested in the disproportionate power that employers continue to exercise over the lives of their employees, especially as reflected in the fact that healthcare for the majority of employees in the US is entirely dependent on their employer. This directly mirrors the historical reality that the welfare of enslaved Africans was entirely dependent on the will or ability of their owners to provide healthcare. Similarly, the lack of a living wage, paid sick leave, maternity leave, and the minimal vacation time that a large plurality of workers experience are also all artefacts of a work culture built on slavery. That the United States continues to be the only developed nation that lacks these basic guarantees for workers shows the extent to which the United States remains beholden to the uncanny perception of workers as essentially expendable, much as slaves were.
STEP ON: APPLY CONDITIONING LIBERALLY
The white mind’s loss of empathy for black pain is learned, as reflected by the fact that studies into racial bias in children show that younger children initially report believing that both black and white people feel equal pain.6 However, by the time they are ten years old, white children typically exhibit the adult white person’s depressed or absent empathic response and report that black people feel less pain.
This erasure of empathy for black people is the defining feature of the social conditioning into whiteness, and its trans identity: blackness.7
A trans identity, I have come to realize, is one that is defined not by its material existence, but by its opposition to a set of socially constructed stereotypes with which a dominant group most closely identifies.
Thus, trans identities are negative identities — they are defined not by what they are, but by what they are not.
For example, under patriarchy, the word ‘woman’ is a trans identity of men which means ‘not male.’ It does not mean ‘adult human female.’ This is why there are now attempts to assert that effeminate men who have ‘failed at masculinity’ are actually women since, having failed to live up to the patriarchal ideal of a man, they are insufficiently male.
Similarly, under white supremacy ‘black’ as an identity category (more properly ‘blackness’) simply means ‘not white(ness).’ It does not mean ‘people of African descent.’
Whiteness and blackness are constructed racial identities under white supremacy that are used to create and justify its existence. For the purpose of analysis, we can think of the conceptual centre of whiteness as being in the top right corner of the uncanny valley graph, approximately where ‘human’ is located. The conceptual centre of blackness, by contrast, is located at ‘humanoid robot.’ Note the diminished status of the humanoid robot in comparison to the human, as well as the literal gulf of empathy between them.
This makes perfect sense when we consider that black people were used largely as humanoid robots throughout the new world during the time of the slave trade. The savage treatment of black people — being worked to death, whipped raw, raped, and having their children and family members sold off — reinforces that black people were not regarded as having any humanity.
The irony of white people believing that black people had no humanity highlights a very important feature of trans identity construction by a dominant group — it always involves the projection of the most negative character traits of that group.
Indeed, while one might try to make the claim that black people were treated like animals, the reality is that the pets and farm animals of slave-owners were often treated with more compassion and concern than black people were, a reality which is still reflected today as many black people will ruefully note in private conversations among themselves.
It is necessary to make this distinction because, in contrast to the notion that black people were treated as subhuman, in reality they were treated as non-human. Moreover, the clear difference between the compassion and concern for animals versus the coldness and lack of concern for black people also indicates that the kind of non-human qualities ascribed to black people were closer to those of non-living objects than to those of living things. This distinction partially explains the kind of depraved inhumanity exhibited by white people’s violation of black people’s bodies.8 To the white mind, black humans are supposed to be either obedient humanoid robots, or dead bodies. As such, it is unable to assimilate into its perception-cognition schema the reality of a black person with full agency.
Such a being creates epistemic disequilibrium (i.e. cognitive dissonance) and ultimately revulsion in white minds that are fully conditioned by white supremacy. Should a black human create such disequilibrium by displaying ordinary humanity, the white mind will seek to restore equilibrium by diminishing and dismissing the black person, or demanding immediate robotic compliance to white authority. And, should non-compliance continue, the penalty is usually death or imprisonment.9
STEP TWO: BRAIN WASH, RINSE, REPEAT
The humanoid robot framing is particularly relevant at this historical moment because there are a substantial number of white men who continue to believe that human beings are simply machines, and that brains are simply computers. In fact, most of the white men who hold this belief are computer scientists and technologists who work in Silicon Valley, and a not insubstantial number of those people are also transhumanists.
