Issue One

RE: Framing Radical Feminism: The Plot Twist

by Esmée Streachailt

The first insight of radical feminism is that under patriarchy we do not know what women are. We do not know what the metaphysics of the feminine is, because patriarchy only presents us with a fantasy it calls femininity that serves its desires, both political and sexual. What our culture knows of women is what men collectively imagine of women: femininity, and that has nothing to do with actual living women. Radical feminists take the suppression of a feminine metaphysics to be the root of women’s oppression through these many ages. Radical means “of or to the root,” getting to the base or bottom of things. One of those roots is the assignment of the mind/humanity/subjectivity to man and of the body/materiality/objectivity (being an object) to woman. Clearly, some ideological sleight of hand is at play.

Betty Friedan, a sociologist and journalist, as well as philosophers like Luce Irigaray and Mary Daly set themselves the task of describing the gender system that supports patriarchy. They then attempt the task of beginning to describe Women and the feminine on their own terms materially, phenomenologically, and ontologically, from their own experience as white American and European women.1 One place to begin an exploration of their radical feminisms is in one of the more obvious expressions of the gender system, psychoanalysis.

TURNS OUT JACQUES LACAN WAS BAD IN BED

In popular discussions on Twitter and Tumblr, the terms post-structural and postmodern tend to be used and accused interchangeably. I like to think of them this way: the postmodern is a historical formation that tends to be conformist, depressive, post-industrial, and technologically advanced; and post-structuralism is a complex school of thought dedicated to analysing the postmodern as a problem. In this scheme, Lacan is a postmodernist (indeed, a student of Modernist intellectuals like Lévi-Strauss, Saussure, and Freud), while his student Luce Irigaray is post-structuralist. (A much too simple scheme, but we need a scaffolding, and this is mine.) I’ve had a time of it determining just where in the glittering constellation of juicy-sharp options to begin this overview of radical feminism, so I’ve opted to start with the written transcripts of seminars given by Lacan.2 Luce Irigaray both reads and reads Lacan back at himself in “Cosí Fan Tutti” from This Sex Which Is Not One. With some flair, she reads him much the way the press now quotes President Trump back at himself. I’m starting us here because lots of profound feminist critique is grounded in post-structural approaches to philosophy and cultural or social critique, including of psychoanalysis.

It’s important to note that by the time Lacan gives these seminars, Maslow’s work on dominance in female personalities, Friedan’s popularization of that work, and all of the research of both Masters & Johnson and Kinsey had been published, and made it quite clear that women experience many kinds of pleasure and can be perfectly articulate about its many textures.3 Lacan, however, as a titan of psychoanalysis, is not really interested in women, their articulation, or their pleasure. He is interested in a “truth,” and that truth is that whatever women are lies beyond the limits of logic, language. That truth must lie beyond knowing because admitting a non-patriarchal feminine into the system disrupts the neat logic of Structuralist approaches to the mind and language.4 That truth must lie beyond knowing, Irigaray points out, because whatever the feminine (the nature or expression of women) may be it “occurs only within models and laws devised by male subjects.”5 The model is a “phallic one,” a masculine imaginary sharing the values of a patriarchal society that honors “property, production, order, form, unity, visibility … and erection” (p. 86). Woman/the feminine has only ever operated as the ground or resource for this phallocentric economy, and phallocratic social structure. For Lacan, and for Freud, woman has value only in so far as a man loves/acknowledges her. It’s a bit Victorian, feudal. For Lacan, there is no reality before its description, before the discourse about it, and all discourse has been “prescribed by male subjects for centuries” (p. 87), so his problem is that he would like to find the truth about something (women, their pleasure) using a set of tools (the tropes of patriarchal myth and religion) that has refused for centuries to define women and their pleasure other than in terms useful to men and patriarchy. At a deep cultural level, the language that matters to men cannot hear or read what-women-are beyond what-men-want-to-see. No wonder he’s frustrated. “Man seeks her out,” but given that his whole cultural history has “inscribed her in discourse … as lack, as fault or flaw,” she is not there. There is no prediscursive reality to refer to when, as he says in his lecture hall, “We are speaking about fucking — a verb in French, foutre — and we are saying that it’s not working” (p. 88). I mean, of course it’s not working. If fucking has anything to do with enjoying, Lacan describes that relation as “one body that is enjoying a part of the Other’s body” who may or may not also enjoy but who “cannot remain indifferent” to being enjoyed (p. 92). A part. Of the Other’s body. No wonder this is not working. How many times must we be taken apart and reshaped by patriarchal logics, the logic of the phallus, before we will finally signify — that is become legible as — human? How, “how many times are we going to have to be cut into “parts,” “hammered,” “recast” … in order to become sufficiently signifying,” Irigaray asks in the exasperated tone that so many feminists, eventually, express. Call it “peak Lacan.” 

And yet, “Fortunately, there are women,” asking questions, making demands, getting off. Woman may not exist, per se, but she still “threatens” — as a sort of “prediscursive reality” — to disrupt [the patriarchal] order. We do this by being “this sex which is not one,” not one organ, not one unity, not singular, not linear/phallic/logical, etc. “Female sexuality has always been conceptualized on the basis of masculine parameters,” the passivity of the vagina, and all that (p. 23). In the Freud-Lacan logic, the clitoris is a little penis, atrophied organ, where as in prediscursive (material) reality “woman has sex organs more or less everywhere,” her sexual geography being “far more diversified, more multiple in its differences, more complex, more subtle,” than the phallic economies of men’s ideas about femininity and women’s sexuality can signify (p. 28).

Where Freud and Lacan are troubled that “woman does not have a sex organ,” Irigaray notes that she has at least two, multiples; and more threatening still, she does not have to choose between clitoris or vagina in order to please herself as man is said to choose between his hand and a woman’s vagina (the reductionism, the screaming heteronormativity, is problematic on so many levels). Freud’s logic is about binaries: sex with the woman is “mature” and better than sex with the hand which is “immature” and worse, just as men are “human” and better than women who are “other” or “Other” and worse. The value assignment is what makes a natural (even pleasurable) dichotomy into a binary, or system of supremacy. Lacan follows this line of thinking inflected by Freud and Structuralism. Anyway. Woman has a lot of sexually pleasurable/pleasuring organs: our breasts, the lips of our vulva, our mouths, the posterior wall of our vaginas, our cervixes, and our clitoris — the only organ on the human body designed by evolution solely to produce pleasure (p. 30). 

With so many points of potential erogenous excitement, points that interact with each other when actualized (thank you vagal nerve!), it makes a discursive kind of sense that women’s descriptions of pleasure, and the imaginary space required to describe ourselves, will shape itself differently to that of a man and his imaginary. Bodies, clearly, do not determine discursive style — e.g. all the experimental writing by men — but they do, as nature does for culture, serve as a base of inspiration. We may only understand them “inside of discourse,” but they are very much there nonetheless, hanging out in that prediscursive space called material reality — where a lot of fucking actually happens. 

To pause over a concept: the imaginary is a term of art meaning the “space” of imagination, whether personal or cultural, conscious or unconscious, in which reality can be made fantasy, and vice versa. It’s where the ideas we have about things are made, whether they are inspirations, subversions, projections, illusions, or delusions. The imaginary is dynamically related to the symbolic and the real, with the symbolic being the “space” of discourse, culture, law, reason, meaning. Sometimes, the whole history of these things is referred to as the symbolic, sometimes as the imaginary with the histories of these things acting as an engine, a kind of universal unconscious for the symbolic. The real is equally slippery in that it can refer both to material reality and nature or to stuff and things, and to essences, or ideal truths, or Platonic forms. That we are so confused today about what “cultural conventions” are or the difference between gender and sex tells me that some folks have been doing a very poor job of teaching these ideas indeed. The mistake is to think of these concepts as things or territories, rather than the mutually affecting phenomena or operations that they are. Again, this is too simple by half, but we need a scaffolding, and this is mine.

So, back to Lacan. In the masculine/phallic imaginary, woman is the (lesser, negative) other of man, and has another logic, too. This other logic reads as “hysterical” from inside patriarchal logic and its centuries of sedimented meaning. In this economy of ideas and of property, and of spirit, and of thought — called the symbolic — woman is “traditionally of use value for man.” In the phallic symbolic, she is exchanged or competed for as a resource for the extraction of pleasure, heirs, labour, care — even ideas he might pillage and put his name on. What radical feminism points to is that unless women make our place, make an imaginary and symbolic for ourselves, strike off along the multiple filaments of desire/pleasure that are ours to weave, history will repeat, will revert to a “sameness: a phallocractism [that] would leave room neither for women’s sexuality, nor for women’s imaginary, nor women’s language” (p. 33). We have indeed begun to articulate the feminine imaginary and effect a female real. Our work in every field, each book, study, performance, builds the presence of this imaginary out into the symbolic and meaning. The spaces, words, styles and logics women are only beginning to develop for ourselves in the last decades are always threatened and even as they are necessary for moving humanity into a world that does not repeat the mistakes of men, again, and again. 

My sense of radical feminism is that any institution, or corporation, or industry, or artifact, or person who would take women for a commodity or resource is enacting patriarchy’s patterns and therefore is a patriarchal subject. If it walks, talks, makes policy, or tweets like a patriarch, it’s a patriarch. If someone attempts to coerce women into their preferred behaviour: how to dress, whom we may or may not marry, with whom and how to have sex, where and when to work, whether and what we may learn—any of these is patriarchy, sexism, and often misogyny. Woman. Man. Transgender people. Religious authorities. Politicians. Who behaves like a patriarch is one and is supporting patriarchy, which is the historical and ongoing structural oppression of women on the basis of our sex.

