Issue One

Lesbian Body, Lesbian Life

by Allie Rogers

“naked in a shower of warm rain …”

This year I am turning 50. In the middle of the pandemic, I am living in a perimenopausal maelstrom. These are bodily times for me — sweat, tears, skipped periods that arrive, unexpected, in a sudden flood. But these are bodily times for us all, I suppose. The virus has brought a new relationship to the physical. Contact is a preoccupation — the loss of it, the longing for it, the transformation of it.

We contain our breath in cloth; wash and wash the hands we no longer use to touch each other; stand back, stand away, weigh risk. We meet friends, lovers, therapists, through the screen. We watch webcams of the places we miss. We mourn real life. We spend too much time online.

In much of my online time, I have been reading the words of detransitioners and desisters. Primarily young women, they are coming forward in ever-greater numbers to share their experiences. The last thing I want to do is to lay claim to those women’s stories or to misrepresent them. I would urge everyone to seek them out and to read what they share.

I read as a feminist: valuing the individual experiences and also looking for patterns that might explain to me how, and why, their journeys are unfolding in the way they are. I read as a lesbian: recognizing some of the challenges faced by young women now realizing themselves as lesbian too.

While the LGBTQ+ community expands along with its acronym, specifically lesbian spaces, community and culture seem harder to find now than they were 30 years ago — in this part of the world, at least. Young women recognizing their lesbianism are immersed in narratives of fluidity and inclusivity which claim the moral high ground as they rehearse arguments of political purity. Lesbianism, it seems, is acceptable only insofar as it remains open to all. Frankly, only insofar as it actually ceases to be lesbianism at all.

Alongside this, more than ever before, lesbian is a word that many teenagers will first meet in porn. The passionless encounters between women (hairless, glossy and disengaged) presented for the titillation of men (and which often involve the eventual arrival of a penis) have very little to offer young lesbians in understanding the true terrain of their sexuality.

But lesbian girls and young women continue to appear, of course, their paths strewn with new challenges and obstacles between themselves and the understanding of themselves. So, in a spirit of sisterhood and fair exchange with those young, courageous women who are speaking their truths, I offer some recollections and reflections, in the hope that my words may be of some use.

My focus in this piece will be on lesbianism as an embodied experience. These days you might be forgiven for thinking that sexuality is something chosen from a list on a screen, the selecting of a tick-box rather than the expression of desire. When young lesbians are harassed for having “genital preferences” it strikes me that the debate is happening on the level of online supermarket purchases. “Will you accept substitutions?” Nothing about it seems relevant to my own experiences. Where is passion? Where is desire?

At 15, in a large comprehensive school in Margaret Thatcher’s Britain, I fell for a female friend like falling off a cliff. I have a good memory, but I’m not simply relying on that to tell you this tale; I kept a diary. The entry for 18 June 1986 reads,

“Something wonderful, fascinating and terrifying has happened.”

You must forgive the intensity. I was a very intense teenager. But there it is, the moment that I realized

“… this is like nothing I’ve ever felt before, like no other crush.”

I think I was lucky to have that lightning-bolt moment. Of course, that’s not a universal thing for lesbians. For many of us, the realization comes more slowly as we struggle against the weight of assumed heterosexuality. For me, the power of the feelings left little room for doubt. But, along with the wonder and fascination, there was, of course, the terror.

For a start, there was my daily life at school to manage, where the atmosphere was generally hostile — a nerve-wracking environment of homophobic banter and constant low-level sexual harassment from boys. I knew that this was going to have to remain a secret and that the cost of being found out would be high. I thought it would cause worry for those who loved me and potential embarrassment for those I loved.

So, in that same diary entry, here is my shame:

“I’m so ashamed of this. I know I shouldn’t be, but I am. Still, the electricity is magic.”

Being raised in a progressive household, I didn’t believe that homosexuality was wrong. But, much like falling in love, it was something I knew about in a purely theoretical sense. When it was real, when it was in me, it was this powerful alchemical mix of a thing — it was electricity and it was shame. The two elements flared together in the crucible of my teenage self.

Recognizing that shame forms part of one’s sexuality is not unique to lesbian women. But for me, and I think for many other lesbians, the fusing of desire and shame was strong. Secrecy suggests shame, to ourselves as much as to others, and the secrecy wasn’t optional.

But, in spite of the complexity, I was enamoured of this new way of being. Four months after that first diary entry, a month after I turned 16, I recorded,

“I never knew I could feel so much, so golden, glowing …”

In fact, I think the strength of my feelings became, in some ways, as attractive to me as the girl I desired. With no outlet for any of this, little wonder that I filled the pages of my diary with my circling, obsessive thoughts.

I survived each school day by disconnecting as much as possible from the brutal reality of the place and sinking into elaborate daydreams. Once at home, I would snatch up my diary and write, to put my thoughts onto the paper and try to make sense of it all.

“God, I wish I had someone to talk to who understood the excitement of looking at a beautiful woman’s body from a woman’s body. Crazy, I know.”