As we continue to analyse the ideological foundations of transhumanism, it is important to note how this underlying belief that humans are simply machines is tied to the underlying cognitive schema of white supremacy. Indeed, transhumanists are essentially techno-supremacists. Where white supremacists believe that white people should be able to dominate non-white people, conceived as humanoid robots, techno-supremacists believe that human technology should dominate biology, conceived as a machine.
Given that almost all techno-supremacists are white men, transhumanism should be recognized as a form of white supremacy.
Before delving further into the connection between white supremacy and transhumanism, I want to take a little more time to examine the antecedents of this clearly false belief that bodies are machines and draw parallels with transgenderism, the political and ideological precursor to transhumanism, as laid out in Martine Rothblatt’s From Transgender to Transhuman: A Manifesto on the Freedom of Form (2011). This is relevant when one notes that there is a relatively high rate of transgenderism among technologists when compared to the rest of the population, a substantial number of whom identify as transhumanists.
STEP THREE: SEE STEP ONE
That humans are not machines, nor brains simply programmed computers, is fairly obvious to most people who have not been conditioned by white supremacy (and even most of those who have). It is also entirely obvious to anyone who actually understands science at a basic level. This leads to the first important point showing the connection between transgenderism and transhumanism, namely that both ideologies are anti-scientific.
Science is divided into two branches — the biological sciences and the physical sciences which include chemistry and physics. The two branches of science exist because the only precursor of a living thing is another living thing. This unique property of biological systems, namely the obligate heritability of life, is why biology has been given its own branch — we simply do not have the ability to generate a living organism from inorganic material.
While scientists have been able to synthesize some of the organic materials used in living systems, the engineering of an entire living creature from scratch which requires, among other things, the synthesis of nucleotides, building DNA, then enzymes to transcribe the DNA, then ribosomes to translate the RNA, and all with a fidelity that enables the genetic material to be passed on through the life cycle without catastrophic mutation is a task that is 100% beyond the capacity of humans, a fact which no amount of technology can change.
Indeed, the belief that this is possible indicates a lack of deep understanding of biology, and/or profound delusion.
Hmm … ignorance of biology combined with delusions … which other ideology does that sound like?
The simple fact is this:
The creation of heritable life from scratch is permanently beyond human capacity.
This is a scientific position, not a religious one.
Indeed, this basic scientific understanding is the very reason that two branches of science exist. But this assertion constitutes ‘fighting words’ to transhumanists, largely because they believe that 1) humans are the highest form of living consciousness, 2) only computers can be smarter
than humans, 3) a computer will have the capacity to create heritable life, and finally 4) humans can build the computer that can build heritable life.
This is, of course, complete nonsense.
But what is particularly appalling is that despite the fact that we are living on a dying planet and should be focused on actually saving it, these inverted theists (contrary to their own beliefs, they are not actually atheists) will not fail to invest the equivalent of trillions of dollars along with a perversely huge percent of the earth’s dwindling resources in order to try to make their vision of a ‘God-machine’ reality.
Though they will never accomplish their task, you should nevertheless expect that in the future (perhaps sooner than later) some lying-ass transhumanist will publish misleading research claiming that he built a living cell from scratch. Of course, what we will eventually learn is that multiple components of this allegedly engineered cell were actually lifted from a living organism and implanted into the man-made cell, but the scammers will go to great lengths to deny that this is so.
Despite the fact that there is literally zero chance that a man-made machine will create life from scratch, transhumanists are committed to the belief that this is possible. This leads to the second point about the similarities between transgenderism and transhumanism, namely that both exhibit a faith-based certainty that their unscientific claims are true.
The third point of similarity is that they both have a profoundly poor grasp of basic logic. This is reflected in the gross categorical error at the core of their respective world views, an error which when pointed out is simply ignored. In the case of transgenderism, it is the belief that some males are women. In transhumanism the categorical error is in identifying living things as machines.
Analogy is not equivalence. While an enzyme might be like a machine, it is not a machine.
Whereas machines are manufactured via external locus of control, living things develop via internal locus of control. Nothing that is alive is machined into existence.
While this is all woefully obvious, this unfortunately has not stopped self-appointed science communicators such as Neil DeGrasse Tyson from spouting confused nonsense like this: “A cow is a biological machine invented by humans to turn grass into steak.”