Lacan cannot understand any of this, or can’t hear it. He’s angry that — and remember, the text Irigaray is quoting is a lecture Lacan gave, in a classroom, to students — that “we have been begging them, begging them on our knees [women analysts]” to describe women’s pleasure, and yet “on the subject of female sexuality, our lady analyst colleagues tell us … they haven’t made the slightest progress on the question of female sexuality.” Though it’s clear they’ve told him something, something that doesn’t serve his ends because Lacan exclaims that women can call it “whatever they like, that vaginal pleasure, they talk about the rear pole of the opening of the uterus and other bullshit, that’s the word for it” (p. 90). He means that when women say that a source of sexual pleasure is the stimulation of the cervix, that’s bullshit. 

As I said, we can see why it’s not working.

If there can be no (reportable, observable, and importantly overdetermined pleasure, there can be no libido or desire. For psychoanalysis, no desire means no person. Woman, Lacan reasons, cannot want man: “the libido is only masculine, it is only from that [point of view] where she is whole, the dear woman — that is to say, from that place where man sees her, and only from there — that the dear woman can have an unconscious.”6 Let me de-theory that sentence for you. Woman is only “whole” from the point of view of Man’s desire because she has no desire of her own, even her unconscious is his unconscious. Hence, it is only from inside Man’s fantasy of her that she can have any unconscious, or libido, and only on his terms.7 Now, in psychoanalysis, to have an unconscious is to have the resources from which to build, in short, a self. So, no unconscious means no ability to form a consciousness, so no actual person. Thus, no subject who can speak (clearly) about herself other than as man defines/describes her to herself. Not only is cervical pleasure bullshit, so is the notion that women might have a sense of their own being that is not given to us by men/the patriarchy. No desire, no imaginary, no symbolic means no being. Only femininity.

And so, I submit to you, that Lacan was probably a terrible lay.

THE RUB

Since the first rule of patriarchy is that men are replete and women are their negative shadow, materially and metaphysically, this not-knowing what women are presents a problem for men. Men do not know what it is they are superior to. The replete being is unstable. This trap he sets for her in the gender system creates a fundamental insecurity in the ideology of male supremacy. Oh irony, thy name is woman (as man has given it to you).

At the same time, since the collective masculine imaginary supposes itself superior to a projection of its own making, actual women cannot successfully conform to it. The Male Gaze does not see and the femininity it projects does not suit actual women. The gender system is an ideology — a “knowledge” that proceeds from idea to myth to interpretation to analysis and back to idea without ever touching the earth. It’s both an idealism and an overdetermination. The supremacist element, however, means that nonconformity to the “feminine mystique” can only be coded as women’s treason, hysteria, or witchcraft and must be punished for threatening the identity and power of men.8

BRIEFLY, WHAT IS AN IDEOLOGY?

Super quick! An ideology is a set of beliefs that are, or seek to be, elaborated into a system of power. Crucially, ideology is based on ideas that are not reasoned up out of material reality. When Lacan says that there is no “prediscursive reality” we must perk up to the presence of ideology. The system of power that expresses an ideology need not be a government. It can be a culture, a subculture, a religion, a cult, a utopia. It’s “grounded” in ideas rather than actual ground. The more consummate the ideology, the more resistant it will be to material evidence and contesting interrogation. So, Lacan has a hard time hearing about women’s bodies because they are not reporting what his ideas about women say they should. 2 + 2 = 5 only holds on pain of torture or death, and that is why autocrats have to disappear so many people. Ideologies tend to overdetermine their results in this way. Ideology takes its goal for its givens and proceeds from there, generally by crushing resistance to it. Ideologies are not political systems or party platforms, but both can be made to serve an ideology. To people who are well served by an ideology, it will feel natural. Neoliberalism is an ideology. White supremacy is an ideology. American exceptionalism is an ideology. Male superiority is an ideology. They are backed up by political systems (democracy, socialism, communism) and violence (state, economic, international, interpersonal) because they are merely ideas and not realities that different people might examine and agree upon and from there develop a shared course of action. They can change their spots, unlike leopards, and they can deny themselves with their own mouths, like QAnon for example, because they are immaterial. They are ever shifting signifiers. Empty, but not powerless. This gossamer is shot through with tear gas, barbed-wire-wrapped baseball bats, and cluster munitions — make no mistake. Thus, when feminists refer to science to claim there is such a thing as biological sex and to history to claim that we are oppressed on the basis of our sex, feminists are making a factual claim that can be tested. When a gender identitarian denies that by saying that sexed bodies (rather than, or just like, gender) are a social construction, we must perk up to the presence of ideology. 

WHY BEGIN BY DISSING A FAMOUS PSYCHOANALYST?

Because Irigaray pays Lacan the compliment of letting him stand in for nearly the whole inheritance of Western Civilization’s patriarchal intelligencia. It’s a history of ideas to which he lays claim, so she holds him very tightly to it. She studied under him around the time that radical feminism was digging in for purchase against the ongoing and intolerable entitlements of the post-World War II patriarchal man. Lacan gives us the Law of the Father, abstracted into the idea that the symbolic Phallus is the guarantor of language and sense-making.9 Since it’s a concept, it could be anything really. But Lacan writes his meaning up from the male body into his theory. The Phallus is the sign of Reason.

I know. It’s a little ridiculous when you just write it flat out like this. 

Also, it’s fun to punch up. When Lacan read her dissertation, now published as Speculum of the Other Woman, he understood it for the critique of him-as-avatar-of-patriarchy that it was, realized it was dangerous as fuck, and dismissed her from the program.10 This exile from intellectual circles in Paris meant that many of her contemporaries would steer clear of her for a long time, much the way we see when a woman goes up against a powerful man and loses today. And it is hard to overstate Lacan’s influence over the French intellectual world in the 1960s. Patriarchy is always only up to the same old thing — always already shunning women who tell the truth—whether by social punishment or corporate arbitration clauses.

But mostly, I begin here because Irigaray’s This Sex Which Is Not One is a germinal text of radical feminism, along with Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique, Mary Daly’s canon.11 These women never met, and they don’t constitute a school of thought, and they probably would not have liked or understood each other, and they are not unproblematic in every element of their work. They are, nonetheless, a few of the women responsible for the approximately six decades of work across the fields of philosophy, biology, sociology, theology, archeology, literary theory, cultural critique, poetry and fiction to political movements that comprise the long history of contemporary feminist thought. They are also, often, lightning rods for ire and derision in current schools of activism that support and defend intersectional approaches to liberation. Some of these critiques are fair. For any philosopher or creative, there is only so far their one mind will get them, they will come to a limit, and they will choose a focus if they mean to be effective. These three women did not address race or queerness or colonialism. Their object of critique was the history and lived experience of Woman and of Patriarchy as Western culture’s bedrock. Their ideas only get so far, and then we get to work out which to drop and which to develop for our projects now, in our moment, as we imagine our own liberations. 

I began with Lacan qua abusive-father because while Irigaray is taking him to task for a rather lazy misogyny, she is also developing his concepts of “the imaginary” and “the symbolic” and “the real” into differently articulated concepts that let her work out insights and theories about sexual difference. And for me, sexual difference is one of the many kinds of “différance” deployed by post-structuralists in their pitched battle with the fascist underpinnings of the desert they perceived in postmodernity.12

Différance is a force that jams the ideology behind Build That Wall. It opens flows of possibility where identity wants to shut down and solidify. To all instances of This Is Certain, différance says, “sure, maybe, but there’s more, and then more.” To Lacan’s “phallus” Irigaray presents the “différance” of women’s sex which is not one.

For me, difference and sexual difference are two impulses or concepts that can help us crack out of this stultifying historical accretion and its present horrors. What post-structuralists call the logic or law of the same, or of the phallus, is this idea that man is one and woman is his negative. A binary. A and ~A. But, as soon as you have one difference, you have an interval between two subjects, A and B. And from the intermixture of A and B all of the differences can articulate themselves and enliven each other. From the merger of two gametes, X and Y chromosomes of the animal kingdom, come the overwhelming variety of life. Once there’s two, there’s variation and evolution of mammalian life. Where there’s two, the fucking might be working. Where there’s only A and ~A, well, tant pis

How we will all live into our liberation and flourishing is yet to be seen, but this much is clear to me: we only get liberated by living into our specificity, our particular ways of being human, however complexly manifested, and then by deeply honouring our differences at personal, social, and cultural levels — so long as those differences are on the side of liberation and well-being. Repetitions of the law of the same (male, white, European supremacy), with its misrecognition and erasure, only obscure and impede liberation.

