by Erin Becker
“My friend Adele describes fundamentalism as holding so tightly to your beliefs that your fingernails leave imprints on the palm of your hand. And I think she’s right. I was a fundamentalist not because of the beliefs I held but because of how I held them: with a death grip.“1
So writes the (heartbreakingly) late, great, Rachel Held Evans in her memoir Faith Unraveled. Despite living her whole life in Dayton, Tennessee — notable as the town where a high-school teacher was once prosecuted for teaching evolution (the Scopes trial) — she became a thorn in the side of many evangelical Christian institutions in the United States. Starting with a blog in 2007, where she began by simply writing out her thoughts and asking questions that were typically forbidden in her Christian subculture, she became more confident in her own analysis over time, and eventually the big-name men in the movement knew they couldn’t opine about ‘men and women’s natural roles’ without getting some kind of response — often in 2000+ word essays — from her own blog. Like Evans, I grew up in this evangelical/fundamentalist Christian subculture, and while both of us were probably much closer to the evangelical side of things, there’s often an especially blurry line separating the two ‘factions.’ As Evans discusses, the line of thought is the same: “The problem with fundamentalism is that it can’t adapt to change. When you count each one of your beliefs as absolutely essential, change is never an option.”
Beyond the problems of the rigid mindset, there were a variety of more concrete harms for female people in the subculture. Influential organizations with names like Vision Forum, Above Rubies, and No Greater Joy vigorously promoted the view that the only place for women was in the home, and they spearheaded a stay-at-home-daughter movement, which pushed for young women to stay home after completing secondary education and hone their homemaking skills for their future families. Husbands were to be found through a ‘modern courtship’ process, which consisted of ensuring that the prospective couple never spent any time alone, while simultaneously and strongly characterizing any result other than marriage as a ‘failure’ which would result in a reduction of the woman’s — the more defensively egalitarian publications would also add the man’s — purity.
For married women, there were numerous exhortations not to ‘withhold intimacy’ (sex), as well as doubt shed on the morality of birth control. The more extreme organizations (which later came to be labeled ‘quiverfull,’ mostly by outsiders) were explicitly against all birth control, and would often cite Psalm 127:4-5 from the Bible: “Like arrows in the hand of a warrior, so are children born in one’s youth. Blessed is the man whose quiver is full of them.” The various organizations with the above cluster of views could be all the more influential because the families in this subculture largely homeschooled their children (my family was no exception), and so the media environment was even easier to control. This was evidenced by the fact that, when I graduated from high school, I was the only girl in my homeschool cohort who wasn’t taking this stay-at-home-daughter path.
Although the announcement of my plans to attend college and my career dreams did raise eyebrows in my community, it wasn’t an act of rebellion in my immediate family. My peer group and their parents were very much in this tight media bubble, but my own parents were not well-connected in the community and were seen more like outsiders, and so more distant from it (far more than I was—I wanted friends and I wanted to belong!). Their expectations for my own education were never revised to remove higher education from the table, unlike those of many of their friends.
My high school years were filled with much of the usual angst, and I had the hatred or alienation for my body that J. K. Rowling described as the “sexualised scrutiny and judgement that sets so many girls to war against their bodies” in her ‘TERF wars’ essay. As a child it was possible to imagine I could do anything, but puberty reminded me I was on the ‘woman track,’ with all the limitations my subculture assured me were good and right. Who wouldn’t want to be a man when that meant freedom? I spent a lot of my time on the internet, which provided plenty of fodder for the questions of what I should be doing versus what I wanted to do. My biggest obsession was with reading the Christian patriarchy publications put out by the aforementioned organizations, which had an active online presence. I didn’t want them to be correct, as I had academic ambitions, but I was terrified they were. Young women also joined the blogging scene to enthusiastically promote being stay-at-home-daughters, and forums for true-believing homeschoolers flourished. Ultimately, I was just grateful that my parents expected me to go to college — I went to a Christian liberal arts school both as a path of least resistance and as a hope to keep the faith. If you’d asked me then about my subculture, I would have said, “It’s fine! It’s all fine!”
