Issue One

Radfem Panic: When Demands for Inclusivity Are A Cover For Moral Disgust

by Marina Strinkovsky

Author’s Note: This piece was written in 2014, a somewhat prehistoric time in what has come to be called “the gender wars.” In the years since Maria Miller, then the Conservative Chair of the Women and Equalities Select Committee of the British Parliament, published a report that recommended the law allow people to change their gender by self-identification, a political movement coalesced around opposition to those proposals and a subsequent consultation, a vibrant and exciting one that deserves its own history. The events and thoughts in this piece entirely predate that movement, but rereading it now, in September 2020, the month in which the current Conservative Minister for Women and Equalities finally announced no such reforms are going forward, what strikes me is not how different things are to what they were in 2014, but how very similar.

Two similarities strike me as critical to understanding the nature of the political contestation: one, that already then, the question of women-only spaces was what the Americans call “a third-rail issue” — when the question of access to women’s spaces was raised, all the oxygen got sucked out of the room in a panicked intake of breath. And two, that already then the validity of the affective argument in favour of trans inclusion at all costs was the dominant mode of discourse on the part of those favouring inclusion.

It seems to me that what later became a standard set of supporting “zombie stats” for trans advocates, things like suicide rates among trans teens and the heightened vulnerability of trans people to violence, were created and instrumentalized in support of the affective argument. People are not vehemently arguing in favour of trans inclusion because they believe that trans people are the most marginalized group in society — they believe trans people are the most marginalized group in society because of the very vehemence of their response to the topic.

This piece was not written to interrogate that vehemence, but a different and related response, equal in strength but opposite in effect: the powerful instinct of condemnation and loathing many people have to the arguments of feminists, not so much against trans inclusion per se as for the right of women to exclude in principle. The general outline of this response does not seem to me to have changed since 2014, and has probably been the same long before that. While it is true that some people feel an instinctive repugnance of trans people, it is equally true that some other people feel an instinctive repugnance of feminists. Sometimes they’re even the same people. Why? That is the question I set out to answer for myself, and I think the answer I arrived at is as applicable today as it ever was.

“Seventy percent of communication is nonverbal.” I really hate that cliché, because I’m a words person. To me, carefully chosen and logically constructed verbal arguments should take precedence over all of the attendant (and extraneous) signals like tone, posture and facial expression. That’s what I like about the internet: it strips people’s mannerisms away and leaves them with only words at their disposal. It comes with all kinds of problems for interpersonal situations, but in the absence of trolling and abuse has been fantastically useful for thought, discussion, argument and idea exchange. I’ve always thought that was a good thing. I never had reason to doubt that the affect I’m missing online mostly conveys information that is of no interest to me as someone who is primarily interested in analysing ideas, not personalities. So it came as rather a surprise to me to encounter a really powerfully emotional, nonverbal situation, which translated to a strong intellectual insight occasioned by a person’s affect and not their words or arguments.

I was on a panel discussing women’s spaces at the Feminist and Women’s Studies Association (FWSA) conference “Rethinking Sisterhood” last weekend, along with several friends and co-activists. All brought some really valuable insights into the question of women-only organizing and the possibilities for interpreting and enacting sisterhood in that context. The part of the conversation relevant to this post came relatively late in the session, when an audience member raised the question of trans inclusion: does the panel think that women-only spaces should be open to all self-identifying women, or not?

Well. You can just about imagine nobody wanted to touch that question with a fricking barge pole. We all know what happens, right? Either what you say is interpreted as being bigoted, transphobic and exclusionary, or it gets interpreted as anti-woman, patriarchy appeasing and callous. No middle ground, no way of pleasing everybody, and frankly a lot of the time no way of pleasing anyone at all. So there was a certain amount of foot shuffling as we all tried to think of a way to not let the issue completely derail the remaining part of the session, and in the end I offered the following observation:

The important point, for me, about exclusion and inclusion in safe spaces, is not so much who they include and who they exclude, but that, as feminists, we keep ourselves obliged to the principle of consent. What that means is that even if a group of women wants to exclude us, on any grounds whatsoever, however spurious those may seem to us, our first duty as feminists is to respect their boundaries and not try to breach them or cause them to be breached.

I illustrated my argument by putting up my hand in a sort of “Stop!” gesture, palm out towards my audience, and saying: “the magic (i.e. feminist politics) doesn’t happen on this side of the hand or on that side of the hand. The magic happens at the hand: praxis is saying ‘no’ and having it respected.”