Humanity is running up against some very real “prediscursive” limits — limits to natural resources, to economic growth, to the ecology’s ability to tolerate our techno-industrial pillaging. As I write this, new calculations move the hellscape of climate collapse to well within this century.13 Recent calculations assert that the Greenland Ice Sheet will melt completely, no matter what we do now. The ocean will rise, billions of people will have to move away from it. Whole peoples and cultures will be forever disrupted if not lost entirely. Just like most of ancient Alexandria is in the Mediterranean, but everywhere. We have three responses to this sense of foreclosure. One is a kind of freezing in the face of its totality. This fear response deserves every care. Another is to pillage and extract as much wealth as possible and set oneself up a fiefdom well upland, or to get off world, leave Earth to the rabble. To these I wish fire and wind. A third impulse is to throw everything we have into liberation projects that seek to protect existence and flourishing. The vital impulse we’re all feeling is a desire to turn a world-historical corner. We’re in a struggle for a new paradigm, a new hegemony, one that is much more flexible, accountable, and generative than the millennia of patriarchal-colonial-capitalist hegemony that evolved over the last centuries to be Eurocentric, white supremacist, heteronormative and almost wholly extractive in its imagination, desire, and re/production. This old world is struggling to hang on. But, we see the corner-turning in the uncertainty of churn, the glorious refusal of any of these movements to relent. There is robust hope in our insistence. But, a caution. My study of the history of ideas and political history shows me that all revolutions are born among oppressed classes who become willing to impose their hegemony by any means necessary. And time again, they reproduce the horrors of the previous regime. Revolution, as a simple negation, tends to lead to the reproduction of the Same (old thing). It is not necessarily liberating. We see it in the neo-populist and nationalists/nativist regimes digging in around the world. In the US, we see the ramping up of drilling and fracking and the appropriation of Indigenous land and national parks for extractive mineral production. We see it in the recalcitrance to justice claims and articulated programs to address structural racism and structural misogyny. We see it in the insultingly slow response to justice demands made by queer, transgender, disabled and indigenous peoples around the world. 

I don’t think we want that: to trade one totalizing ideology for another. All systems created without reference to what is and what came before become totalitarian and sacrificial. These people wind up enforcing their order and defending their existence with all manner of force and domination aimed at “others” who threaten the new regime either in their foreignness or their values. 

And what, really, would be new about that? 

It is a trick of patriarchal hegemony over society, culture, meaning, that all reversals return to the Same. As Irigaray put it, all theories of the subject return to the masculine. I hope that our moment is deconstructive more than revolutionary. I hope our moment is not one of choosing to “keep or cancel” but of discovering “how and what can we grow from the old and present worlds that helps us move into something new.” Bearing in mind that “new” is not a cozy world for perfect comfort and the absence of all irritation. Difference and liberation seek a new cadre of problems and modes of solution. If the old world is basically extractive and self-interested, the new one wants to be generative, restorative, and mutually interested. This is no simple thing. Creating it comes with problems.

SO, WHAT IS RADICAL FEMINISM?

To move toward a future that is not the past, I begin again with the first insight of radical feminism: under patriarchy, we have no idea what women are. Lacan’s skepticism regarding female pleasure and subjectivity is just one instance of the encompassing structure of life — the habitus — in which women/femininity are projections thrown forth by men (collectively, and singularly). The very work of regimes of femininity is to obscure from everyone what women really are in all our variety—beings we have long been in the process of imagining and liberating through a collection of efforts called the feminist/women’s movement. Radical feminism is a liberation project that seeks to abolish the gender system because it is damaging to men and women in body and mind, and we just don’t need it. We can suppose, radical feminism claims, that we have some idea what men are, since they built this habitus and do very little to change it no matter what harm it does even to men in the forms of homophobia, colonization, class oppression, transphobia, or structural racism. Radical feminism does not take up the work of helping men reform. We leave men to work on their implication in patriarchy. Men will compete, even go to war, for control of the patriarchal world and its resources, while the patriarchy itself, the system which requires the war, goes untouched. Men vie for control of the resources for extraction, including from other men, but not to remake the civilization that operates through control and extraction. It seems to suit men (mostly heterosexual men, but not exclusively) well enough. It’s a hard bloc to challenge, the bloc that can cloak itself in History, Nature, Tradition, Civilization.

Radical feminism is a tool for smashing this complacency in its most elemental or archetypal form: the myriad iterations of delusional sexist bullshit and damage called the gender system. It is one among a number of feminisms, each intentionally developed to address patriarchy’s many strategies for subjugating whomever and whatever might destabilize its power in any given era or area of the human world. Black Feminism/Womanism. Eco-feminism. Lesbian Separatist Feminism. Liberal Feminism. Postcolonial Feminism. Psychoanalytic Feminism. Queer Feminism. Suffragist Feminism. Socialist Feminism. Abolitionist Feminism. And the several waves. And more schools. And Intersectional Feminism, created by black women intellectuals and activists of the Combahee River Collective, as a methodology to address the interlocking oppressions of women by sex/sexuality/race/class/age/ability by drawing on and developing the strongest insights, strategies, and points of cooperation among these of many liberation projects. Ideally. What radical feminism was not made to analyse or include were most of these other feminisms, or the several kinds of difference that are grouped in the adjective “transgender.” Radical feminism addresses itself to the metaphysics and politics of that element that runs through all these feminisms: women.

All schools of thought have limits whether due to historical horizons or political commitments. That is, in fact, a good thing. A system so old and entrenched we mistake it for nature, and so pervasive and violent that we mistake it for divinity, must be confronted on many sides at once. Patriarchy can go at one challenger hammer and tongs. The many justice movements, working separately and jointly as tactics require, in support of many kinds of women whose experiences are tempered by other supremacies and norms—these can surround patriarchy by addressing the many locks that enclose us. So, this introduction of a few radical feminists is meant to help open possibility and leverage all our glorious differences against the walls patriarchy uses to contain our becoming in its image of and use for us. Fight to get to the center? Nope. Difference as a fact, and as a tool, burns centers and walls, leaves us each free to and mutually responsible for imagining our next world. Outward!

Radical feminism invites us to engage the work of change like that of all complex justice movements, those that have a robust dynamic of critique and creation of history, philosophy, the arts, politics and economics. Radical feminism asks us to investigate the ways that patriarchy as a system of male supremacy has configured sex through gender in a complex of politically and psychologically motivated ideologies divorced from nature and evidence—projections and lies. These configurations are maintained through various kinds of systemic violence and cultural production that radical feminists seek to expose and transfigure toward a world of différance more completely suited to human complexity.

But first: The Gender System.

 

THE COMMONLY ACCEPTED PARAMETERS OF BEING A WOMAN 14

Girls are pink, like pink, pink is the only colour for girls and for girls only. I know this because the Girls’ aisle in Target or Tesco is very, very pink. Fun fact about pink, it’s thought to have a calming effect on one’s mood or nervous state. The walls of many US prisons are painted pink to help the incarcerated people there comply. Pink = Sedation? Maybe. The pinking and blueing of gender is relatively new, and has not always been so configured. Yes, there is the pop star Pink, and everything about her themes and performance makes an irony of her name. Pink is a parameter.

This kind of parameter enforces biological essentialism: the view that gender arises naturally from sex. To think in an essentialist way would be to say that girls like pink because pink is sweet and girls are sweet because they have vulvas. Boys do not have vulvas, so they cannot like pink. To think essentially, in an essentialist way, would be to say that women’s oppression arises from our sex as naturally as our sex makes us (on the whole) capable of pregnancy. Our sex makes us capable of pregnancy, which naturally requires the nurture of children, so women are naturally nurturing and fit for motherhood, and should take care of everyone, and not mind being confined to the home (where the care happens) or being paid less (because professional work is not natural to us) or even told that the word that designates us, “Woman,” should be expanded to include biological men because we are so caring and giving and nurturing how could we possibly mind, it would be unnatural . Clearly, the cultural attachment of “caring” and “needing restriction” is laid onto our bodies with motive, not as a cooperation with our nature. Essentialism drove the 19th century belief that women are less intellectually capable than men because we have shorter (and this shit is real) femurs.15 Women have shorter femurs (on average) than men and fewer women are educated (by design) than men, so femur length equals intellectual capacity, which justifies women’s exclusion from education and the professions. Does this sound at all familiar? Essentialism is a parameter. It might be growing strategically desperate, but it’s still a parameter.

Pink and essentialist discourse are both elements in the enculturation (social training) of girls and women into femininity. Femininity, to put this more strongly, is the essentialist discourse about women that enforces our oppression on the basis of sex. And femininity is an invention of patriarchy, and its manners, laws, and violence are how it is enforced. Femininity arises out of the patriarchal imaginary and becomes reified into “identity” and “role.” Right? Biological sex and its common names of “female” and “woman” designate the real. Femininity and womanhood arise from the imaginary and vary across cultures and time. And patriarchy reifies womanhood into custom, tradition, law, and force in the symbolic — which have real effects when applied to the bodies of women, and there’s part of the inter-affectation of these elements of signification. Ta-da, meaning.

Essentialism is the idea that all this arises naturally from the female bodies of women, and essentialism ignores all the reification and rulemaking that enforce it. Changes to the imaginary and the symbolic can be created and contested and eventually settled into new forms we call historical change. Replace the real with the imaginary, or the symbolic, and meaning is knocked out of all orbits, to be enforced, in the final analysis, only by raw power. That’s why it’s a gesture associated with fascism to ask us to believe what we are told, not what we see or experience. Femininity is imagined by patriarchy and encloses women in the commonly accepted parameters of being a woman. Femininity is all the parameters.