College brought plenty more questions for me, but also more confidence as I became more skilled in analysis. The evolving dynamics on the internet affected my questions too. While the first movers in the homeschooled community had been Christian patriarchy organizations, other women who’d grown up in the community but were critical of it were now creating their own blogs, building platforms, and speaking up. With names like Defeating the Dragons, Love Joy Feminism, and Becoming Worldly, which were often plays on things we were taught (such as the ‘fruit of the spirit’ or the use of ‘worldly’ as a pejorative label), these women were documenting their evolutions online. Sometimes it would be something seemingly mundane such as buying a pair of pants (too unfeminine by the community standards). Sometimes it would be long treatises to ever-so-gently push back against the idea of there being an essential ‘male’ personality and an essential ‘female’ personality. Surely we reinvented the feminist wheel many times in the comment sections — Mary Daly would never have shown up our syllabi — but it was liberating. The women who began these blogs had wit, curiosity, and sometimes righteous anger.
This activity exploded in the early 2010s — during the last two years of college for me (at least that’s when I noticed it), and I couldn’t look away. I personally knew many women like these bloggers, and even though I was in college, I was still full of my own questions of whether I was wrong to be there. I watched them as they struggled to go out on their own — challenged by educational neglect or not having the skill sets to find work. I watched them as they fled abusive marriages that they’d been rushed into. I watched them struggle to make it as they’d already had four-plus children before they’d been given time to figure out that they were people too. And when they got angry, I got angry too. I realized my instincts weren’t wrong, that our community indeed wasn’t treating women as the full human beings we were, and I could say so.
I started talking with my friends at my Christian college about feminism, and then, when I went to grad school, I didn’t stop. Reading these proto-feminist ex-homeschool blogs paved the way to reading mainstream feminist publications, such as Feministing, The Mary Sue, and The Toast, and I found so much liberation in them. Male and female brains aren’t a thing! ‘Acting like a woman’ is however I decide to act! ‘Women’s clothes’ are whatever I decide to wear! I learned about the sex/gender distinction and how gender was bullshit. In the comment sections of these mainstream blogs and publications I found so many other women from mainstream American culture who were equally chafed at the prescribed roles put on them. As a woman in a STEM field, it became obvious to me that even in the mainstream, ‘free’ world there were still distinct expectations on the work men as opposed to women were expected to do, again a result of gender norms imposed on us according to our sex. So I appreciated the work feminist publications were doing to point out and analyse gender in the world—with no cultural aspect too trivial to examine.
One thing I avoided, however, was ever putting my feminist evolution in writing under my real name. The costs would be too high. I had dreams of one day teaching at a Christian liberal arts college, and I watched heterodox thinkers lose their jobs over the most minor internet infractions. A woman who was fired for showing solidarity with Muslim women, a man who was pushed out for holding alternative (as in closer to the scientific consensus) views of the earth’s origins, another man who was fired for converting to Catholicism. Tenure meant nothing. The blogs were dying and Facebook and Twitter were becoming ascendant, and the eyes of these institutions were focused on our every move. I also didn’t want to be alienated from my family. So, I gestured ever so slightly to more feminist ways of thinking, and created a private no-follower Twitter account to ‘throw stuff into the void.’ It felt marginally better than never writing anything out at all.
For a while it felt like I had a new intellectual home, but as readers here know, the feminist statements I listed above are not really representative any longer of the current internet feminist consensus. I saw it first in awkward headlines of, “Stop saying women are half the population,” from the website Everyday Feminism, and later in the blogs of my ex-homeschooled feminist heroes as they championed the idea of having a ‘female brain in a male body’ (or vice-versa) and started promoting BDSM and all ‘choice’ as being feminist. Surely we knew firsthand that things we once thought were ‘our choices’ were actually bounded by our communities! Somehow the feminism I was reading started feeling less and less liberating. The fundamentalist framework of my childhood had long ceased to be a useful way of making sense of the world, and now it seemed like the same was proving true for the framework of the ex-homeschooled feminist space. I watched women being shouted down when they said their female bodies weren’t a privilege. These women were wrong — they were supremely cis-privileged. A group of homeschooled women even tried to form a group called the Magdalene Collective to help out ‘AFAB people’ in finding their voices after leaving the community, but it was shut down within days of forming for being a hopelessly bigoted concept.
