Issue Two

Both/And: Gender

by Jane Clare Jones

There is probably no word in English currently as contested, and as mired in confusion and conflation, as ‘gender.’ As Lucy Tatman suggests in this issue, the term has evolved from its origin in linguistics to be used, variously, as:

 

  1. a) A polite euphemism for sex (Thanks American puritanism!)
  2. b) To denote the ‘masculinity’ or ‘femininity’ of an individual, often taken as a natural property of their being
  3. c) To describe the hierarchical system of sex-roles, values and status which subordinates women, that is, as the mechanism of patriarchy
  4. d) As a social identity constituted through repetitive performance of stylized gendered acts or behaviours, which, notably, is also taken to constitute sex, and
  5. e) As an inner, innate identity, which probably has something to do with sexed brains, or gendered souls, or something (‘it’s science!’), and which is taken to determine whether someone should be considered male, female, or, maddeningly, neither.

 

It would take several volumes to make a decent stab at disentangling this unmitigated mess. My more modest aim here is to begin thinking through how we should best understand the interaction of nature and culture in radical feminist, gender-critical, or gender-abolitionist accounts, and start unpacking how that differs from, on the one hand, conservative notions of gender and, on the other, trans-ideological accounts.

 

Gender: nature vs culture?

 

Traditional or conservative accounts of gender—which existed long before gender was even a concept—consist of the view that males are masculine and do masculine things and females are feminine and do feminine things. They do these things, because that’s how God and/or Nature made them, and it follows, ‘naturally,’ therefore, that if men do feminine things and women do masculine things, something unnatural, unholy and quite possibly sinful is going on. While this is, from a traditional feminist perspective, usually regarded as a conservative account, it is probably fair to say that, when they are not using it as an awkward euphemism for sex, most people’s concept of gender comes down to some general thought of male = masculine, and female = feminine, and that under the aegis of unstoppable capitalist ‘pinkification,’ this is probably far more true now than it was in the 70s and 80s, when at least some people seemed to grasp what feminists might be on about.

 

Because of the alleged givenness of the equations male = masculine/female = feminine, when feminists came to challenge this system, and implicate it in the subordination of women, they addressed themselves directly to the question of whether gender was ‘natural.’ “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman,” wrote Beauvoir famously, followed immediately by “No biological, psychological, or economic fate determines the figure that the human female [Note!] presents in society.” In her foundational analysis of the Sexual Politics of male dominance, Kate Millett partitions gender into ‘temperament, role and status,’ and likewise maintains that “it must be admitted that many of the generally understood distinctions between the sexes in … role and temperament, not to mention status, have in fact, essentially cultural, rather than biological, bases.” “New research,” she continues, “suggests that the possibilities of innate temperamental differences seem more remote than ever” and “gives fairly concrete positive evidence of the overwhelmingly cultural character of gender, i.e. personality structure in terms of sexual category” (p. 29). And thus, the analysis of the ‘social construction of gender’ was born, and, back when words still meant what they meant, ‘biological determinism’ and ‘essentialism’ became the cardinal feminist sins.

 

The problem with all this, of course, is that it seems to commit the analysis of male dominance to ‘blank slatism,’ that is, to the denial that humans have innate temperamental dispositions (if not full personalities), and more specifically, the denial that some of those temperamental dispositions might have something to do with sex. Given that anyone who has met a human infant for more than five minutes will testify that they blatantly have at least rudimentary personalities, this is all a bit implausible. This is made more implausible still given that we know that males and females have different ratios of sex hormones, that hormones are chemicals, and that human consciousness is manifestly impacted by certain types of chemicals, of which hormones are one group. The very existence of ‘organic psychoactive chemicals’ then points us to a further problem, one already recognized by the feminist analysis of patriarchal metaphysical dualism. That analysis commits us, correctly I think, to denying the neat, hierarchical bifurcation of mind from body, and of culture from nature, which would then seem to scupper—and much contemporary ‘feminism’ has run with this, mostly in the wrong direction (Hi Judy!)—the sex/gender distinction, on which the ‘social construction of gender’ argument rests. This is all then, to use a technical phrase, a fucking mess.

 

To unpick this mess, I want to stop and do a bit of metaphysics, of the type that basically inspired the thought for ‘Both/And’ as a regular feature. The human intellect is spatializing, which makes sense, seeing as it first developed to help us recognize spatial objects and navigate through space. What this means, however, is that we have an annoying, and distorting, tendency, to view concepts like they are solid objects … and the pertinent property of solid objects here is that they can’t be both one thing, and another thing, at the same time. Hence, when we come to think about a concept like ‘gender,’ we tend to think it must be either all one thing, or all another thing: in this case, that it must be either all nature, or all culture. Which is, um, stupid.