Femininity, not femaleness, is assigned to women. It is not innate, it is not born in us, we are not feminine at birth. It relates in no necessary way to our personalities or preferences. We are female humans. Female human mammals. Mammals include bats, whales, mice, cats, cows, sheep, dogs, monkeys, horses, deer, apes, meerkats, and people. They are classed as mammals because the females of each species feed their young from mammary glands. In human females, these are called breasts. This is biology. And femininity is gender. This is culture. It’s the negative pole of the gender system that women are encouraged to accept into their psyches. Femininity is taught into female people. For example, in the way girls are punished for expressing anger or shamed for strong opinion while these are accepted in boys. Enculturation and performance are no trifles. We are rewarded for living within its parameters with an unstable and illusory safety from the violence any man can do to us at any time. Moreover, we are taught that if we are targets of this violence we are at fault for not performing our femininity correctly. This is victim blaming: why did you drive there, what were you wearing, hadn’t you slept with him before? Victim blaming happens to unlucky and insubordinate women alike: tomboys, intellectuals, witches, independent women, bisexual and lesbian women, women who find themselves alone in an elevator with a male coworker. The gender system renders female people dependent upon male people for their protection (from other males — the triangulation is baked-in) so that males can extract from women resources they enjoy or need: personal care, professional assistance, affection, sexual intercourse, management of the domestic sphere, and heirs/children. Femininity is a sexually available housekeeper, personal assistant, and nanny.

It’s 2020 and the hip hop artists Cardi-B and Megan Thee Stallion released the single “WAP,” a gloriously unapologetic and campy display of heterosexual female desire, initiation, and control of sexual experience. It’s camp is on the same scale as that of glam rock bands in the 1980s. Every lyric is a command to the male lover. Many of them complimentary, but commands nonetheless. “When I’m ridin ya / I’m gonna spell my name” is a lot of gender-fucking in one line. Both their femaleness and their blackness make this song transgressive, though this song is not the first in this tradition. The wet ass pussy they celebrate is no passive void, no blank on which another’s desire can be “written.” That the song and its performance are perceived by so many as a transgression is how you know it ran up against a parameter of womanhood.

The male body does the enjoying in patriarchy. The male body with the right to enjoyment is also a white body. Black female bodies are particularly enjoined for their pleasure. No, the parameter is not only the “dirty” word “pussy.” These artists chose not to take responsibility for the way patriarchy and The Male Gaze turn the movements and gestures of female pleasure against us as parody and weapon. Cardi B and Megan Thee Stallion know that. There is a wink in this performance, in each twerk and thrust. The wink says, we know this is salacious, we know this will frighten and anger, we do not give a fuck, but we will take one. The only more subversive version of this song I can imagine just now would be a bardcore version from Hildegard von Blingin.16

Remember, chez Lacan, a (male) body is to enjoy a part of an Other (female) body that probably won’t enjoy itself but will be forced to notice that it is being enjoyed. This song is not about that kind of fucking. It’s an answer to the tens of thousands of songs by men about their desire, their conquest. America has lost its damn mind fearing for the moral and sexual propriety of its young women lest they enjoy their lust incorrectly.17 Saints forbid we control our own sexual experience. The girls might reject the boys who don’t make them wet. And then, where would so many boys be?18

Lacan is correct that whatever he thinks women are in the Discourse of the Phallus has nothing at all to do with love. Or women. Or our sexuality. No wonder the fucking isn’t working. Love requires difference, and he can’t admit difference into his system.

The radical feminist critique of this set up is that female people are trained from youth to keep their expectations and their behaviour well within the commonly accepted parameters of femininity. This is the meaning of de Beauvoir’s old chestnut, “One is not born, but rather one becomes a woman.” Becoming a woman, in 2020, still means batting your eyelashes, demurely pretending you have no idea what pleases you, the better not to interrupt a man’s overdetermined narrative about the fucking you are about to do for him. The radical feminist critique of this set up extends to the history of civilizations, philosophy, literature, the sciences, economics, medicine, and popular culture. These parameters of womanhood are built into society at every level.

They are designed to do one thing: make sure women don’t know ourselves and keep men in tacit and explicit control of us. Being nice is a parameter. It functions to coerce women into denying themselves for the benefit of others/men.

When a transgender identitarian tells women to just go with the commonly accepted parameters of womanhood, they are telling women to accept patriarchy’s use of us. They are acting like patriarchs, so I respond to them as patriarchs. Critically.

Being nice, pink, soft, welcoming, open, accommodating, gentle, easily pushed over, unthreatening — these traits render women more susceptible to the culturally holistic workings of misogyny. Femininity is the negative pole of the gender system in which compliant women perform all the ways patriarchy hates us. Make no mistake, the qualities our cultures train into women are qualities it despises in men and punishes men for embodying. The patriarchal gender system as we have known it teaches women to embody qualities that it teaches men to hate, especially in themselves. The category “man” is not being asked to expand to include any element of femininity in the new era of gender wars.

It’s 2020, the year of COVID-19, when most essential workers are women of colour. These are women who are actually holding our world together in a new pandemic that’s killing both people and economies. Talk about valuable labour. In a recent series, “In Her Words: 7 Issues, 7 Days,” The New York Times explored some of the structural sexism that still disadvantages and endangers women. Cars, specifically their safety features, are not designed with women’s bodies in mind, “a female involved in a crash is 47 percent more likely to be seriously injured and 17 percent more likely to die.” From cars to medicine, “Women are sometimes described as a confounding factor.”19 Design and scientific experiment can, obviously, be made to account for women’s bodies, our hormones, etc. They simply do not choose to develop ways to account for these anomalies, these externalities—women. Of course, that which you do not learn about and which yet exists is confounding.

Woman, so exploitable, so mysterious. This is the gender system and the structural sexism in which women’s bodies are beyond the pale.

And the people who adhere to this system hate us for what? They hate us both for obedience and for insubordination to commonly accepted parameters of womanhood. For performing our gender badly, or well. That a high compliment for a woman now is that she is “fuckable” demonstrates the hatred poisoning so much male heterosexuality. Radical feminism is the critique of that gaslighting, and it is the reclamation of the traces of real women’s being we can find in history. Radical feminism is the imagination of the future of what actual women might actually be. That female being has no known parameters other than the biological limitation imposed by lower levels of testosterone than men. That is why culture and law work so very hard not to lift those parameters. It’s why the Taliban shot Malala Yousafzai for going to school. It’s why the American Republican Party is still angry at Secretary Hillary Clinton for those emails. It’s why 58% of American women “just don’t like her.” It’s why female sex-selective abortion is so common in India. It’s why Mexico does nothing about the tens of thousands of disappeared girls and women. It’s why there are such phenomena as revenge porn, Men’s Rights Activists, and incels. The idea, the gall of the notion, that men should be given access to women’s bodies, whether the women consent or not, as a matter of law and practice — and that noncompliant women should be killed—is unimaginable in a world where femininity is mere performance, where gender is just an identity. We don’t live in that world. Femininity and masculinity have real stakes. One in Five goes the refrain. We also don’t live the post-feminist future where instead of gender we will have personality, selfhood, interests.

A US Department of Justice study published in 2009 shows a total of 551,590 women reported sexual or other violence by their intimate partners.20 That is the number of simple assaults, aggravated assaults, robberies, and rape/sexual assaults committed against women by intimate partners. That’s not the whole number for all violence against women (a staggering number).21 A 2005 study of 572 men in a rural county in Iowa (so, mostly white, sleepy-bucolic-small-town America—the heartland) found that 13.6% of those men had committed at least one act of physical violence against their wives/partners in the previous year.22 I’m not going to rehearse the statistics. Quick searches bring up good sources for that. The bill that would reauthorize the Violence Against Women Act (which funds shelters and other services) was introduced to the House of Representatives in March of 2019, passed in April, and STILL LANGUISHES unaddressed by the Senate as I write this in August of 2020 because the majority leader, Senator Mitch McConnell, will not let it to the floor for a vote.23 That’s one reason we do not have more recent numbers on violence against US women. It is one of the over 200 bills he says constitute “the Nancy Pelosi agenda,” cue angry MAGA chants. Anyway, the catalogue is deep. I just want to make clear what I mean when I say that gender is a power system with real stakes. Common parameters.

One more, why not, since it’s about women’s access to redress in the law. It’s 2020, and in New York State, The National Women’s Law Center is co-filing an amicus brief in a case in which a woman filed a police report on her attacker, and he filed a defamation suit in retaliation. It’s like revenge porn, but in court. Christina was attacked in her car by a coworker who followed her out of a work social. The court:

held that she was not entitled to New York’s protections for people who report [sexual] misconduct solely because sexual assault was the type of misconduct she reported. Specifically, the court said that her reports of sexual assault are so “extravagant” that it could “infer” Christina might be both spiteful and a liar The court also said that Christina could have lied about the sexual assault to advance her career.24

INFER. Oh, yes indeed.

This dehumanization, this lazy misogyny that leans back on tropes about women’s dishonesty and avarice, this breezy denial of the daily and ubiquitous violence of men, these are the commonly accepted parameters of womanhood. The full-face makeup, tight or flowing gown, the platform heels — that’s glitter.

Glitter is not sex, not lived experience. Decorating oneself for the Male Gaze is not experiencing the feminine gender. Gender is a system of control, and its ultimate expressions are both violent and randomized. We encounter them at home, in the street, at work, in our cars, in court of law. We watch perpetrators of this violence become presidents and justices supreme.

 

MOST EXPRESSIONS OF THE GENDER SYSTEM ARE CALLED “SOCIETY”

Now, for a visit to the world of gender in post-war America and the unique institution of upper-class suburban marriage.25 This period in US history is the source of our current expressions of the gender system. It is also the period in which radical feminism is born. 

Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique is the book that launched the second-wave women’s liberation movement in the US. For one class of women, at least. It named the problem that had no name, and that problem was the structural sexism that was draining the life out of suburban housewives in the 1950s and 60s. For context, keep in mind that married US women were forbidden by law from opening their own bank accounts or lines of credit until 1971. Coverture was still a thing.

