Issue One

Our Fathers Who Aren’t in Heaven

by Clare Frances Davies

FATHERS 

When my father left us he told my mum he’d see her in the gutter — “dead.” As he said the words, he made a slicing action with his forefinger across his throat. Then he sped off in his ugly purple Porsche, which to me had always symbolized a massive, egotistical cock — essentially, what my father was. His mistress was waiting for him in the poplar trees at the bottom of our drive. I picture her in her ’80s white stilettos, tight silk skirt, bouffant hair and the blue sapphire dangly earrings that belonged to my mother. “Dennis,” she’d have said in her Liverpool drawl, “Did yer get the necklace?”

I stood on the drive for what must have been several minutes, processing what had just happened. At last he’d gone. My dad. The grade-A tosser and bully. He’d made our lives hell ever since I could remember. Yet my eyes filled up with tears. He was still my dad.

Then, there was a rustling in the rhododendron bush. My father clambered out from behind a clump of sticky red flowers, brushing leaves off his chinos, ignoring my shouts of “Dad! Dad! What are you doing?” He sauntered over to the small green car that belonged to my mother, unlocked it, got inside, and drove away.

In 2013, my father died of complications from diabetes and Alzheimer’s. I did not visit him in the hospital. But I attended his funeral. His wife (the mistress who waited for him in the poplar trees) spelt my name wrong on the order of service — a final, humiliating acknowledgement of my insignificance in his life. I didn’t throw a red rose onto his coffin before it whirred towards the incinerator. And this time, I didn’t cry.

That summer after he’d left, my mum and my sisters and I lived in claustrophobic fear as my father lurked most nights around our isolated gardens. At 4am, I’d lie in bed listening to the crunch of gravel beneath my window. Given what I knew of my dad’s propensity for violence, it was not far-fetched to assume he wasn’t only after the garden furniture or the stone flower pots which, come morning, had vanished. He may have decided that it was easier to slit our throats in the night. Bloody women.

These acts — first stealing the car and then the garden furniture — summed up my father. He was a cowardly and ridiculous thief whose need to possess everything possessed him and who never, ever looked back. 

We have all known men like this. Men who steal from women. Men who feel entitled to whatever they lay their eyes on. Men who think they own females. Men who’d deny us women and girls the right to even belong to ourselves, never mind possess what’s rightfully ours. Men who colonize with their eyes, hands, words, money, laws, politics, violence — sexual or otherwise. Men who are both the product and the vectors of misogyny. 

Men like my father. Because Dad wasn’t just a rotten parent: he really, really hated females. Misogyny didn’t colour his view of the world — it was his world. 

Our fathers are the first men in our lives, the original male role model, the template from which we potentially come to judge all other men (and mankind itself) and judge ourselves. Growing up with misogyny can mark a girl for life. Under its gaze, girls lose their own subjectivity, becoming flat screens onto which misogyny casts its projections. (Stupid. Nagging. Insignificant. Invisible. Fuckable. Hateable. Pitiable. Malleable. Breakable.) There is no space for that girl to exist as a complete human being in the misogynist’s world. This cuts to the bone. Eventually scar tissue grows over the wounds and as women we carry them around with us in the world, often unwittingly, and often for the rest of our lives.

I’ve met many women in gender-critical feminist circles whose stories, if not the same as mine, bear similar hallmarks. We share the scars of being girls who never had the choice to say No, or to draw any boundaries because, for a misogynistic father (or brother, or uncle), boundaries are red rags to a snarling bull.

Yet, despite the wounding, despite that buildup of scar tissue, despite a world being on fire with misogyny and sexism, the most important thing I’ve learnt is that the world is not my father. 

Whether it happened in the past, or it’s happening now, in our own lives or to another woman or girl halfway across the world, I think we can agree that misogyny is universal. And it is often our personal experiences (including trauma) that fuel our desire to fight against it for others’ sake. Having experience with a misogynistic, gaslighting male (or males — many women have been abused by more than one man) can make us more aware of red flags in others, recognize patterns of abusive behaviour and encourage us to trust our instincts.

However, when we unconsciously project our own traumatic experiences of past misogyny (for instance, male abuse we grew up with) onto present-day, external situations, people and events, this may keep us trapped in a trauma cycle, which prevents us from feeling safe in our skins. 

