Issue Two

My Journey Out of the Rabbit Hole

by Nehanda

It’s a familiar tale: Alice takes a trip down the rabbit hole to a world where nothing makes sense. 

But it’s an odd place to begin a journey, waking up Alice-like at the bottom of a rabbit hole. 

Nevertheless, that’s where my journey began, at the bottom of a rabbit hole — a place where mainstream media plays the role of the white rabbit, a world where up can be down, left can be right and men can be women.

Sometimes, a journey can be just as important as the final destination, so let’s rewind nine months or so to a conversation that took place in a car between me and my mum. I think it’s safe to say that a lot of people hold their mums in high regard, but I have always looked at my mum as one of the most compassionate, understanding and intelligent people I’ve ever met. I’ve always looked to my mum as a perfect example of how to navigate the world and, bar a few minor disagreements, we’ve always seen eye to eye.

But here we were, voices raised, tempers high (well, mine certainly was at least) and actually butting heads. We were revisiting a conversation that had been had many times over the previous few months. I was beginning to lose my patience. Why were we having this conversation again? How had my mum suddenly become so lacking in compassion, so unwilling to fight for the underdog? 

She had explained what a TERF was, and how it was a slur only used against women. I couldn’t help but think, well … if the shoe fits. I painfully remember arguing that allowing trans women into women’s sports would surely make women work harder to be the best. As much as I’d rather forget I ever uttered those virtue-signalling words (and meant them), I think it’s very important not to forget but to instead ask how, and why, an outspoken and usually free-thinking individual like myself had adopted a position that favoured male-born people’s emotions over women’s hard work and safety.

One of the things I distinctly remember my mum saying is, “Language is being policed and the words for women erased.” This one, I had no argument for. Language is important to me, and so is being a woman. I’ve always found comfort in words. We need them to mean what they mean. Reading, writing, singing, listening, explaining and understanding — what are we without these things?

Finding just the right words to encompass a feeling, a thought or an idea, for me, is like scratching a hard-to-reach itch. I love to communicate and am pleased humans came up with such an effective way to do so. I had no ‘pre-programmed, here’s one I learned earlier’ argument for “language is being policed” so I chose instead simply not to believe it. 

I stuck with ‘trans women are women,’ a comfortable mantra that I knew not to be ‘true’ in, you know, the normal sense of the word, but true in that, yeah it might be false — but hey, it’s ‘kind.’

I failed to see that I was already comfortable bending and betraying language. I had chosen kindness over accuracy and truth, which I can safely say, considering I once corrected my best friend’s pronunciation whilst she was mid-emotional breakdown, goes entirely against my nature. 

Without being aware, I was compromising my values and putting truths aside out of fear of being unkind.

Some might not see the problem with this: what’s a little white lie here and there? What’s so wrong with telling a friend they look great in an outfit you don’t like? 

For me it’s disingenuous. Why go through life speaking untruths? My friends are used to this; they know how much I care for them and that I mean what I say. They know that both, “I think you were wrong” and “I’m so proud of you” come from the same place of love.

But back to the journey. I was quite happy betraying my values, naively trotting along in my little ‘kindness bubble.’ This ‘trans stuff’ only seemed to affect me when I was falling out with my mum and we had agreed not to discuss it again for a while, so I didn’t give it much more thought. 

Until one grey February morning as I absentmindedly scrolled through Instagram. 

I came across a post on one of the many ‘feminist’ pages I was following. It was an unconnected post about two well-known actors, Amber Heard and Johnny Depp, and allegations of abusive behaviours in their relationship. The post suggested that, contrary to initial reports, it may have been Heard herself who was the abusive party.

I’m not one for celebrity gossip or arguments had on a tiny screen with people I’ve never met, but I felt compelled to have my say on what I felt was the bigger issue: that Heard was initially so readily believed because of how familiar we are as a society with accounts of male aggression and the abuse of women. 

Someone was, of course, quick to reprimand me for bringing the discussion back to the root issue — male aggression, a pandemic we choose to accept. This seemingly innocuous interaction led to me unintentionally ‘toeing the TERF line’ for the first time. When I refused to join the witch hunt against Heard, and focused instead on the ubiquity of male aggression, one user said: 

“You’re the type of feminist that makes me ashamed to be female … You’re not a woman nor a female.” 