On the whole the argument was well received, though at least one radical feminist in the audience thought that this was a fudge and an insufficiently direct engagement with what she saw as the real underlying question: “what/who is a woman?” The question of what is prior, definition or action, is a complex one and one I think that is being worked out as praxis within feminist communities rather than ever being resolvable by pure reason. So it will remain unaddressed here. What I wanted to get to was a particularly powerful response from one other member of the audience.

This woman (I’m going to call her Angela) opened her statement by describing her own emotional state: she said that she was very upset, that she was surprised by the level of her own emotional reaction to this issue. Angela described the physical symptoms of the reaction to us: her legs were, she said, jelly, her heart was beating, she felt flushed and panicky. She was basically telling us (I think mostly me personally, but I might be being a bit self-centred there) that our words had induced some kind of trauma response in her, a fully-fledged psychic distress event. She then went on to say she simply couldn’t understand how I could be so lacking in empathy, that I could reject someone out of my space who wants to be there as she is claiming fellowship with me as a woman. She also said that she found my forbidding, stopping hand “incredibly aggressive.”

My first reaction was to be irritated: here I am, trying to make a careful argument for something I think needs to be calmly talked about and discussed, and this woman is trying to one-up me, to exploit her own obvious distress by manipulating my emotions. How illogical! How childish! How, well, rude! But later, in that over-intellectualizing way I have, I couldn’t help thinking and trying to really understand what just happened in that room.

To explain what I think did happen, and in fact does happen a lot in discussions about lesbian separatism, radical feminism, women-only spaces and other politics of women’s autonomy, I need to refer to three concepts: moral disgust, the uncanny valley, and gay panic.

The first of those is quite a familiar concept. We’ll take as a guide the definition proposed by Michael Hauskeller in a 2006 paper: “the expression of a very strong moral disapproval that cannot fully be captured by argument.”1 Liberals pride themselves on their low levels of moral disgust, in particular in relation to the sexual practices of others.2 This is why we tend to conceptualize the objections of the right to certain things like homosexuality as “phobias”—irrational fears stemming from an underlying moral disgust. It’s also why the “phobia” frame has so successfully, and without any problematizing interrogation that I could see, migrated to be applied inside the social justice left, in terms like transphobia, whorephobia, fatphobia, femmephobia and so on.

But here was a person literally, in every physical sense of the word, exhibiting a phobic reaction. Angela was terrified by me, terrified of my implacable “Stop!” And much like conservative activists seeking to criminalize or marginalize homosexual relationships, she was using the very viscerality of her own reaction as a strong progressive/liberal moral argument: you have upset me, therefore I am right. What was going on?

To explain that, let’s look at the other two concepts: the uncanny valley and gay panic.3 The first comes from the world of humanoid robotics. Researchers working with robots found that people react emotionally with high levels of comfort to robots that look completely non-human, somewhat non-human, and absolutely believably human. But at the point on the scale where robots exhibit almost-but-not-quite believably human features, there is a dramatic dip in the levels of comfort people experience (the “valley” of the name). There are a lot of theories as to what could be the reason for this, and no conclusive explanation, but that shouldn’t concern us here; all I want to point to is the discomfort associated with confronting an object that doesn’t fall neatly into one of two categories (machine/human), exhibiting insufficient characteristics of both but not seeming to be fully either. This concept can be useful in thinking about reactions to trans people and the different ways people in general view drag queens or pantomime dames (obviously not female and therefore not triggering discomfort), passing trans women (completely female-looking and therefore not triggering discomfort even when we know they are trans), and non-passing trans women and cross-dressers (not quite fitting into either the definitely-male or definitely-female category and therefore the focus of a lot of the hostility and discomfort from the general population).

It’s a hypothesis that needs testing, more a hunch of mine than a proven phenomenon, of course, but I think it’s worth thinking about.

Lastly, “gay panic” is a legal device employed (sometimes successfully) in the defence of men who commit violent crimes against gay people. The contention is that when discovering someone is gay (or transgender — the use of this defence has transferred to the category of hate crime against trans people too), some people, in practice men, are overcome by an uncontrollable sense of panic that functions like temporary insanity and drives them to react violently and seek to destroy the cause of their panic by beating or killing that individual. In essence this defence legitimizes violence based on moral disgust, claiming that its visceral power is such that it can lead to irresistible defensive (and therefore aggressive) urges. Why these men don’t just run away if they’re scared, don’t ask me — I don’t think it’s a very convincing argument at all, rather an excuse to make male violence seem inevitable and unavoidable (what else is new, etc.).

