Issue Two

A Just and Appropriate Sentence

by Sibyl Ruth

IN MEMORY OF NATALIE CONNOLLY1

Content note: graphic descriptions of sexual violence

INTRODUCTION

1.

A lovely girl, Natalie.

She was a free spirit, full of fun,
free to make her own choices,
loving, bubbly Natalie.

She had been in a relationship with you for a few months.

A much-loved mother, sister and daughter,
she was just 26.

There had been times in her life when Natalie had struggled.
She was happy.
She was happy when she was drunk.

You and Natalie
drank more or less continuously.

 

THE FACTUAL BACKGROUND

2.

I have heard you are a wealthy man.
You are a successful businessman.

I have heard you were getting on well.
You were able to buy Natalie a car
and support her financially.

I have heard you and Natalie were happy
apart from the stresses and strains that happen
in nearly all relationships.

I have heard this could cause Natalie to become bruised.
Most weeks she’d have bruises.

 

3.

As a stimulant
you beat her on the bottom.
You struck her on the breasts.

Natalie suffered.

You struck her on the breasts.
You beat her on the bottom
as a stimulant.

Natalie suffered at your hands.

 

4.

She was now very drunk indeed.
She was in a dangerous situation.
She was effectively naked.
She was incapable of standing up properly.
She was at very high risk.
She had fallen over at the foot of the stairs.
She had ceased being able to speak coherently.
She was in a highly intoxicated state.
She had multiple injuries

Her need for help was obvious.

 

5.

You went to get a bottle,
a bottle of spray carpet cleaner.

A woman may lawfully consent
to having something inserted into her vagina.

A large bottle with a trigger.
The use of the bottle was not unlawful.
The bottle caused lacerations.
It became lodged.

You could not get it out.
You went to get lubricant.

It gave you time to think and work out what do to.
It seems to me that this act was not unlawful.

You proceeded to remove the bottle,
breaking it in the process.
You did not summon assistance or call an ambulance.
You left her.

 

6.

Stupor:
symptoms; apathy; general inertia; approaching paralysis;
inability to stand or walk.

There was blood.
There was thick haemorrhage into fatty tissues.
There was corresponding injury
to the tissue within, extending deeply and widely.

There was a large area of bruising,
red-purple and yellow areas,
a variance of colours.

Coma:
symptoms; near or complete unconsciousness;
anaesthesia; depressed or abolished reflexes; subnormal temperature;
impairment of circulation and respiration;
possible death.

Natalie was dead.
You were awake.

 

7.

It is for me to form my own judgement.

I have regard to your good character.
I am prepared to accept in your favour
that you loved Natalie and were planning a future with her.

The sentence I pass upon you for manslaughter
is one of three years and eight months imprisonment.
You will serve half of that in prison.

You may go down.

Sibyl Ruth has published two small press collections of poetry and is a former winner of the Mslexia Poetry Competition. Her short fiction has appeared in The Book of Birmingham (Comma Press) and her creative non-fiction in Who Are We Now? (Tangled Roots). Her review of Mieko Kawakami’s novel Breasts and Eggs recently appeared on the Litro website.

1 All material is taken from the sentencing remarks of Mr Justice Julian Knowles in the Crown Court at Birmingham (Regina v John Broadhurst, 17 December 2018).