Stephen Grosz describes it like this:

Experience has taught me that our childhoods leave in us stories like this — stories we never found a way to voice, because no one helped us to find the words. When we cannot find a way of telling our story, our story tells us — we dream these stories, we develop symptoms, or we find ourselves acting in ways we don’t understand.1
Whilst the world still wears his face, my father still holds the power. He still lives inside me. Or else lurks out there in the darkness. Waiting to steal everything precious to me. Crunching the gravel beneath his feet. Waiting to slit my throat. And I do not want him to hold that power. Because, then, every man I pass looks like him. He shapes all my relationships with men. Every time I am disempowered, life yanking my strings like I am its puppet, whenever a male doctor gaslights me about my health, or a male Tory politician lies with a self-satisfied grin and a paunch: there is my father in disguise. Because patriarchy itself looks remarkably like Dennis James Davies. Each wink of the eye, each pat on the bum, every cold, grey, empty stare: all will come back to him. Carl Jung articulates how “Projections change the world into the replica of one’s own unknown face.”2 Other men are not our fathers. Only our abusers are our abusers. I cannot stress this enough. Slay that demon of projection lest it eat you alive. Otherwise, we are at risk of attributing to males characteristics, motivations and behaviour that are not actually present because we are seeing only what our projections tell us to see. This differs greatly from trusting our gut instinct, or spotting red flags. Yet disentangling the two is not necessarily easy. It means doing the work: self-reflection, honesty and, ultimately, showing ourselves a great deal of tenderness. But the prize on the other side of projection is a door that opens onto safer ground. Bessel van der Kolk explains that “if you feel safe and loved, your brain becomes specialized in exploration, play, and cooperation; if you are frightened and unwanted, it specializes in managing feelings of fear and abandonment.”3 Healing, for me, isn’t fighting misogyny whilst blood gushes from wounds that get torn open again and again. Or remaining stuck in a trauma cycle of fight, flight and freeze. It is in finding my place of safety, and for me, this is how I can finally lay my father to rest.

MOTHERS, SISTERS

Growing up, I witnessed the fire and fury in my two older sisters: gobby, defiant — they stood up to Dad’s bullying and fought back physically despite him being six foot four and a jujitsu black belt. Their rage bubbled over like molten lava into our family home. Much of it, I recall, seemed to revolve around records. I remember a Blondie single in shards on my sister’s bedroom carpet, shattered by a single stamp of my other sister’s winkle picker heel. I recollect red, white, green and yellow vinyl cascading down our stairwell in a multicoloured waterfall as one sister frisbeed a Gang of Four LP at my other sister’s head. I see my sister’s fist punching through a glass door. Mugs of tea flung up the dining room wall during That’s Life. Blood. Cut wrists. My sister’s eyes shrunken beneath thick, black kohl and a Chrissie Hynde fringe, white patches on her head where her hair used to be. Mum slapped down the stairs by her own daughters. And then there was me — the lonely peacemaker with a dweeb bowl haircut and Clarks shoes, asking them all politely to please stop.

No one listened to my mother. Eventually, her impotent rage would unleash itself (later on, worsened by booze) in Scarlett O’Hara–style theatrics and threats of suicide. Our home became a swirling, scalding, spitting toxic liquid of unacknowledged emotions: Tara without the sweeping staircase. And when mascara crawled like spiders down my mother’s cheeks as she wept, I held her. When my sisters went missing, I phoned the police. No one else knew how to be an adult, so I stepped up to the plate. I was a calm, almost invisible presence in the house. You could say I was pretty grown up for eight years old.

Even after leaving home, I still played peacemaker and saviour. It was only decades later, after both my parents were dead, that I finally stopped trying to save the women in my family, and started trying to save myself.

THE WOUNDED FAMILY

So, why am I telling you this? What’s the purpose of me sharing with you my gory childhood stories? Because I want to divulge the most significant insights I’ve had in the last three years of involvement in the online gender-critical movement. I wish to do so hoping it may be of some use.

So, let us go back 12 months to an incident online in which I was called misogynistic names by a trans activist. I noticed a recurring pattern in how “interactions” like this made me feel. Such behaviour — extreme, aggressive, boundary crossing, space stealing — created in me a similar feeling my father had: annihilated, dissociated, a nauseating sensation of not being quite real. I was a terf, a bitch, a cunt; a witch who must shut the fuck up. Womanhood to this person seemed exactly as my father envisioned it: land to conquer, a vast open space to trample through, be stolen, burnt, our geography existing only for the conquerors. My god, I thought, in my panic, these people want to kill me. They are going to destroy me, along with any other woman who speaks and resists. They won’t be happy until they see us silent in the gutter, “dead.”