 

To flesh this out a bit, let’s look at the various different levels of the gender system in the table overleaf. The first thing to note is that the apparently ‘simple’ equations male = masculine/female = feminine are not actually so simple at all. The traditional or conservative view includes the thought that certain gendered characteristics arise ‘naturally’ in each sex (Level 1), plus the thought that those characteristics are proper to each sex (Level 2). It also includes, usually, the thought that the social roles of each sex just arise naturally directly from the characteristics (Level 5) as does the distribution of status, power and value (Level 6 and 7), and tends to skip neatly over, and dismiss as irrelevant, the entirety of socialization (Level 3 and 4).

Masculine

Feminine
1. Sex-role stereotypes: The distribution of characteristics coded as ‘masculine’ and ‘feminine.’ Including:

Active/Subject

Passive/Object
a) Personality traits, tastes, preferences

Active, aggressive, dominant, object-oriented, rational, adventurous, strong, competitive, stoic, independent, etc.

Passive, agreeable, kind, sweet, people-oriented, nurturing, emotional, social, domestic, weak, talkative, etc.
b) Acceptable/unacceptable emotions

Acceptable: Aggression, anger, competitiveness, bravery, stoicism. Invulnerability.

Unacceptable: Most emotions, especially fear, sadness, anything ‘weak’ or ‘soft.’

Acceptable: Most emotions, providing not excessive. Vulnerability.

Unacceptable: Aggression, rage, defiance, failure to ‘be kind.’ Anything ‘hard.’

c) Behaviours congruent with traits/emotions Rough physical activity, competitive sport, fighting, adventures, heroic quests, exploration, technical skill and mastery. Passivity and compliance, domestic and nurturing activity, attracted to ‘prettiness,’ concern with self-presentation.
d) Aesthetic preferences and presentation Not unduly concerned with self-presentation. Clothes are generally utilitarian and designed to facilitate movement and activity. Preoccupied with self-presentation. Clothes are elaborate and designed to accentuate attractiveness. Often compromise movement and activity.
e) Bodily comportment and vocal presentation Occupy and often ‘spread out’ into space. Move body as locus of agency and mastery. Direct assertive speech and eye contact. Fold body up in order to minimize occupation of space. Do not fully use body to express agency. Speech and eye-contact expected to be hesitant/deferential.
2. The belief that characteristics coded as ‘masculine’ and ‘feminine’ are proper to males and female respectively. Inversely, the belief that gender non-conformity—that is ‘femininity’ in males and ‘masculinity’ in women—is aberrant and wrong. This is a social norm. This norm leads to:
3. The process of socialization through which proper gendered characteristics are inculcated in males and females. Achieved through ‘gender policing,’ i.e. punishing and rewarding in/correct traits and behaviours, funnelling individuals into correct gendered activities, and the massive cultural edifice of gendered coding, which begins with children’s clothes and toys etc., runs through sex-roles, and extends right up to the hierarchy of metaphysical values.

‘Boys don’t cry.’

‘Man up.’

‘Don’t be a sissy.’

‘What a big strong boy you are.’

‘This one is going to be a charmer.’

All gendered coding of toys, clothes, activities etc. which reinforce that active, adventurous masculine traits are good and proper to boys.

‘That’s not ladylike.’

‘Aren’t you pretty?’

‘Smile!’

‘You went and got yourself all dirty!’

All gendered coding of toys, clothes, activities etc which reinforce that domestic activity and passive prettiness, unicorns and sparkles are good and proper to girls.

4. Males are thus socialized to be active assertive subjects, who prize their strength and invulnerability, while females are socialized to see themselves as passive/attractive objects and oriented to nurturing or serving the needs of others. Male socialization revolves around the performance of invulnerability and the experience, and developing expectation, of service by females, especially around men’s material and dependency needs (physical, emotional, and sexual). This allows men to maintain the illusion of invulnerable in-dependence from material need, and fosters entitlement and aggrieved entitlement when thwarted by female non-compliance. What I would call ‘the deep structure of patriarchal gender’ turns on this psychological mechanism, viz. the inculcation of females into service, and the concomitant inculcation of entitlement in males.
5. The distribution of appropriate social roles justified and enforced through gendered norms and socialization (1-4) Men traditionally occupy high status public and professional roles, as well as most roles which require manual or technical labour. Women traditionally occupy private or domestic roles, or public roles in caring or service-based labour.
6. The hierarchical distribution of wealth, social status and power, in accordance with these roles. Males have traditionally been the property-owning class. The vast majority of wealth and social power is still accumulated in the hands of males, and they still occupy the majority of high-status/paid roles. Females were traditionally barred from owning property. Women still do far more unpaid domestic labour than men, and disproportionately occupy low-status/paid roles. When an area of labour is ‘feminized,’ its status and remuneration decrease.
7. The hierarchical distribution of value to all gendered characteristics up to and including cultural and metaphysical polarities. Activity, strength, invulnerability, independence, solid, hardness, rationality, mind, culture, ideality, immateriality, universality, singularity, eternity, transcendence, sky/sun, light, civilized, white. Passivity, weakness, vulnerability, dependence, penetrable, softness, emotion, body, nature, sensibility, materiality, particularity, plurality, change, immanence, earth, dark, primitive, black.