First published in 1963, The Feminine Mystique remains incompletely read only slightly less than the major works of the ethicist and economist Adam Smith. Even if you know one thing about The Feminine Mystique, you know nothing about this book. Friedan undertook one of the first comprehensive critical readings of American pop culture and advertising, interviewing the creators of these media, to describe the cultural landscape that left millions of American women alienated from their bodies, their lives, their sexuality, partners, families, and well-being. The “femininity” demanded of white, educated, middle class women was so narrowly gauged and so descriptively thin that many women found they could not cope with it at all. Some turned to Valium and vodka tonics to numb out, and some tried to live and were committed to psychiatric institutions by their traditional husbands for a variety of maladies ranging from melancholy to hysteria (yes, even in the 1950s and 60s) to borderline personality disorder. This is the world lamented in The Hours, satirized in Suburbicon, sensationalized in Girl Interrupted, and eulogized in Gloria Bell. There is a very clear reason that when American men of the Greatest Generation saw teenage Baby Boom girls respond to the music of Beatles and Elvis Presley they decided these men were a direct threat to the future of heterosexual life in America.26 (Like the fizz over “WAP,” but with women as spectators.) And they were right. For readers in GenX and some Millennials this is well trod ground, but I offer these quick points of cultural reference to set the milieu out of which Friedan’s feminism emerges. 

The Feminine Mystique sort of invents feminist cultural studies. The chapter on advertising has yet to be surpassed as an analysis of media shaping social behaviour. It also grounds itself in qualitative sociology with an interview given to 200 women at Friedan’s college, the “sister school” Smith. The interview is presented in the index, but to read about this book you would think she’d done no research at all. Critics saw the title of chapter 12, “Progressive Dehumanization: The Comfortable Concentration Camp,” and their adrenaline took over. The historical reference was not casual. The personal blankness and lack of self-regard she finds in these women parallel in kind, though mostly not in degree, the effects of depersonalization imposed in the camps. What she’s interested in is the particular patriarchal imaginary of her era concerning women and femininity in their closest relation to it — marriage. Like Mary Daly and Luce Irigaray whose work comes just after, Friedan also does not have much analysis of gender identity as we understand it now—except to say that the gender identity called “womanhood” in the mid-20th century had not much at all to do with living, breathing, human women. 

So, back on point: in all the froth of scandal obscuring Friedan’s revelations, no one ever carefully read the last couple of chapters. These present some findings worth glossing in an introduction to radical feminism. The situation is this: women educated at “sister schools,” Brown and Smith and the like, marry successful capitalist men and go live in Westchester, NY, where they raise children and participate in the PTA, etc. This becomes a stultifying situation, and many women begin to develop all kinds of maladaptations. Given that human beings are made to grow and develop by committing to meaningful challenges and work, a woman who “evades her own growth” by clinging to the “childlike protection of the housewife’s role will — insofar as that role does not permit her own growth — suffer increasingly severe pathology, both physical and emotional.”27 This evasion can take the form of noncommitment — drifting through life without actually engaging in “tests of reality” or vicarious living. Living vicariously can mean, 1) “repression of one’s own personality” and seeking “fulfillment as women” through the richer lives of their husbands and children (no surprise, this pressure warps these people and relations dramatically), or 2) she might substitute an idealized version of a woman “a standard of absolute goodness … suppressing all impulses that are incompatible” for her own personality (also very hard on proximate humans), or 3)—and this is my favourite—she might just take “on the personality that is the popular cliché at the time” without much reflection on how it suits her. While a psychologist like Andras Angyal would describe this as a personality disorder,28 Friedan argues that this weak ego, this undeveloped self, is “the way the feminine mystique teaches girls” to be women. During the 1950s, in suburbs of New York City, housewives aged 18-44 presenting with depression and other “psychiatric and psychosomatic disorders with increasing severity … became by far the predominant group of all psychiatric patients” (pp. 351-52). Of course, at the time, the pathology was just part of being a woman. A cure would make her more accepting of this reality. 

These cures ranged from prescription depressants to electro-shock therapy to frontal lobotomy. The lobotomy in particular is interesting.29 If one’s social role, woman-mother, requires so little of one’s own talent or drive, the lobotomy is perfect for adjusting a woman who finds her parameters hard to bear:

Historically, patients of lobotomy were, immediately following surgery, often stuporous, confused, and incontinent …

The purpose of the operation was to reduce the symptoms of mental disorders, and it was recognized that this was accomplished at the expense of a person’s personality and intellect.30

In the US, “the procedure increased dramatically from the early 1940s and into the 1950s; by 1951, almost 20,000 lobotomies had been performed in the United States and proportionally more in the United Kingdom. The majority of lobotomies were performed on women; a 1951 study of American hospitals found nearly 60% of lobotomy patients were women.”31 If Herbert Marcuse and Jack Kerouac are to be believed, there was much stultification of American men in this cloying post-war world of soft and corporate fascism. But it’s the American enthusiasm for a technological intervention into human-being, rather than a social intervention into what harms a human being that expressed itself through the gender system here. 

American housewives of this class had access to care, families who wanted them well—even if only well-adjusted. Freidan makes the comparison to the camps in these terms: the conditions created to dehumanize and depersonalize the imprisoned people there were different in their far greater amplitude. A degree likely satisfying to the sadist element of all fascisms. They deprived the prisoners of “stimulation from the outside world,” and forced them to spend their time in labour that “produced great fatigue—not because it was physically killing, but because it was monotonous, endless, required no mental concentration, gave no hope of advancement or recognition” and was paced by the external demands of overseers or machines. The work bore no connection of any human personality or initiative and allowed no expression of oneself.32 A woman whose interests are utterly sublimated into the interests of her husband and children, their care and maintenance, the ever-more-detailed care of the home—that woman can crumble.

In addition to Angyal’s work, Friedan turns to another “existentialist psychologist” to describe a healthy human being, Abraham Maslow. Where Angyal, a Hungarian, left Austria just as Hitler was ascending to power, Maslow was a second-generation Jewish immigrant whose parents fled the Tsarist persecution that also forced my husband’s grandparents to the US. Similarly, the Frankfurt School philosophers (Adorno, Horkheimer, and Marcuse) fled Hitler’s Germany, and arrived to the US in the same world Friedan researched where they found a softer but familiar fascism and began to analyse to expand the possibilities of human flourishing. And, I would imagine, to protect their new home from the forces that overtook their homeland. These thinkers were interested in how a human became a:

“well-rounded individual” someone who could engage in life, set forth a project for themselves, and develop the capacities needed to live meaningfully. A healthy human being (male, you know), drives himself toward “fuller development, to self-realization.” This “will to power,” “self-assertion,” “dominance,” or “autonomy,” as it is variously called, does not imply aggression or competitive striving in the usual sense; it is the individual affirming his existence and his potentialities as a being in his own right; it is “the courage to be an individual.” (p. 373, my emphasis)

This is a healthy person. One who is “happy, self-accepting, … without guilt” because he/she is “fulfilling himself and becoming what he can be” (p. 373). It is not enough, Maslow argues, for a person to be “loved and accepted by others, to be ‘adjusted’ to his culture.” Mind you, the highest compliment one could pay in the deeply conformist 1950s, that someone was “well-adjusted,” that a woman was “well-liked.” No, for a human person to flourish, they must take their life in their own hands, take existence “seriously enough to make his own commitment to life, and to the future; he forfeits his existence by failing to fulfill his entire being. For years, psychiatrists tried to ‘cure’ their patients’ conflicts by fitting them to the culture. But adjustment to a culture which does not permit the realization of one’s entire being is not a cure at all” (p. 374, emphasis mine). 

Note that fulfillment, self-actualization, does not require being thought of as nice, or good, or cute, or ideologically obedient, or getting lots of likes on Twitter. Fulfillment is not validation. Fulfillment depends less on other people than validation does.

The problem is that taking one’s life in one’s own hands, possibly diverging widely from the herd, produces a lot of anxiety. This kind of anxiety is a symptom of growth. It occurs when a person feels into the way to “fulfill his existence, but this very possibility involves the destroying of present security,” which leads to the fear and even the need to mourn that past incarnation. When women take on our lives as projects and our own development as exploration, we become gender non-conforming women. We are no longer doing the mystique, we are no longer performing femininity. Our divergences vary in degree and style — we are individuals, after all — but we are not negating ourselves, I mean living for others, in the way patriarchy assigns for us to do when it calls us “women.” 

Rather, as detailed in that New York Times series cited above, we are destroying ourselves in whole new ways that serve the form of patriarchy called capitalism. The one that says Sure, honey, you can seek your own ends, but if you try to do it without abusing the labour of a working class woman, we’ll make sure it wears you to the bones. A world in which women still do better than 60% of the housework and childcare in addition to their full-time jobs is one that allows men more freedom to pursue their own life projects. Granted, capitalism is not at all interested in our individual flourishing, none of us, beyond the constant growth of our productivity. It’s just 60% less interested in women’s flourishing, on this line of analysis.

