Issue Two

Between the Waves: A Review of the Souvenir Centenary Edition of Time and Tide

by Susanna Rustin

Time and Tide, ed. by Catherine Clay, published free online (timeandtidemagazine.org) and as a pamphlet (Nottingham: Five Leaves Publications, 2020), 36pp., £5.

Starting in May 1920, and throughout the interwar period, a weekly news and culture magazine called Time and Tide was published in London. Owned by Lady Margaret Rhondda, the Welsh heiress to an industrial fortune, and including among its contributors such well-known writers as Winifred Holtby, Sylvia Townsend Warner and Rebecca West, Time and Tide was in the mould of the New Statesman (started seven years earlier) and Nation and Athenaeum. But where its rivals in the intellectual weekly review market were dominated by male writers and editors, Time and Tide was a feminist enterprise — not only in the politics it espoused but also as a woman-led institution, with an all-female board of directors.

To mark Time and Tide’s centenary, a Souvenir Edition of highlights has been published online — in the same format as the original, including advertisements — and as a 32-page pamphlet. And it’s a struggle to decide whether to be more impressed by the content, which is excellent; or dismayed that Time and Tide isn’t already better known. Picking up the baton from the suffrage movement, and carrying it through the campaign that led to the granting of the vote to women on the same terms as men in 1928, and beyond, Time and Tide was among the outstanding performers of women’s journalism.

Unlike second-wave feminist publications such as Spare Rib, however, Time and Tide had largely been forgotten — until a handful of scholars began digging around. Catherine Clay of Nottingham Trent University is the leading figure behind the special issue, and the author of a book, Time and Tide: The Feminist and Cultural Politics of a Modern Magazine (Edinburgh University Press, 2018).

The book describes a trajectory that saw a proudly feminist magazine move away from its overt connection with women’s rights, for a mixture of motives including rising anti-feminism in the 1930s. But for the centenary issue it is Time and Tide’s original, suffragette colours that Clay has nailed to the mast. It includes a notice about the “rainbow procession” being planned for 3 July 1926, to demand equal political rights for women, and a report following the march, which included “women journalists who walked in a procession as a professional group for the first time” (a stirring sentence for any feminist journalist to read).

Also included is the manifesto of the Six Point Group, the campaign with which Time and Tide was closely associated. Its aims were improved widows’ pensions, stronger laws against child assault, equal rights of guardianship, new laws to protect unmarried mothers, equal pay for teachers and equal opportunities in the Civil Service. But of all the pieces in the centenary issue, perhaps the most powerful is an unsigned opinion piece following the passage of the Equal Franchise Bill in 1928, which lays this victory at the feet of the militant suffragettes and the campaign they fought between 1905 and 1914. 

“Those who fail to realise what militancy did are not merely refusing to honour the hand that set them free, they are decrying a part of the freedom they have gained,” it declares. “No one, man or woman, likes to be thought violent, unreasonable, ugly in word or deed, and because of their upbringing this is an even harder thing for women to bear than it is for men. But on occasions it is necessary … the vote was not won by sweet reasonableness, it was won by self-sacrifice and courage and — above all — by that most difficult of all forms of courage, the courage to appear violent, unreasonable, ugly.”

A century on, and in the midst of a new phase of struggle over women’s rights in the UK, this endorsement of direct action and reminder of the suffragettes’ extraordinary courage could hardly be more timely. Arguments about the intersection of women’s and trans rights, and about the increasing commodification of women’s bodies (pornography, commercial surrogacy), are often framed as differences between ‘second-wave’ feminists and younger women influenced by queer theory and anti-racist politics. So it is with a jolt of recognition, as the journalist Polly Toynbee points out in her preface to the souvenir issue, that one learns about the conflicts in women’s politics in the 1920s and 1930s.