I’m frankly no longer surprised to see this kind of ridiculous statement coming from a physical scientist given that I have come to recognize that the entire field is riddled with arrogant men who are utterly ignorant about advanced biology, and yet, due to their own sexist casting of biology as a ‘soft’ science, have developed a chauvinistic attitude towards the field. As such, rather than correcting themselves when they misspeak, they instead double down on their nonsense and engender more confusion about science in an already woefully misinformed public.
I wouldn’t care if this was just some regular idiot spouting off on Twitter, but when one promotes oneself as a science communicator, it becomes one’s job to actually communicate science, not transhumanist ideology cum physical science chauvinistic bullshit.
That biology is actually the only science that requires a working knowledge of both branches of science (as well as high verbal fluency, the ability to retain vast stores of information due to the high volume of material, as well as a facility with the humanities and ethics due to the moral dimensions involved in engaging in the study of living systems) is apparently entirely lost on physical science chauvinists who need only know one subject (advanced math) to succeed in their field. But, because they are men, they believe that whatever they are better at must be the more difficult and important subject, despite all evidence to the contrary.
Male chauvinism/narcissism also accounts for why they believe that their narrow personal interests must become globally relevant. Indeed, what is perhaps most perverse about these male chauvinists is that they will recast the pursuit of their own personal interests as a global mission that will ‘save the world.’
Right now, there are oceans filled with plastics that are killing marine life and causing further disruption to an already collapsing ecosystem. Incidentally, there are also machines that can now convert plastic back into oil with an assist from pure water. Are any of the so-called ‘greatest minds of our age’ figuring out an autonomous seafaring plastic-collection system with a built-in desalinator to make the water to power the plastic-to-oil converter?
No.
They’re making robot receptionists.
If only these tech-obsessed sociopaths had the moral discernment and emotional intelligence to actually feel shame.
But, they can’t.
Shame is not in their programming.
In any event, this issue leads me to highlight a fourth point of congruence between transgenderism and transhumanism: both transgenderism and transhumanism are deeply misogynistic and chauvinistic ideologies born of misogynistic and chauvinistic intellectual cultures. I could elaborate beyond what I said above, but is there really anyone left on this planet who doesn’t know that ‘tech bros’ are sexist assholes?
STEP FOUR: SEE STEP TWO
Having identified just a few of the similarities between transgenderism and transhumanism, it is time to revisit the intersection of transhumanism with white supremacy. Both transhumanists and white supremacists express an outdated belief in biological determinism. White supremacists have a long history of using determinist arguments to ground their claims to racial superiority, while transhumanists have an entirely mechanistic understanding of living systems, which is necessarily then deterministic.10 This belief stems from a combination of ignorance of biology and an apparent inability to understand nuance. As such, to techno-supremacists, the fact that genetics ‘largely influences’ or ‘greatly influences’ a person’s behaviour is equivalent to saying that they determine or even dictate them.
This is, in a word, stupid.
Actually I need three words: extremely fucking stupid.
Because they are physical/computer science majors who only learned one subject, they apparently never developed the mental capacity required to attend to the complexity of interacting dynamic living systems. As such, they have interpreted their own lack of ability to analyse, attend to, or be influenced by this complex reality as evidence that it either does not exist, or is entirely irrelevant.
This is like a person who suffers from colour-blindness declaring that certain colours do not exist or are ‘irrelevant’ because he cannot see them.
Like I said: dumb. But even dumber than that is their construction of an argument that leads to the justification that the oppressed of the world must rise up against them:
“I wasn’t socialized into whiteness, I was born an amoral narcissistic kleptomaniacal violence-prone sociopath. I can’t help it.”
Oh yeah?! Cool story, bro!
STEP FIVE: REPEAT STEPS ONE TO FOUR
When one reflects on the gendered nature of the branches of science (i.e. biology being feminized as ‘soft’ and the physical sciences masculinized as ‘hard’), its context within a broader culture of sexism and misogyny, and its intersection with a white supremacist belief in the supremacy of man, specifically white men, along with a rigged capitalist system that has given a tiny percentage of white men disproportionate wealth and power, it suddenly becomes extremely apparent how a group of men living in a tiny ideological echo chamber are able to convince themselves that their pursuit of a science-fiction fantasy grounded in fundamental logical errors is actually really ‘science’ and a ‘human good’ and an ‘inevitable development’ as opposed to what it actually is — a few egomaniacs pursuing a self-serving agenda to create a world that aligns with their ill-conceived visions.