What is denied to women in the name of femininity’s service to man is, in Friedan’s words again, “precisely this unique human capacity to transcend the present, to live one’s life by purposes stretching into the future — to live not at the mercy of the world, but as a builder and designer of that world — that is the distinction between animal and human behavior, or between the human being and the machine” (p. 376). American wives had not “had their brains shot out,” but if these psychologists were correct (spoiler, they were), and the basic drive of the human person was not the “urge for pleasure” or the meeting of biological need but the “need to grow and realize one’s full potential,” then these housewives’ “comfortable, empty, purposeless days” were “cause for a nameless terror.” (p. 377) In the name of femininity, in a culture of tremendous conformist pressure (this is the age of June Cleaver and Joseph McCarthy), these women had still not been forced into this trap. They had “evaded choices that would have given them personal purpose, a sense of their own being” (p. 378). Those choices are easy to evade. Just wrap yourself up in the needs of others or in the need for their approval, and you’ll block the way to your own self-realization tout de suite. 

But here, Friedan takes a vital turn to look critically at these very psychologists. For while it’s very easy to check out of one’s own life (some find the cost easier than the freedom), and it’s very easy for a millennia-old system of sex-based control through gender roles to block a woman at Maslow’s “physiological level with … no need recognized higher than the need for love or sexual satisfaction (if that),” part and parcel of this habitus, this new psychology does not recognize the higher needs for women. Friedan points out that the “‘desire for strength, for achievement, for adequacy, for mastery and competence, for confidence in the face of the world, and for independence and freedom’—is not clearly recognized for women” (p. 379).

 

PLOT TWIST, WOMEN CAME BEFORE FEMININITY

Even Maslow, however, already had the evidence that put the lie to both the gender system and his own forgetting of women in the context of self-actualization. Friedan goes on to summarize the study called “Dominance, Personality, and Social Behavior in Women” in the Journal of Social Psychology from … wait for it … 1939. 

I know! Turns out progress is not linear or unidimensional. What did Maslow find, and we all then forget thanks to June Cleaver, Joseph McCarthy, and enculturation through advertising? 

According to Friedan, Maslow found the generation of women born around 1900, who were maturing in the 1920s, displayed a greater capacity for what he called “dominance feeling” or “self-esteem” or “ego level” in women (p. 382). In this period, the US moved out of its Gilded Age and into early Modernism. Suffragettes were marching, being attacked, and going to jail to achieve the vote. There was comparatively more room in the world for a woman to explore herself for herself. 

I’ll admit now that this chapter is almost entirely highlighted in my copy of The Feminine Mystique. It so gives the lie to the codes of femininity written into women’s minds and bodies, the dysfunction of the patriarchal fantasy of femininity. Friedan advises that, “The simple truth would seem to be that women will never know sexual fulfillment and the peak experience of human love until they are allowed and encouraged to grow to their full strength as human beings” (p. 382). Turns out (so delicious) the more traditionally feminine a woman is the more likely she is to be pathological in her behaviours and less likely to love fully or experience sexual pleasure. 

Forbidding female authenticity makes women even less of “what men want” than men say they want. Fun for all. 

The gender system insinuates itself into our most intimate relations. This is what we mean by the personal being political, by saying that feelings are political. The person and her feelings are shaped by the gender system, economics, racism, and various othering phobias which themselves require analysis, and that shaping is political. It’s not that our feelings are our politics, but that we can read in our feelings the traces of the political and how we might begin to change it. Even there, especially in our beds, patriarchy is there to preserve its power over everyone’s pleasure:

the more “dominant” the woman, the greater her enjoyment of sexuality — and the greater her ability to ‘submit” in a psychological sense, to give herself freely in love, to have orgasm. It was not that these women higher in “dominance” were more “highly sexed,” but they were, above all, more completely themselves, more free to be themselves — and this seemed inextricably linked with a greater freedom to give themselves in love. These women were not, in the usual sense, “feminine,” but they enjoyed sexual fulfillment to a much higher degree than the conventionally feminine women in the same study. (pp. 382-83)

Today, if we like the new terminology, we would call such women gender-non-conforming, maybe even non-binary, or just women. Perhaps they would be feminists. Perhaps they would be anti-feminist feminist Republicans who suggest one vote per household at nominating conventions for their presidential candidate (this happened), but they would all be people of greater depth and breadth than the commonly accepted parameters would allow. More than glitter, such a woman would be what was once called simply a well-rounded individual. 

What Maslow called “high dominance feeling” in women expresses itself as “feelings of general capability” and even a clear sense of superiority as she finds it. This woman is not shy or timid, is not easily embarrassed, and therefore responds to insight and evidence rather than manipulation and insult.These high-dominance women are not conventionally “feminine” because they feel free to accept or reject convention on their own judgement, but also because they are: 

stronger as individuals than most women. Such women prefer to be treated “Like a person, not like a woman.” They prefer to be independent, stand on their own two feet, and generally do not care for concessions that imply they are inferior, weak or that they need special attention and cannot take care of themselves. This is not to imply that they cannot behave conventionally. They do when it is necessary or desirable for any reason, but they do not take the ordinary conventions seriously” (pp. 383-84)

Raise your hand if this sounds familiar. These qualities of a confident woman get us in trouble for being gender-non-conforming, unruly, feminist, difficult. “Rules per se generally mean nothing to these women. It is only when they approve of the rules and can see and approve of the purpose behind them that they will obey them … They are strong, purposeful and do live by rules, but these rules are autonomous and personally arrived at” (p. 384). I read this and I see Katherine Hepburn, Heddy Lamar, Lily Tomlin, Julia Stiles. I read this and feel so seen!

These women tend to be less self-centered and more interested in engaging the world than non-dominant women. More conventional, low-dominance women tend to be more concerned with themselves, with their own insecurity and needs. “From a psychological point of view, a high-dominance woman was more like a high-dominance man than she was like a low-dominance woman.” The gap between low and high-dominance women created so many differences in personality, intellect, capacity, attitude, even vocation that “Maslow suggested that either you have to describe as “masculine” both high-dominance men and women or drop the terms “masculine” and “feminine” altogether because they are so “misleading”< (p. 385). These high-dominance women are more likely to combine work and family, to find their field of expression in the world as much or more than in the home and play the ball rather than the competition. They don’t worry too much what others think of them. Low-dominance women, however, are not their own women, and so the:

low-dominance woman was not free to be herself, she was other-directed. The more her self-depreciation, self-distrust, the more likely she was to feel another’s opinion more valid than her own, and to wish she were more like someone else. Such women “usually admire and respect others more than they do themselves”; and along with this “tremendous respect for authority,” with idolization and imitation of others, with the complete “voluntary subordination to others” and the great respect for others, went “hatred, and resentment, envy, jealousy, suspicion, distrust.” Where the high-dominance women were freely angry, the low-dominance women did not “have “nerve” enough to say what they think and courage enough to show anger when it is necessary.” (p. 386) 

Low-dominance women are indeed the negative pole of the paranoid, authoritarian, patriarch. There’s more to do with local culture, with upbringing, with generational and family trauma here than Maslow was looking at, but what he describes in these passages are the phenomena behind conservative/anti-feminist women blaming feminists for judging them and making them feel unworthy “for just being a mom,” and then seeking to ostracize feminists for being “radical” and “too far out of the mainstream to be impactful.” Low-dominance people really care what people on Twitter think of them. This makes them malleable. Meanwhile, feminists are focused elsewhere entirely trying to make “just being a mom” a better supported position in society. The paranoid authoritarian needs an enemy who is both vastly powerful (to fuel movement against them) and too weak to bother about (to assure the in-group that they are just-right as right can be).

To be pointed about it, high-dominance women are “self-actualizing.” In Maslow’s famous hierarchy of needs, they’re cruising around the top two or three tiers of the pyramid, looking beyond themselves and even beyond their circle of kin and kith for meaning and purpose. They seek to discover their horizon and then live themselves toward it with gusto. That. Is. Not. Femininity. Not glitter.33

These women and men, whomever they might be loving, are free to move about in love and relationship and “roles” with spontaneity and as needs-must. For these people, partnered love is an exploration of “growing intimacy, honesty, and self-expression.” These people found it possible to be themselves, to feel natural; they could be psychologically (as well as physically) “naked and still feel loved and wanted and secure; they could let their faults, weaknesses, physical and psychological shortcomings be freely seen” (p. 390). They can be authentic in themselves with each other. They can build what we usually call “a healthy relationship” without feeling like it’s “work.” These couples “made no really sharp differentiation between the roles and personalities of the two sexes.” Crucially, as Freidan puts it, “These people were all so certain of their maleness or femaleness that they did not mind taking on some of the cultural aspects of the opposite sex role” (p. 391, emphasis mine).

They just don’t have to be anybody else. They don’t have to monitor themselves for gender conformity. So, self-actualizing people don’t seek to over-power others or force them to conform to their own wishes or needs in order to feel whole. That is, self-actualized people are not narcissists. 

More than in love and sex, these whole people — not perfect, not without neurosis or trauma, not without peevish feeling — operate in their lives as both/neither masculine and/or feminine. They’re humans, capable of expressing and examining and emerging from their complexity. They are not dysfunctional with regard to the larger world and its habits of gender, its enforcements. They just don’t take that very seriously as a way to live. 

 

SERIOUSLY, AS A WAY TO LIVE

I have long been pained, annoyed, pissed-off that second- and third-wave feminists have done 70 years worth of research and imagining and activism and this is all the farther we have got. In the US we still don’t have our Equal Rights Amendment. In the UK, the Equality Act is being dipped in an acid bath. Part of my mind is always buzzing with this problem: radical feminists have done so much work, so much recovery of lost knowledge (cf. Freidan on Maslow here), so much development of policy and so much activism on its behalf—we have taken so much fucking shaming and threatening and self-righteous disdain. No matter who you are, if something is wrong in your life in 2020, you can bet a radical feminist is behind it. Sure.