Then, a few months later, I had a run-in on Twitter with some fellow gender criticals. I’d tweeted about how in the US a violent white supremacist organisation called the Proud Boys had accompanied Christian “feminist” protesters to a Drag Queen Story Hour picket, armed with guns, and how troubling I found this. My point had nothing to do with whether I found DQSH objectionable. Yet several women called me a “paedophile” and “groomer.” I understood women’s concerns about safeguarding. However, this wasn’t the first time women supposedly on the same “side” had attacked me. It wasn’t outright violent or threatening, as with some transactivists, but it followed a not-too-dissimilar route of ad hominems, deflection and hyperbole. This always happened when I challenged prevailing GC views on a topic, or attempted to introduce another context for the subject being discussed. If you want to witness the bared teeth of GC Twitter I recommend tweeting an alternative take on a charged topic and watching your replies fill up with vitriol.

At the same time, there was a real-life battle going on. Women were in trouble. So, alongside them, I did what I could to fight for women’s spaces and, as I did so, thought of my mother and of my sisters and of the boundaries they were never allowed to hold, of the personal space they could not forge for themselves. With so many others, I fought against my own dehumanization. Refused to be that dead woman, that witch.

However, over time, I felt burnt out. And alone. I noticed women tearing strips off each other online. Some even seemed intent on destroying other women. I watched the multicoloured records flying down the stairs at an alarming rate. I felt tired and sick (because childhood trauma makes you tired and sick), and this place I found myself in on GC Twitter was not a place of healing. It was a place of trauma. I was back with my sisters and my mother, fighting my father. Once again acting out trauma I’d fought so hard to leave behind. Feminism had become a receptacle for my projections, and when I looked around me, I saw that this was true for other women too. Their own personal histories lit up their eyes with suffering. As my wariness grew, guilt tugged at me. I only felt a part of the gender-critical movement when I was supporting “the cause,” and saying the “right” things. The sisterhood I had hoped might sometimes flow both ways, I discovered, only flowed in one direction, and once again in life, that direction was away from me.

It was then that I understood that I had projected my father onto trans activism, my mother onto the gender-critical movement and its fight for sex-based rights, and the fire and fury of my sisters onto gender-critical twitter.

In fact, I witnessed my entire dysfunctional family and upbringing laid out in all its toxic glory before me on my Twitter timeline and in the social media accounts of other feminists and transactivists and their “allies.”

And this, my friends, is what’s informally known as a complete headfuck.

This is when I knew something needed to change.

It’s significant to note I was not the only person projecting in those two examples I’ve just recounted. In both, without provocation, I became the receptacle for some deeply ugly and dark projections: I was evil and inhumane (a witch or child abuser) at the same time as being subject to dehumanizing personal attacks and smears. This is how the mechanism of projection operates. And it always ends in bad faith.

I want to be clear this is not the same thing as women standing their ground, or expressing anger at the erosion of their rights. That is neither projection nor bad faith. Projection is very specific, and can be very toxic.4 It’s also prevalent on social media.

So, now, I’d like to have a little word in your ear about the platform we all love to hate (or hate to love): Twitter. We all know Twitter is the Wild West of social media. However, I see it more like a discombobulating, maze-like hall of mirrors — a shimmering labyrinth of projection.5 It’s in the platform’s design and culture to foster discord, feuding, tribalism, mob rule, scapegoating, dehumanization and bullying. Twitter is perfect for populism and for reducing the complex to the simplistic. Here, a certain politics thrives. If you enjoy playing dirty and smearing your opponent, shouting and screaming at people or strutting about in righteous indignation, Twitter is magnificent. If you wish to get to grips with complex, difficult, charged and often triggering subjects (like the clash between women’s rights and trans rights) expect misunderstanding and polarization to blight many of your interactions.

Not all Twitter debates will be destined for distortion by bad faith, but it’s useful to know that as a platform it manipulates us towards less constructive and more reactive modes of communication. In short, it primes us for warfare.

Most users engaged in online activism curate their Twitter feeds. It is natural to seek accounts with perspectives which chime with our own and follow voices reflecting our values and priorities. This means our feeds6 become an echo chamber reflecting back to us only those views that correspond with our own pre-existing notions of what’s true or right. At the same time it fools us into believing we are engaging in genuine discussion with contrasting viewpoints. Hermetically sealed off from views that may challenge our underlying assumptions and biases, we tweet away in our tiny bubble assuming it to be reality.7 Yet it’s just another trick of the light.

Gender-critical Twitter is a vital platform for connecting women, feminist organizing, disseminating information and ideas, and exchanging perspectives. It is too precious a resource to give up on, despite its issues. Instead we must preserve and strengthen what’s useful and positive about it whilst minimizing the unhelpful or negative.

But how?