Contrary to how it is defined, transhumanism is not the teleological end of science. Rather, it is the ontological end of white male supremacist capitalism, and as such is an anti-science.
Thus, transhumanism is best understood as the religion that underlies the unwavering belief in white male supremacist capitalism.
Real science recognizes that technologies are to be used in service of human beings. An inverted anti-science believes that humans are to be used in the service of technology.
Sheldon Wolin, one of the greatest political theorists of the past century, was frighteningly prescient when he coined the term ‘Inverted Totalitarianism’ to describe the current form of American governance. But what he did not fully appreciate is that this form of governance is the outgrowth of a collective consciousness that is similarly inverted and totalitarian.
The incoherent logic, fanaticism, and fascism shown by advocates of transgenderism and transhumanism are nothing new in America — they are simply the most potent examples of the twisted ideologies born of a corrupted American psyche conditioned by white male supremacy.
As it turns out, engaging in horrific forms of violence and astonishing hypocrisy, and never reckoning with the damaging consequences of cultivating and indulging such base and immoral mindsets and behaviours, does not actually lead to anywhere good.
Shocking, I know.
But hey, never mind all this …
Carry on, you uncanny men of the Silicon Valley.
Build your robots.
I am quite sure they will save you.
1 Fariss Samarrai, ‘Study: Racial bias in pain perception appears among children as young as 7,’ UVA Today, 27 February 2014.
2 Sandhya Somashekhar, ‘The disturbing reason some African American patients may be undertreated for pain,’ Washington Post, 4 April 2016.
3 CNN Pilot Demonstration, 28 April 2010.
4 A ‘white mind’ is not equivalent to white people. I define a ‘white mind’ as ‘a mind conditioned by bias that believes that some humans feel less pain.’ As this discussion is explicitly about the perception and cognition that minds develop under white supremacy, I have called this a ‘white mind.’ It is important to note that people of any race can have such a mind.
5 The folk-story of John Henry, originally memorialized in blues, and subsequently the subject of plays, films, and novels, tells the tale of a 19th-century black American steel-driver whose job was to hammer metal rods into rock ready for explosives, in the process of making railway tunnels. One day, John Henry was pitted against a steam-powered drill that threatened worker’s livelihoods. Henry beat the drill, but, legend has it, then collapsed and died from the stress, hammer still in hand. The term ‘John Henryism’ now refers to the phenomenon of stress-related ill-health among African Americans as a result of structural labour inequality, but from the perspective of the humanoid-robot framing advanced here, the story should point us to the extent to which black labour is rendered machinic by the system of exploitation.
6 Rebecca A. Dore et al., ‘Children’s racial bias in perceptions of others’ pain,’ British Journal of Developmental Psychology, 32 (2014), 218-231, and also.
7 As I explain, ‘trans identity’ does not refer here to ‘transgender identity’ but to all identities that are created by negation from a dominant identity.
8 We could argue that within the uncanny cognitive schema of whiteness, the dismemberment, disembowelling or burning of black people’s bodies is as much an act of murder as it is the disassembly of a malfunctioning machine. Moreover, this notion that Africans were more robot than people gives another context for explaining how and why the white mind invented the alleged mental illness of ‘drapetomania’ to explain why slaves ran away. Robots do not exercise free will; they simply malfunction.
9 Sandra Bland’s violent interaction with law enforcement over a minor traffic violation is one of many vivid examples of this. The man who murdered Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo. believed he had to kill him because Michael was getting ready to turn around and run through a hail of gun fire. If you viscerally understand that Mike Brown is a human being, such a belief is patently absurd. If on the other hand you unconsciously believe that Mike Brown is actually some kind of robot, such actions make perfect sense.
10 The central thought of transhumanism is that life is fully explicable as nothing but an extremely complex machine, and that consciousness is fully explicable as computation. Hence, their project relies on the thought that a sufficiently complex machine or computer will, at some point, become conscious and develop free will. Given that we presently have no adequate understanding of what consciousness is and how it emerges, such a belief is, let’s say, naïve at best, and full of hubris at worst.