For what? For carving out cultural and legal space in which women might discover what we are other than an extractive site or fungible commodity in the patriarchal economy.

Absolutely, this feminist intellectual and political tradition has come up short from time to time. Our alliance has been unsteady, sometimes willfully obtuse. I plan to walk through some of that failure as this essay continues, though many other scholars have been more astute and thorough than I can be here and so I will offer a syllabus of reading that can bring their work and thought to you whole and shining. 

And we find ourselves, in the year of our lord 2020, in the year of civilization 14,020,34 in a situation that requires we rehearse this knowledge, re-introduce the rocket fuel that is this tradition. The very word “woman” is under threat. On the one side, “woman” is poised to become a kind of prison once again. The rise of nationalism is also a rise of the Isms and Phobias. Some feminist groups have begun to ally with these fascist energies in order to defend women. This move is both vicious with regard to race/class/sexuality and catastrophically stupid with regard to liberation generally. And on the other side, “woman” is poised to become so inclusive as to be meaningless, weaponized by a misogynist progressive left that sees women as that which must serve or be nothing, again. Mother of All Gods that particular return of the Same gets on my last nerve. Woke bros. Hissst.35

My goal in these essays is to help establish a new trailhead for a feminist path between these forces. A way between transphobic feminists and misogynist transwomen. A way that allows feminist women and feminist transwomen to work together. A way that lets me mark the difference between a patriarchal narcissist assuming trans-identity, and a transwoman who allies with women. These are labels I apply on the basis of behaviour and persistently evidenced attitudes. I want the name “radical feminist” back. Radical feminists, in our best dreams, want a world resplendent with all kinds of respected, specific, mutually responsible, and creative humans. Our task is the confrontations of patriarchy’s oppression of women — in all areas. What we cannot abide are patriarchs who threaten us while insisting they know, and know us, better than we do. No matter the sex, race, gender, sexuality, class, pronouns, name, identity, ideology, politics, religion, or nationality of the person speaking or acting in patriarchal ways — if one walks and talks like a misogynist, we will resist and overcome that misogyny. 

Allies, even accomplices, are not people who set their cultural and rights projects aside for others. Intersections are not about ignoring any axis of oppression. Alliance and cooperation are not about fighting over The Agenda We Will Pursue For Justice — it’s about finding the issues on which we have common interest and working on them strategically. It’s about coming to each other’s aid when the pervasive flow of patriarchal power coalesces like a python around one of our cohorts and working on those threats tactically. It’s not a dogma by which to police each other. It’s about finding intersecting projects where our interests overlap, dealing honestly with rights conflicts when they arise, and leaving each other space and time to work on liberation/rights projects that don’t involve other cohorts.

Equality does not mean sameness. Liberation is not monolithic or unidirectional. This is the teaching of difference, this is the inheritance of the dreaded and maligned post-structuralist feminists like Luce Irigaray: that we cannot be if we are only one. That we cannot win if we are only one. The power we are trying to outlive is very flexible, and it will become anything — capital formations, a buffoonish authoritarianism, even pretend to be a transwoman — to keep power. This is not to say that transwomen are authoritarian, but to say that patriarchy will use whatever tools available and whatever path goes downhill to keep on keeping on.36 One of those paths would be to erase protections on the basis of sex. Patriarchy needs the gender system of A and ~A.

The difference principle of post-structuralist radical feminism both admits that there is no unified field theory of justice insists this is a strength. Intersectionality used to be a strategic expression of this insight rather than a bludgeon against the “unwoke.” We must live beyond such a world in many ways, as many kinds of well-rounded humans, at once. And at once!

Radical feminists have the effrontery to believe that this 70ish year old tradition has much to offer current movements for justice. Where we have done the work, we hope current movements will take it and adapt it to need. This is a kind of allyship, this finding our intellectual as well as our political points of beneficial cooperation. But to write us off, pretend we made nothing of the ground current justice movements stand on is to constrict the possibility for alliance. 

In the second installment of this essay, I will deepen the context. It’s very difficult to discuss the work of Continental feminists like Irigaray or Braidotti in a moment when many (often otherwise admirable thinkers) dismiss the postmodern moment and post-structuralism for obfuscation, irrationalism, moral relativism, and nihilism. This characterization (not reading, the people who wave off this tradition by maligning it usually have not read in it) is, to put a fine point on it, wrong. This generation of intellectuals grew up during World War II, in France, in Algeria, in Bulgaria, in Italy. They are personally intimate with the violence and avarice of colonialism and fascism, and if they share a politics it is this: to jam all mechanisms of fascism and othering, and to imagine portals and lines of flight that we might begin to live more humanely. 

For the feminist philosophers present in this essay, and the schools of thought they represent, liberation is the impetus and goal. We have lost the details of their biographies and the subversion in their thought. With all of that went methodologies, critiques, and chances to change the course of history. I’m going to lay out some of those methods and insights so that we might reclaim their power in our current moment to the projects we (the broad community of people working for our liberations) engage so urgently now.

Difference is a way to live, a kind of value system. More than live and let live, difference calls us to reciprocity with others since there is no becoming without each other. Derrida was an ethicist of a kind.37 Irigaray was explicitly so. There’s hope in their work, as in the metric tonnage of feminist research, analysis, and theory. The planet is closing the door against us for treating it the way patriarchy treats women — as both resource and enemy. Radical feminism imagines a future in which humans flourish beyond our present imagining. It insists that women, everywhere we are found, be the poet-architect-leaders of that future. More than power stands between us and that world we are imagining. That vision is also multiple, vast, and complex, and deep, and messy with progress and conflict and tension. It could be no other way, I suppose, with people embedded in history as we are. Some of these tensions are hugely creative and generate conversations that spur more robust worlding, and some tensions have us fighting each other over rights to the ultimate benefit of white-het-colonial-capitalist patriarchy rather than going about the more vital and, frankly, fun work of ripping it off its moorings. I want all of you to live shining in that future, re-moored in something stronger and more secure than patriarchy, and to live well through this churning, damaging, and risky era. 

In the third installment of this essay, I will discuss a few elements of my intersectional practice and philosophy. Certainly, some radical feminists still need to find ways to reciprocally expand their engagement with other feminisms and justice traditions. As mentioned in the first footnote here, strategic and principled cooperation between schools of feminism and between radical feminist and other justice movements has been limited, often dismally so. I will sketch some points of confluence between Continental and black feminist activists and metaphysicians in the US context, beginning with a point of distrust generated by Mary Daly’s lacking response to Audre Lorde. I will condense a few more key radical feminist insights like the connection Mary Daly makes between sexist and capitalist forms of extraction. 

I will pause over Mary Daly as an example for the complaints about radical feminism. As with most thinkers, her focus on a few burning points led her to dismiss, or superficially engage, or hold hostilities to critiques of her work or to other projects entirely. She was no fan of “postmodern feminism” (her word) of the kind Irigaray develops, thinking it played into the patriarchy’s hands. But, what I see is that many of her key insights and those of “postmodern feminists” reinforce each other beautifully. By putting them in conversation with Daly, I will sketch out a feminism of difference that rests on the work of Luce Irigaray and Rosi Braidotti. Irigaray’s critique of the repression of the feminine spans the entire history of philosophy. Irigaray performs, over her career, a genealogy that retrieves the outlines of a metaphysics in the feminine out of the moments male philosophers address their repressions directly, and out of the very patterns in their discourse. I will bring Braidotti, a student of Irigaray and Gilles Deleuze, to bear on Daly’s gynocentrism in ways that I hope will enliven her best theories and relate them to currents in contemporary feminist thought. 

Mary Daly was horrified at how technology (nuclear, industrial, genetic, informational) manifests the death drive and misogyny of patriarchy. She is less acute in her thinking on how racialized people are impacted by these, but she does gesture toward that analysis. I feel that several threads in her work are of vital importance today: her emphasis on embodiment, on the physical connectedness of humans and our planet, and her model of imagining a living world, a culture, on feminist terms. Her vision does not suit all women. What it does is offer a powerful example of such imagining. Daly missed some powerful possibilities and opportunities to connect her work to that of other feminists, especially Audre Lorde. These certainly qualify, but do not disqualify, her rich analysis of hetero-patriarchy’s flight from embodiment, and with it the planet that supports these bodies, and how that follows from its subjugation of, reliance on, and hatred of women.

Esmée Streachailt, PhD is a nom de guerrière. Esmée’s cultural and organizing work leverages strategic alliances across difference for the liberation and flourishing of humans. Her writing embraces feminist critical theory, cultural hermeneutics, comparative religion, & poetics. Esmée a co-founder and contributing editor with . All respectful and reciprocal conversation welcome at their Twitter, @estreachailt. 

1 These women write more and less directly about that positioned view, and I take that experiential and epistemic limit for an opening to more writing on differently attenuated feminist metaphysics that neither I nor these writers carry. Friedan does include some analysis of the combination of sexist and racist oppression on black women, but the majority of her analysis pertains to upper-middle-class white women. Irigaray and Daly make almost no mention of race, though the case of Daly is more complex than generally known. While this essay offers introductions to three white radical feminists, a future section of this essay will set the work of white and black and queer metaphysicians in conversation at least a gesture from my side, embodied as a lettered, white, married, suburban American woman (from the Midwest no less). My hope there will be to model one instance of a creative, generative encounter among these lineages.