Those words interest me because I was a very cerebral young person. If you had asked me, I would certainly have said that I existed in my brain. Suddenly something was alive in me that did not appear to live solely in my head. But, equally, it wasn’t just a genital thing. I’d been aware of my clitoris, and of orgasms, from the age of eight. But this was on another level, a whole-body experience.

The sense of bodily engagement was something I returned to again in another diary entry a few months later. I had bought myself a video of Joan Armatrading (I was an obsessive fan) and would watch it for hours. In a fairly rambling block of text, I wrote,

“This woman, I watch her with everything, and I can’t explain that. I don’t know what to say …”

I’m not surprised that, at 16, I couldn’t find the words to explain my experience of lesbian desire. At that point I still had not even kissed another girl, and I had never knowingly spoken to another lesbian. Nothing I had seen or read in the mainstream culture had properly communicated the holistic experience of desire, certainly not the desire of a woman for a woman. I had no one to ask, but, luckily for me, I was in the right place at the right time.

The mid-1980s were something of a heyday for lesbian feminist publishing. Of course, the only way to find those books was to go to small, independent bookshops. My first lesbian book was from Collets, a left-wing bookshop in Charing Cross Road in London. It was Incidents Involving Warmth by Anna Livia, published by Onlywomen Press. The tales of cool London dykes who lived in squats were quite a challenge to a schoolkid, but they were enticing. From there, my collection expanded rapidly when I found there were bookshops that sold lesbian books in my hometown. I read a lot of short stories, novels and poetry too.

In these books, I found women writing about this consuming, holistic passion I had found. My favourite poem, for a time, was in the anthology Naming the Waves (ed. by McEwen), published by Virago. By Sapphire, the poem was called “I guess if I was a sound or if I was your woman.” A long, joyous, sweet-souled celebration of love, it rolls on like a river, engaging every sense in a delicious stream, unbroken by punctuation. Here is a fragment:

if i was a touch
i’d be fur on a cat’s back
burlap     a silk sand
hot wet thing
if i was a sight i’d be
an African print gold hoop
brown round glorious
red bird a mirage
of mad things
if i was a smell
i’d be sesame oil
coconut natural
funky thing
i’d be flowers
and sweat
perfume and piss
manufactured and
real     i’d be a sweet
thing open
wide to your need
a bowl a river
to flow fill

is was just one poem in one collection and to truly explain the power and range of the literature I found would be a book in itself. I should note particularly that much of it was the work of Black women. In terms of the body, what I learned from lesbian feminist writing was that a rich, multifaceted, multisensory experience was integral to lesbian desire and to lesbian sex.

Realizing this as my right, that I could, would, did have an entitlement to the breadth and depth of my sexuality, was grounding in a way that I can’t overstate. Over the next few years, as I met my first lovers, I developed a relationship with my body that enabled me to live a lesbian life that has been full of adventures. Has it been perfect? No. It has been a life as messy as all lives are. But coming into this relationship with my body, through lesbian feminism, was a gift of immense value. In our bodies, in the full experience of our bodies, there is power.

Back there in the 1980s, as well as discovering lesbian literature, packed with magic words that helped me to understand myself, I also had the incredible good fortune, at just 16, to see the film Desert Hearts. I somehow managed to get into the local cinema, where I found not just Donna Deitch’s beautiful interpretation of Jane Rule’s classic of lesbian literature, but actual, real-life lesbians. That night, I wrote this:

“I was embarrassed by the strength of my desire watching that film, or at least I would have been if I hadn’t felt so happy. I felt like I was standing naked in a shower of warm rain … so relieved when I saw, not just on the screen, but all about me, women, real women happy to be themselves and to be in love with another woman. I felt like I was at home, putting on old jeans, comfortable and at ease.”

I didn’t speak to anyone that evening. But there they all were, and from then on, I knew it. I had found a lesbian community.

The truths of lesbian bodies, lesbian lives, are so easily marginalized and silenced. This has been the case for centuries, for millennia. As each generation beats a path through the omissions, distortions and outright lies, new versions are created to ensnare the next. But lesbians will continue to find their way, as women did before us. One of the most treasured lesbian novels of my youth was Patience and Sarah by Isabel Miller. It’s a story based on the real-life experiences of two women who escaped their families to live and farm together in early 19th century America. In their new home, in their bed, Sarah wonders at where they have found themselves:

“Where are we, high or deep? ‘Heaven,’ she says. We’re high then. We stay here so long, like gulls that don’t have to move to stay up.”

Allie Rogers is a Brighton-based writer of novels and short fiction. Her first book, Little Gold, published by Legend Press in 2017, was longlisted for the Author’s Club Best First Novel Award and shortlisted for the Polari First Book Prize. Her second novel, Tale of a Tooth, was published by Legend Press in 2018. Allie’s short fiction has appeared in a number of anthologies and magazines, including , Queer in Brighton> and the Salt Anthology of New Writing. She tweets as @alliewhowrites.