I think when liberal feminists and transactivists talk about transphobia, they are accusing radical feminists of a type of “trans panic,” a desire to enact violence on or at least distance themselves from trans women based on a moral disgust associated with the uncanniness of their sometimes ambiguous presentation. I think this is a mistake: there is, as I was saying above, a rational argument to be made for the need for female-only spaces in all kinds of different situations, and radical feminists are seeking to make that argument, rather than simply deny trans people full rights and humanity out of a culpable, in the progressive worldview, sense of repugnance. I think that mistake leads people to respond to radical feminist argument the way Angela did: we react with “radfem panic,” a kind of moral disgust that “cannot fully be captured by argument,” but just is.

Why? What about women seeking to define, defend and police their own social and sexual boundaries causes that visceral, panicky reaction? It seems such an innocuous thing to ask: just leave us these small spaces. Go on with your lives, think, write, organize, work alongside us, ally with us, but respect our demand for some spaces where we would like to be alone. I mean, put like that, it seems completely incomprehensible to refuse, doesn’t it? Who else but women would be denied a small private space to discuss their experiences of childhood sexual trauma, for example? What can even be gained from breaching those boundaries and enforcing unwelcome inclusion in those spaces?

Welp, here’s what I think: I think (and I know this sounds a bit grandiose, but I’ve had a Big Emotions sort of weekend) that the argument between radical and liberal feminists about the inclusion of trans women in women-only spaces boils down to Angela’s reaction to my hand saying “Stop!” And the reason that happens is that the non-compliant woman falls, for many of us, into the uncanny valley of gender, just as much as the non-passing trans woman does. The woman who insists:

“I am not permeable, penetrable, all-containing. I have a border, a definition, a limit to my physical and psychic self which you are not allowed to enter. I contain an authentic subjectivity to which you are not privileged. I get to decide who to empathize with and who to reward with my nurture and my effort; you do not get to claim them as your due. I have an ‘I,’ a real and embodied experience which belongs only to me, which is understood only by me, which I insist must be controlled only by me. I am as fully human as a man. I am a person, and I demand you respect my personhood by respecting my right to set boundaries. Thou. Shalt. Not. Pass.”

That woman is a monster of sorts, an aberration for which we have no language. She is uncanny; she is neither a man nor fully a woman, for to be a woman is to be the opposite of all of the above. To be a woman is to be permeable, accommodating, open, inclusive. Femininity is inclusion. The aggressive hand raised in a gesture of prohibition is the antithesis of femininity, and to see someone like me, who for all other intents and purposes looks and acts like a woman, enact that transgression is disorienting and potentially frightening. All the more frightening when many women, whole groups of them, communities of women stand up and say: no more. We shall not contain. This is our space and we get to say who comes and goes here.

None of the above pertains necessarily to the hoary “are trans women women or not” debate. Who knows what a woman is? I sure don’t. A more badly defined concept hardly exists in the history of Western thought, mostly because for at least the last three millennia it was not considered worth bothering with. Everybody knew what a woman was: she was that formless Other that contains as its very function, the repository and source of all life, passive and mute in her fecundity. She has no right to ownership, because her borderlessness lets all property slip through and out. She has no right to know, because she cannot control what thoughts flow into her and what thoughts emanate. She has no right to say who comes and goes in her body and on her body and out of her body; her body’s function is only to receive and contain. She can only feel, and include.

When it turns out that other views are available, is it really a surprise that those views cause “rad-panic”?

Marina Strinkovsky is a feminist writer and campaigner who blogs at “It’s Not a Zero Sum Game”. Her main interests revolve around male violence against women, reproductive justice, sexual exploitation and rape (fun at parties). Marina has written for the New Statesman, the TSE and Indy Voices among others, and is currently working on a an edited collection provisionally titled ‘A Witch’s Dozen: Thirteen Essays in Contemporary Feminist Struggle’. She lives in Swindon with her one surviving cactus and, remarkably, no cats.

1 Michael Hauskeller, “Moral Disgust,” Ethical Perspectives, 13.4 (2006), 571-602

2 Dan Kahan, “Is Disgust a Uniquely ‘Conservative’ Moral Emotion?” The Cultural Cognition Project at Yale Law School (blog), 23 July 2013

3 “The Uncanny Valley,” Popular Science, YouTube, 30 September 2008; “Gay Panic Defense,” Wikipedia, last edited 8 September 2020, <>.