2 The lectures referred to here are collected in Jacques Lacan, Encore, Le Séminaire XX (Paris: Seuil, 1975). The lecture “The Signification of the Phallus,” is particularly interesting in this context, and can be found in translation in Jacques Lacan Écrits: The First Complete English Edition (New York, N.Y.: W.W. Norton & Co., 2002).

3 We are reaching back into the mid-20th century with all these researchers. Whether or not they personally laboured under universalist attitudes about whiteness, their funders and institutions did. These studies address behaviour and attitudes of mostly white, middle class subjects. The same is true of Shere Hite’s report on women’s sexuality, which was published in the early 1980s. At any rate, Lacan had access to some of the answers to his questions, had he wanted them.

4 The several branches of Structuralism and its origins are their own subject. A very brief introduction to these broad themes and be found at “structuralism” in The Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy online: https://www.rep.routledge.com/articles/thematic/structuralism/v-1.

5 Luce Irigaray, This Sex Which Is Not One, trans. by Catherine Porter (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell, 1985), p. 86.

6 Irigaray, This Sex, p. 93.

7 In some future project, someday, if the world doesn’t actually burn, I will explore how this problem affects the lines of trans poetics derived from Lacan’s work.

8 Speaking too broadly, this projection, misperception, and resulting entrapment modulates and reformulates along the lines of sexuality, class, and race, as well as in the forms of colonialism and resource capitalism in ways that we now analyse for their own intersectional damages.

9 “The Law of the Father” is another enabling fiction patriarchy gives itself. Very generally, it’s the belief that in a family (and in one’s relation to the state), the father must intervene in the relational bond between mother and child. Since the child must learn to live in the man’s world, and the mother is a kind of nurturing soup of a human, she will never be able to help the child become their own person. If the father does not cut this bond, they will remain in a kind undifferentiated oneness. So, by taking “ownership” of the child, the father begins their formation as a subject or person. In Structuralist terms, the Phallus is given to the male child and brings him into the language of reason and the symbolic. If the child is male. If the child is female, she is left more in her mother’s care as she will not need to become a person, just an attractive and useful soup of a human. You see what Irigaray might have been annoyed with.

10 Luce Irigaray, Speculum of the Other Woman, trans. by Gillian C. Gill (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell, 1985).

11 Mary Daly was, among other things and not all of them excellent, a superb writer and turner of phrase.

12 It is a shocking claim. But, in a future installment of this essay, I will show readers that academics and public intellectuals who say that postmodernists or critical theorists have no politics and no ethics either have not read the tradition they impugn, or are lying. They’ll say it’s all obfuscation and irrationalism, but that’s because the discursive style demanded by Continental academic gatekeepers at the time was extremely formal and of the highest possible level of diction. That made all this stuff hard to read. So, a lot of people haven’t. But, they feel a very strong need to put you off the scent, and there is a clue in that. To these people, I say, if you can digest Hegel, you can do this.

13 Bill McKibben, “130 Degrees,” New York Times Book Review, 20 August 2020.

14 I owe this section title to a transactivist, Eden Ladley, who made the argument on Twitter that this whole conflict around words and rights would just go away if women would just accept the commonly accepted parameters of womanhood. Tweets available at: twitter.com/ripx4nutmeg/status/1291620728153014277?s=20.

15 See page 87 of Nancy Tuana’s The Less Noble Sex: Scientific, Philosophical, and Religious Conceptions of Gender (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1993). Also, if you have never read her essay “Coming to Understand: Orgasm and Epistemology of Ignorance,” do it soon. It will set something free in you. Nancy Tuana, Feminist Science Studies (Winter, 2004), 194-232. I will spend some time with these texts in future installments of this essay. In a world struggling over bodies and their meaning, Tuana’s are indispensable insights.

16 Get you some bardcore at <https://www.youtube.com/c/Hildegardvonblingin>.

17 Charles Holmes, “The Conservative Crusade Against ‘Wet-Ass Pussy,’” Rolling Stone, 11 August 2020.

18 The refrain seems to undercut this reading, and the agency claimed in the verse lyrics. “There’s some whores in this house,” is the one, repeated, line of an eponymous 1993 song by DJ Frank Ski. Arguably, three minutes of “there’s some whores in this house” is either camp itself, or a crystallization of a toxic masculine view of women. Either way, the repetition, with its stress on “whores,” functions to reduce women to functions in a sexual economy. “WAP” clearly has more to say about women and sexuality than its old-school house music sample. DJ Frank Ski, “There’s Some Whores in This House,” Decco Records (1993).

19 Francesca Donner, “7 Inequities: A Weeklong Look at the Biases Women Face,” The New York Times, 6 July 2020.

20 Shannon Catalano, Erica Smith, Howard Snyder, and Michael Rand, “Female Victims of Violence” for the Bureau of Justice Statistics of the United States Department of Justice, revised 2009.

21 The number transgender adults in the US is 1.4 million, according to a population survey from 2016. And every one of these humans deserves as much protection in laws as women do, and still don’t have, and shouldn’t have to qualify with gender.

22 C. Peek-Asa et al., “A Population Based Study of Reporting Patterns and Characteristics of Men Who Abuse Their Female Partners,” Injury Prevention, 11.3 (2005), 180-85. Famous second-wave books such as Shulamith Firestone’s The Dialectic of Sex (1970) address the violence endemic to traditional patriarchal masculinity. Catherine Mackinnon’s Are Women Human?: And Other International Dialogues (2007) details her successful work to have rape categorized as a war crime in the late 1990s, and to bring the Serbian soldiers to justice for their participation in rape campaigns. But, politicians and transactivists keep telling us women are in little danger, we are so safe in this world.

23 The Violence Against Women Prevention Act.

24 Elizabeth Tang and Emma Peoplow, “Courts Must Not Carve Out Sexual Assault Survivors from Existing Legal Protections Against Retaliatory Defamation Lawsuits,” The National Women’s Law Center, August 2020.

25 The suburban housewife ain’t who she used to be, as evidenced by the new Twitter hashtag #Suburbanhousewife.

26 The Beatles and Presley videos, YouTube.

27 Betty Friedan, The Feminine Mystique (New York, N.Y.: W. W. Norton & Co., 2013), pp. 346-47.

28 Andras Angyal emigrated from Vienna to the US in 1932, significantly, and is the originator of the holistic view of personality. A quick introduction to his work is available in Wikipedia.

29 Louis-Marie Terrier, Marc Levêque, and Aymeric Amelot, “Most lobotomies were done on women,” Nature, 548, 31 August 2017; “Lobotomy,” Wikipedia, 16 September 2020.

30 In the Wikipedia entry.

31 Also, the Wikipedia entry.

32 Betty Friedan, The Feminine Mystique, p. 368.

33 It’s important to note here that all this “self” actualizing takes place in the context of all of society’s other ways of impeding human flourishing: structural racism, crushing poverty laws and lending practices, relative water and food security, poor quality education and health care, bad air quality. All of this makes securing the personal ground of self-actualization exponentially more difficult. The terminology should not be used to blame people for not overcoming structural oppressions.

34 The date system Kurzgesacht refers to in the argument for its decolonized calendar is Göbekli Tepe, built around 10,000 BCE. It’s the oldest permanent structure we know of yet, and it is a temple complex made by people with rich and nuanced knowledge. In a decolonized timescale based on the first permanent human temple in Göbekli Tepe, it’s the year 12,020, and only about half those years have been lived under a rapacious patriarchy. These temples are shaped like wombs, they are illuminated with realistic images of flora and fauna, and at some moment, they were very quickly buried entirely. They were precious to a people who probably weren’t yet patriarchal in the abstracted, sky-god kind way we are. It’s even arguable that the sky-gods and their body-fear didn’t complete their domination of western/European civilization until the late 17th century. Patriarchy’s power may be vast, but it is young yet. The known Indigenous cultures that came before and created the first civilizations evince forms of animist, goddess centered and/or polytheist religions. And, if the archeological records are to be believed, they already had deep knowledge of astronomy, geometry, and heavy architecture. Though we can only infer what these peoples thought about sex and gender, or how matriarchal their political organizations may/not have been, my bet is that our ancestors’ views and habits were not shaped like ours. The problem for all civilizations/societies is knowing that there have been and currently are others, that any particular form of life is not the only one fitted to human being. This key insight is what I take to be the basis of all work done in the name of social justice: another world is possible and the desire for it is completely natural given the vast structures of suffering and extractive relations engineered by powerful minorities over the last several centuries. See Kurzgesacht on YouTube and “Göbekli Tepe, Turkey,” The Global Heritage Fund.

35 See Susanne Moore’s “How Progressive Misogyny Works,” Spectator, 2020. Hers is a quick and excellent precis on how all that works. The fact is that if your life is negatively affected by patriarchy, your target should be patriarchy and not women. It’s harder to fight, I know. There are real costs to turning away from or against power and those who embody it, even if you are one of those bodies. That’s why we call this capacity courage. Turning on women, even (even!) white women, is choosing to embody the power one says one rejects. And that turn, against women, just makes you the advance guard.

36 I, for one, endorse a feminism that would protect transwomen from the stigma and resulting prejudice that will arise from association with men who enact patriarchal violence, emotional or physical or sexual, against women. Given that over half of transgender people have experienced sexual assault/abuse, an urgency we share is working across communities to force men to address patriarchal violence (which goes well beyond the sexual).

37 If you find this claim shocking, read the forthcoming second installment of this essay.