Unsure how to respond to such an odd accusation and in a haze of blissful ignorance, I typed out what I thought was a light-hearted and comical retort:

“Can you tell that to my uterus please? It’s really griefing me right about now.”

I was oblivious, but I had just made a wildly controversial statement. By attaching my womanhood to my female anatomy, I, Nehanda ‘trans women are women,’ had outed myself as a bigot, “hurtful to trans women.” After a few futile attempts to clarify my use of the scandalously provocative word ‘uterus,’ one user put me out of my misery and hit me with the big guns:

“So, you’re a TERF. Got it.” 

And there were those four letters, like a slap in the face. I felt a little like I’d missed a step. I’d been misunderstood, misconstrued, misrepresented. Yet, no matter how many times I scrutinized the conversation, I couldn’t find the bigotry — only facts. And the fact was, my mum was right. Here I was on an app full of filtered pictures and celebrity gossip having the ‘mum conversation’ again, except this time it was flipped: I was the TERF and the language police were out in full force. 

It seems we have already accepted the unreality of filtered pictures and I wonder if this has made it easier to accept the unreality of ‘filtered’ words. It felt like I was being told to put my words, my language, my reality through a filter to make it prettier or more palatable for others. 

Right there, on that chilly February morning, I began my trip back up the rabbit hole … 

What a progressive world we have come to live in where once again women must not speak of our uteruses, for that is taboo. We must be silent and take responsibility for the emotional distress of those we have never met, those who demand our silence because they are unwilling to bear our emotional distress. 

Along my journey, I have researched with an open mind, always attempting to look at all sides. I now know that no matter what I say and how careful I am with my words, I will always be called a TERF along with other insults, all with the same desired outcome — to shut me up.

In a strange turn of events, knowing this granted me the freedom to speak up. My worst fear in life was being misread as unkind or bigoted in any way, and realizing that it will happen when I stand up for women meant I had to make a choice. I chose truth. 

Nine months later and I was almost out of the rabbit hole. I awoke on another cold and drizzly morning to a DM informing me that the “blood and rights of trans women” are on my hands. 

I felt an initial stab, the one such emotive language was intended to provoke. Maybe because it was early and before my morning coffee, before I’d realized what I was doing, I began to formulate a response. Except something had changed in those nine months.

It is impossible to look into the discussion surrounding trans rights without reading the deeply personal and distressing pleas of thousands of women who don’t wish to be forced into unsafe situations and object to being erased. I will not turn away from the voices of concerned parents, afraid they will lose their children for following the innate reflex that calls for them to protect their children from harm. 

I have watched teenage girls hold back tears as they have their needs pushed to the side and have seen the damage a male-born fighter can do to a woman in a controlled environment.

Now, when I get that “blood and rights” DM, I feel no guilt or fear when I ask in response, “Who is willing to take responsibility for the blood and rights of women?” 

Because I know the answer. Me and thousands of others across the globe who care more about the safety of women and children than we do about being called names. 

Me and thousands of other women who live in a world that is becoming curiouser and curiouser by the day. Fortunately, we know our own hearts well enough not to fear being called a bigot by those who live in fear of being called a bigot.

We will not be punished for crimes that were never committed.

In the final scenes of Alice in Wonderland, Alice begins to grow to a massive size. She becomes too big for Wonderland and wakes to find it was all a dream. We cannot give up on those who have fallen down the rabbit hole; we need to find ways to help them expand until they no longer fit in ‘Wonderland’ and begin to see it for the absurd illusion that it is.

So now I sit, at the edge, looking down. I see good people following the rabbit. I try not to be discouraged or lose hope. I made it out — so can they.

Nehanda is a travelling musician, social activist and avid tweeter. Hailing from a working-class background, she has a natural skill of finding the good in the bad, digging silver linings out of the avalanche of grey clouds. Nehanda writes her own material and isn’t afraid to touch on topics that are often glossed over. She has a soulful and poetic style, takes pride in her feisty nature and hopes to leave the world a slightly better place than she found it. You can follow her journey on all social medias @NehandaMusic.