Over the years I’ve noticed a rise in the view “if you are not 100% with me, then you must be against me” in the online gender-critical world. I’ve witnessed criticism treated as an attack, or mischaracterized as “policing women,” “dividing the movement” or “giving ammo to the TRAs.” Women drawing boundaries around issues they find contentious or problematic, or who assert what they will or won’t support in the movement, may find themselves scapegoated as heretics, or even framed as “the enemy.” Levelling the accusation that someone is “pulling apart the movement” when they are being honest or questioning, or guilt-tripping them into “keeping it behind closed doors” makes us vulnerable to mimicking the behaviour of dogmatic, even abusive groups and organizations. It also echoes a refrain often found within dysfunctional family structures: Shh, keep our secrets, or else. None of us want a movement like that.

It is also incorrect. We forget that critiques often emerge out of a desire not to see a movement fail, but for it to flourish. Allowing space for difference and dissent (including the questioning of strategies, arguments and directions the gender-critical movement may take) — when given and received in good faith — provides a movement with resilience, flexibility and trust.

This is the opposite of brittle dogmatism and blind faith, which creates a fractured, weak movement dominated by the loudest and most extreme voices.8 This becomes a movement that cannot acknowledge its own shadow — that which “personifies everything that the subject refuses to acknowledge about himself [herself: sic].”9

Feminism is a tool. A set of analyses. A map. It helps us to understand how patriarchy works in the world and gives us directions out of the brutal constraints it places upon women and girls. This is not a religion. This is not an absolute creed. This was not given to us by the Goddess. When we cling to it in order to refuse to see reality and the world from any other perspective, we become like any other dogmatist. We are just another bunch of religious zealots, with gender-critical feminism as our doctrine. If you accuse a trans activist of being in a cult, be damn sure you aren’t using GC feminism in the same way. Because any group, political or religious movement, any organization or institution can become a cult, or develop aspects that are cultish. I repeat: Any. Jung confirms this, since “None of us stands outside humanity’s black collective shadow.”10 This includes feminism.

THE GREAT MOTHER

So, how can we balance out bad faith in the gender-critical movement? Prevent the shadow from consuming us? This mentality is frequently a response to being under attack, or feeling we are. Women rarely respond well to online abuse, threats, misrepresentation, gaslighting, and so on. But how might we undo our unconscious projections that leave us feeling unsafe, triggered, raging or powerless, and which can be destructive to ourselves and to others? 

Well, the adage is true — often it is in the mucky depths of experience that the most exquisite flowers bloom. So too, it is within what our conscious selves may see as sinister or frightening that “represents the true spirit of life as against the arid scholar.” 11 As Carolyn Kaufman points out, “in spite of its function as a reservoir for human darkness — or perhaps because of this — the shadow is the seat of creativity.”12

So, finally, I’d like to explore the Jungian idea of how the shadow can either remain the destructive, unconscious part of us, or else become fuel for creativity, humanity and insight. I’ll do this by relating it to two different symbols that we can use for gender-critical feminism: the circle and the spiral.

The circle goes around in a continual “reactive” cycle. It is closed. There are no exit points. No entry points. The circle represents close-mindedness, dogmatism, ideological intractability, groupthink, intolerance. It also represents the fight, flight and freeze cycle of trauma where we feel compelled to either dominate or run away, or else we feel stuck or paralysed. Unconscious, blind to its own flaws — projection and “acting out” are its inevitable consequence. This is a painful, insular way of thinking and being engulfed by self-righteousness, blame and self-pity. It is also tyrannical, averse to any dissent or difference. It will crush all opposition. Yet it remains disembodied, floating in a world of abstract theories and ideas, excluding human realities.

The circle seeks simple answers to complex questions (no nuance here): an outrage machine permanently set to red alert. It is the perfect vehicle for populism. The knee-jerk platform of social media is its best friend. Around and around it goes, engulfed by its own shadow, with no healing possible. Those trapped within that circle are doomed to act out their shadow, willing to do whatever it takes to “win the war.”

The spiral is open at both ends. It is open to the rest of the world whilst remaining true to itself. It expands out of the circle and grows upwards as opposed to revolving in a repetitive motion. So, this is an inward and outward movement. Rather than remaining stuck in cycles of trauma, the spiral empowers us to look inside and, with great gentleness, make conscious whatever suffering and past experiences are bolstering our projections. We can step outside of our echo chambers and allow dissenting voices in. Yet the spiral remains grounded as it winds around a centre that stays rooted even as the spiral grows. It is a useful image for understanding our relationships with others in the gender critical movement, and for the movement as a whole, and provides insight into how we can integrate conflicts, different perspectives and uncertainties.