 

There are several things to unpack here. Firstly, contra Millett, it may well be the case that some of the conventionally gendered personality traits, or temperaments, are very loosely distributed by sex (Feminist thought crime!). I am, for example, prepared to accept the suggestion, say, that female humans have a tendency to be more relational, linguistic, and person-oriented, and male humans have a tendency to be more spatializing, mechanistic and object-oriented. Something like this would account for some, but not all, of the characteristics subdivided under the first level of our table. It does not explain, for example, why ‘acceptable emotions’ should be sexed, why female people should be thought as passive, or why male humans and not female humans get garments with adequate pockets. It is, however, I think, important to accept that there might be some natural distribution of personality traits, and that this might have something to do with organic factors, such as hormones in utero. 

 

The first reason to accept this is that it’s good intellectual practice to have the most robust and accurate model that you can. And this is especially important right now, when we find ourselves facing down a tsunami of absolute bullshit. Secondly, many of the arguments we are currently making about the dangers of medicalizing gender non-conforming children more-or-less tacitly accept, because it is empirically the case, that gender non-conformity in children is importantly correlated with adult homosexuality. That there is a reliable association between gender non-conformity and homosexuality, that this persists from childhood into adulthood, and that it persists in spite of social conditioning to the contrary, suggests to me that to some degree or other, humans do have ‘gendered’ personality traits. The fact that the phrases ‘feminine man’ and ‘butch woman’ mean something, and often mean something with respect to physicality, as well as personality, further suggests that there is something going on here not reducible to socialization.

 

From a conservative perspective, this would be game over—viz. ‘gender is natural’—but this is way too fast. By our table, the idea that gendered personality traits might be naturally distributed is only the first level, and the thinnest conception, of what ‘gender’ is. The second level, the thought that such traits are proper to each sex, and the system of socialization that inculcates, polices and reinforces that thought of ‘what is proper,’ is by no means ‘natural.’ Social norms about what traits or behaviours are proper to each sex are, by definition, just that, social norms. Moreover, the argument from the association between gender non-conformity and homosexuality I used above to suggest that we should accept that ‘gendered’ personality traits might be natural suggests that it is also evidently natural for those traits to be distributed in the putatively ‘wrong’ sex. If there are gendered personality traits, they are distributed between the sexes in an extremely loose, overlapping, bimodal type-way, and the vast majority of humans have a fairly good distribution of both types of gendered traits. That is, there is nothing ‘natural’ about the idea that certain gendered traits are only proper to a particular sex, or that the distribution of those traits needs to be socially policed.

 

The alleged properness of gendered traits—the thought we often express by referring to gender as ‘boxes’—and the associated mechanism of socializing people into those boxes and punishing them when they digress, is far more key to the core mechanism of ‘what gender is’ than the thought that humans might have natural personality traits, which is, in fact, evident. What this clarifies, I hope, is that commitment to ‘gender abolitionism’ does not then necessitate an untenable commitment to ‘blank slatism.’ The problem is not that humans have personalities, but that the natural distribution of those personalities means that most of them, to greater or lesser degrees, do not fit neatly into the gendered boxes, because the boxes—the thought that certain traits are proper only to one sex—are a bullshit social norm, and one that serves social and political purposes. ‘Gender abolition’ is not, therefore, a wilful, ideologically naïve demand that humans erase their personalities or some such nonsense, but the demand that those personalities are allowed to develop free from gendered normativity.

 

The other important reason for framing things this way is that it proofs the feminist analysis of male dominance against the endless efforts by conservatives to dismiss it by pointing at human personality traits and screaming, ‘they’re natural.’ They are, to some degree. What is emphatically not natural is thinking they are only, and must be, proper to each sex, and the entire structure of socialization and policing that props that up. If indeed the distribution of personality traits fell as neatly into their boxes as the conservative thought says they should, then the entire mechanism of socialization would be redundant, which it evidently is not. The function of socialization remains to reinforce the boxes, and, as feminism claims, to serve the social and political purposes of amplifying male activity/dominance and female passivity/compliance. 