The puzzle of feminists promoting anti-feminist gender theories rattled around my brain as a constant background noise until I discovered gender-critical feminists and radical feminists online. The Sheila Jeffreys quote (from Gender Hurts) at the top of the r/GenderCritical Reddit forum gave me chills: “Women do not decide at some point in adulthood that they would like other people to understand them to be women, because being a woman is not an ‘identity.’ […] The idea of ‘gender identity’ disappears biology and all the experiences that those with female biology have of being reared in a caste system based on sex.” Here was the theory that was consistent with what we young homeschooled girls experienced! Here was the theory that correctly diagnosed the problem — our oppression wasn’t a reaction to any ‘feminine’ behaviour or natural inclination of ours (that concept always repulsed me), it was a reaction to our existence as female people! This was the understanding that the ex-homeschooled proto-feminist blogs once had. To echo Evans from before, holding too rigidly to a particular framework can lead to incuriosity and a fear of thinking critically. For this reason, I will always try to avoid adhering too rigidly to any framework, and any feelings of absolute certainty are long gone. But it’s freeing to be able to continue to ask questions and put out my own ideas, facilitated by new spaces such as Ovarit and Spinster. Gender-critical feminism would not be able to work as a cult, as much as Pink News wants the world to view it that way. The reality is it flourishes best in spaces where women can speak with each other freely. It thrives when all sorts of our ideas can be freely discussed without fear of cancellation. Even when I may disagree with a particular viewpoint, I value these authentic female voices more than ever.
I’m still in academia, and the irony is that while my dreams no longer involve ending up teaching at a Christian college, I’m still not able to voice my opinions online. It’s a bit of a same old, same old situation because it turns out mainstream institutions don’t like heterodox opinions any more than Christian institutions do. The parallels are unavoidable for me: for example, questioning ‘trans women are women’ would put me in the dangerous-person box at my current institution just as much as questioning ‘the Bible is inerrant’ would at an evangelical institution. And in both cases it would be vitally important to use those precise words ‘women’ and ‘inerrant’ to describe ‘trans women’ and ‘the Bible,’ respectively — no substitutes possible. Similarly, avoiding gender-based pronouns now could get me in just as much trouble as ‘misgendering’ God would have then (Evans herself got angry mail for years after writing a single blog post that referred to God as “she” in the very last sentence).
After J. K. Rowling was smeared over and over again by one American publication after another, I took to my private Twitter feed to vent once again. While reading over my angsty posts from years before, where I vented the changes I had wanted then but was unable to publish lest I be cancelled by Christian institutions, I see that it’s come full circle, and while I’ve lost one religion after another, I’ve gained a lot of sisterhood at each stage.
Rachel Held Evans died tragically young at age 37, but her words against fundamentalism mean more to me now than when I first read them as college student. One of the things she would say repeatedly on her blog, in posts on all sorts of issues, was “you’re not alone.” Her posts would field comment sections full of confessions like “I took a biology class and was convinced that the theory of evolution was sound,” “I’m tired of fighting the culture wars,” “I couldn’t live with the thought of all non-Christians going to hell,” and always part of her answer was “you’re not alone.” In a community with so much that wasn’t allowed to be said, those words were such balm to the questioning. Before the analysis could even start, just the feeling that one wouldn’t be unpersoned for thinking the wrong thoughts was such a relief. It broke the spell and it brought lots of tears. And that’s where I find myself now: continuing on Rachel Held Evans’s legacy by saying ‘you’re not alone’ to any woman questioning this current form of gender fundamentalism.
Erin Becker is a researcher in a computational field of science. She’s using a pseudonym, just as many of those pioneering ex-homeschooled female bloggers once did.
1 Rachel Held Evans, Faith Unraveled: How a Girl Who Knew All the Answers Learned to Ask Questions (Zondervan: New York, 2014, Kindle Edition), p. 18