Self-reflection is a supportive tool. In the heat of online conflict, we can ask ourselves: How is this interaction making me feel? Do I feel aggressive, terrified, traumatized, frozen, mute? Do I feel safe? Grounded? Triggered? Do I want to run away? Attack? Does my voice feel strangled? What is the trigger? How may I best protect myself? Am I able to identify what is happening to me in the moments before I respond? Do I feel like I need to destroy before I am destroyed? Is there a parent or sibling or early childhood figure haunting me as I “debate”? Am I driven to win the war at all costs? Can I recognize a mob when I am in it? What are my bodily sensations during this interaction? How am I breathing? Can I feel the ground beneath me? How might I take care of myself in this moment?

The spiral unites the warrior-like, fearless, uncompromising nature of the circle with a healing, constructive and consciousness-raising path that helps us to resolve inner and outer conflicts so that the gender-critical movement can thrive.

This creates an upward, spiralling effect. The spiral is the path of the Great Mother: the magic authority of the female whose transforming wisdom nourishes and sustains. The Great Mother is the archetype for protection, and she draws a magic ring of safety around us as we seek to embrace all of ourselves. She walks beside us as we delve down into the underworld of the unconscious, and she knows its inhabitants. Robert Bly explains it is with her support that “we begin to travel [up] through the healing spirals… straight up.”13

I’ve had a lifetime of the Tyrannical Father and Devouring Mother.14 A bellyful of shadows and secrets and wars and attrition. I imagine you have too. We each have the choice and the power to forge our precious feminist movement (and shape ourselves). I hope that my words and stories offer some useful insights in these challenging times. And remember: “Behind her gentle character, the strength of armor was found.”15

Clare Frances Davies is a writer who has published in Aeon Magazine, The Observer and literary journals. Her first book is a memoir – a neurological detective story about mysterious seizures and her haunted childhood. She is currently working on a crime novel set in the world of female artists.

1 Stephen Grosz, The Examined Life: How We Lose and Find Ourselves (New York, N.Y.: W. W. Norton & Co., 2013), p. 10

2 The Collected Works of C. G. Jung, ed. by Herbert Read and others, 20 vols (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 1957-79), IX (part 2): Aion, ed. and trans. by Gerhard Adler and R. F. C. Hull (1959), p. 9.

3 Bessel van der Kolk, The Body Keeps the Score (New York: Penguin, 2014), p. 56.

4 For an interesting read on how projection works, see Marie-Louise Von Franz, Projection and Re-Collection in Jungian Psychology: Reflections of the Soul (Chicago: Open Court, 1980).

5 Jung described the archetype of the maze: “The maze of strange passages, chambers, and unlocked exits in the cellar recalls the old Egyptian representation of the underworld, which is a well-known symbol of the unconscious with its unknown possibilities. It also shows how one is ‘open’ to other influences in one’s unconscious shadow side, and how uncanny and alien elements can break in.” Marie-Louise von Franz, “The Process of Individuation,” in C. G. Jung, Man and His Symbols (New York: Anchor Press, 1964), p. 170.

6 And the accounts we follow and who follow us…

7 Not to mention the constant flow of information and opinion in our feeds where, aided by Twitter’s algorithms, the same subjects gain attention over and again whilst other, equally important ones, fade to nothing.

8 Where contrasting perspectives are subject to smearing, scapegoating and ad hominems.

9 The Collected Works of C. G. Jung, IX (part 1): The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious, trans. by R. F. C. Hull (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 1959), p. 284.

10 The Collected Works of C. G. Jung, X: Civilization in Transition, trans. by R. F. C. Hull (Abingdon, UK: Routledge, 1964), p. 297.

11 Carl G. Jung, Memories, Dreams, Reflections (London: Fontana, 1983), p. 262.

12 Carolyn Kaufman, “Three-Dimensional Villains: Finding Your Character’s Shadow,” Archetype Writing: The Writer’s Guide to Psychology, 21 March 2012.

13 Robert Bly and Marion Woodman, The Maiden King (Dorset: Owl Books, 1999), pp. 160-61

14 According to Jung, the Tyrannical Father is the archetypal representation of patriarchy, bullying and misogyny. Note: just because we are women doesn’t mean we can’t act out patriarchal behaviour of domination, toxic aggression and misogyny. For Jung, the path of Devouring Mother is where what is secret remains hidden in the dark, in the abyss of our individual and collective selves; it is the world of the dead, and it devours, poisons.

15 Erin Forbes, Fire and Ice: The Kindred Woods (Fire Opal, 2019).