 

Moreover, fundamental aspects of these boxes, particularly the image of patriarchal masculinity as a form of stoic invulnerability, manifestly fly in the face of ‘nature.’ Male humans are animals, and animals are not invulnerable. The action of testosterone might make male animals more inclined to engage in risky behaviour, but it does nothing to protect them from being harmed by such actions. Nor does testosterone protect males from loss, grief, depression, need, dependence, or any of the manifold human experiences and emotions that patriarchal masculinity codes as ‘weakness.’ ‘Patriarchal masculinity’ turns centrally on this denial of human vulnerability, which is impossible to incarnate, and is centrally implicated, for example, in the higher suicide rates of men.

 

The function of patriarchal invulnerability is that it reinforces male dominance. Most obviously by encoding tough guy machismo, but more profoundly, by making it difficult for men to negotiate the vulnerability of their needs in an ethical way. Tough guys take what they want and expect to get their own way. And they are acculturated to it by being raised in a society where, from boyhood, they get used to women bending the world around them, picking up after them, washing their socks, and giving them what they want. Conversely, girls are frequently punished for asserting their needs or opinions and expecting them to be met or listened to. There is no specifically masculine equivalent of the tendency to malign ‘spoilt’ or ‘demanding’ girls as a ‘Princess’ or ‘Little Madam.’ There is no reason on earth why male humans should be ‘naturally’ over-entitled, and female humans ‘naturally’ inclined to entirely subordinate their needs to serving the needs of males. And there would be little need for the panoply of discipline and shame brought down on women when they fail to fulfil their sweet, compliant, service function, if women came as ‘natural’ support humans simply by dint of being female.

 

This matrix of entitlement and service constitutes what I think of as the ‘deep structure of gender,’ and it is by no means all natural. By contrast, much of what is taken to be the substance of gender, by both conservative and queer accounts, is relatively thin or superficial, especially insofar as it focuses on the performance of aesthetic masculinity or femininity. We are by now all familiar with arguing with the same old entitled mansplaining dude who thinks he’s queer because he’s wearing black nail polish. This theoretical superficiality, along with the tendency to focus on gender as a property of the individual, rather than on the structural power it supports and maintains, allies queer and trans-ideological thinking more closely with conservative accounts than with feminism. Like conservative accounts, trans ideology also, fundamentally, accepts the equations male = masculine/female = feminine, but has simply reversed the direction of causality. Where conservatism thinks males should be masculine, and females should be feminine, trans ideology thinks masculine people should be male, feminine people should be female, and that people who are kind of both, which most people are, are neither male nor female, that is, insanely, don’t have a sex at all. All this does is reify the ‘boxes,’ shorn of any grasp of their social and political functions, or why they even exist at all, other than a gratuitously naïve, and fundamentally quiescent, belief that they arise directly from people’s innate natural gender, and that the only injustice in them is that some male people don’t get to hang out in the ‘woman’ box and vice versa. There is nothing, we’re told, inherently harmful about male entitlement or machismo or dominance, or women being made passive, pretty, and complaint. It’s ‘natural.’ And any female person who doesn’t repudiate ‘being a woman’ must be a-okay with it.

 

So much for ‘smash the patriarchy.’ 

 

I think I’ll stick to smashing boxes.

 

1 Simone de Beauvoir, The Second Sex, trans. by H. M. Parshley (Middlesex: Penguin Modern Classics, 1983), p. 295.

2 Kate Millett, Sexual Politics (New York: Columbia University Press, 1969), p. 28.

3 It is this type of spatializing either/or thinking, which explains why we are also extremely bad at thinking the relation between binary poles. We tend to flip-flop between poles, ‘either it’s nature, or it’s culture, or it’s nature, or it’s culture!’ When we work out that this is stupid, rather than then thinking it is probably both nature and culture, we then often decide, because we can’t draw a clean line between them (as we could if they were spatial objects), that the poles therefore don’t exist and they should be completely collapsed into each other, which, by erasing the existence of one pole, then just reinstates the hierarchy. This is also stupid. It is in fact exactly the type of stupid that leads Judith Butler to collapse sex into gender in Gender Trouble, proclaim everything is ‘discourse all the way down,’ and destroy the sex/gender distinction because that’s going to work out great for everyone thanks. This is how the misconceptions around ‘deconstructing binaries’—which should lead to understanding that it’s both body and mind, nature and culture, matter and idea—have actually resulted in the reinstatement of the patriarchal hierarchy of mind/culture/idea over body/nature/matter.