One key dividing line between what were described at the time as ‘old’ and ‘new’ feminists was the extent to which they wanted to carry on campaigning as feminists after winning the vote. ‘Old’ feminists, including Winifred Holtby, author of the novel South Riding, hoped feminism would be replaced by a broader-based campaign for human rights. She devoted much of her life to supporting black trade-union organizers in South Africa.

By contrast with Holtby’s wish to downplay sex differences, however, ‘new’ feminists — also known as ‘welfare feminists’ — sought to emphasize women’s specific needs and particularly the difficulties faced by mothers. The programme of the Six Point Group can be seen as a compromise between these two tendencies, including elements from both. But arguments in favour of new maternal entitlements became harder for left-wingers to make in the 1930s, as fascists and Nazis developed their cults of militarism and motherhood. Two articles in the souvenir issue raise the alarm about the extreme form of anti-feminism then in the ascendant across much of Europe. 

Other pieces of interest to feminists include a discussion of menstruation, which some might be surprised by given the date (1928), and an appeal by the writer, Naomi Mitchison, for couples who might be willing to help with research into contraception. From Croyde in Devon, E. M. Delafield (author of Diary of a Provincial Lady) wrote to suggest that other households could follow her example and offer a guest room to “one or two Jewish refugees in need of rest and country quiet.” A letter with multiple signatories protested against the death sentences passed on the nine ‘Scottsboro boys’ in Alabama. An exchange in the correspondence column about whether letters to Time and Tide should begin ‘Sir’ or ‘Madam’ is arch in tone, but spoke directly to the question of whether Time and Tide wished to make a point of sex difference, or not.

Time and Tide continued to be published until 1979, but its politics changed after the Second World War, moving to the right and with control ceded to male editors even before Lady Rhondda’s death in 1958. Lady Rhondda herself became more conservative as she grew older. But her wealth, and its sources, had always made her a somewhat unusual patron of radical and left-wing causes (although not more so than plenty of others).

About her mission she was admirably clear-sighted. In a column for the magazine’s ‘Notes on the Way’ slot in 1935, she noted Time and Tide’s habit of allowing internal disagreements to be aired in its pages, and joked that an alternative title might have been Tooth and Claw. Her aim, she said, was “at one and the same time to pursue a definite editorial purpose and to serve as a medium for the free expression of the best honest opinion of the day that one can collect. One must allow the views one believes the right ones to be shot at and be able to show that they can survive bombardment.” 

This frank acknowledgement of conflicts and compromises makes this, I think, as good a manifesto for journalism that is both politically committed and pluralistic as there is. Campaigners are fundraising for a statue of Lady Rhondda in Newport, and while defunct periodicals are by definition obscure to some extent, I can see no reason, apart from sexism, why period pieces such as T. S. Eliot’s Criterion or the Leavis quarterly, Scrutiny, have reputations that are so much bigger than Time and Tide’s. 

The magazine was an important one, containing prescient commentary on foreign affairs and high-quality cultural criticism as well as feminist polemics. But the centenary is also an opportunity to re-evaluate the feminist movement of which it was part. Contemporary understandings of the ‘first wave’ of the women’s movement in Britain — at least among non-specialists — often appear limited to an argument about tactics: gradualist (suffragist) versus militant (suffragette). 

Reading Time and Tide brings home what a huge amount this version of feminism’s history leaves out. Feminism did not simply fade away after the battle for the vote until the second wave got going at the end of the 1960s. We can learn as much or more from the backlash against sexual equality in the 1930s, and from differing views about which direction the women’s movement should take (including the internationalist, anti-imperialist causes adopted by activists such as Holtby), as we can from the triumph of the Pankhursts.

A century after Time and Tide’s launch, there is newly vehement resistance to some feminist arguments, and from LGBT+ and men’s-rights activists as well as the social and religious conservatives who have long been feminists’ opponents. What better time than now, then, to revisit what Time and Tide’s centenary reminds us was a key moment in the history of the British women’s movement? And what better place to do this than in a brand-new feminist magazine?

Susanna Rustin is a journalist at the Guardian, where she writes mainly about social affairs.