by Suffragetti
Abigail Shrier, Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters (Washington, D.C.: Regnery Publishing, 2020), 256pp., $28.99.
The precipitous rise in teenage girls — a notoriously vulnerable group — identifying as boys and pursuing medical transition, is a feminist issue. As Abigail Shrier observes, “In 2018, the UK reported a 4,400 percent rise over the previous decade in teenage girls seeking gender treatments,” the number of gender surgeries for female-to-male transitioners quadrupled in the US between 2016 and 2017, and clinicians in Canada, Sweden, Finland and the UK have reported a “sudden and dramatic shift in the demographics of those presenting with gender dysphoria — from predominantly preschool-aged boys to predominantly adolescent girls.” As expressed by many of the people interviewed in her book—including public health researcher Lisa Littman, psychotherapist Lisa Marchiano, and transman Buck Angel — it is necessary, and not inherently transphobic, to be sceptical of these startling statistics. As Buck, one of the first transmen to medically transition in the 90s, says, “How can we not question it? How can our own community not question it?”
This is Shrier’s project in Irreversible Damage. The book’s strength is in these interviews, where, with journalistic flair, she gives a voice to many of those invested in the health and wellbeing of teenage girls. The personal accounts of detransitioners, such as Benji and Helena, powerfully attest to the impact gender ideology can have on the lives and identities of young women. Helena’s susceptibility to online communities which encouraged her self-harming and disordered eating meant she was also vulnerable to other communities convincing her she was “anything besides a girl.” Benji’s testimony of being groomed as a young teenager is particularly distressing. Shrier’s interviews with the parents of teenage girls identifying as male form a substantial part of the book, a group with whom she clearly identifies strongly. However, whilst compelling, these interviews prompt further questions. I frequently found myself wondering how the young people themselves would tell their own stories.
In fact, there is an overwhelmingly smug, patronising tenor to Shrier’s discussion of the teens discussed throughout Irreversible Damage. In a typical address to the reader, Shrier instructs us to “Resist the urge to squeal out loud at the preposterous notion that a teenager in any sense knows who she is with the level of certainty sufficient to entrust her with life-altering decisions.” I found this attitude both lacking empathy, and counter-productive to any meaningful engagement with a diverse audience of readers, especially those who currently view adolescent transition as unproblematic. Shrier explicitly addresses gender-questioning adolescents at the end of the book, but which teenage girl, questioning her identity, is going to listen to someone who dismisses her subjectivity in this manner?
This is unfortunate, as it should be possible to make the case that young people are impressionable, that puberty is traumatic, and therefore that patience and nuance is vital when considering a trans identity, without denigrating the experiences of these girls. Her discussion of transition manages to reinforce both the idea that women’s breasts and fertility are key to sexual desirability and maternal destiny. For instance, she describes the “bulldozed version of a woman’s profile” of one transman youtuber, and later recounts how her father opposed her breast reduction on the grounds that she “looked like a woman should,” a comment which “comforted” her that “one day, just as I was, I would capture the right man’s attraction and love.” For Shrier, “Testosterone arrives like a Rumpelstiltskin to claim their fertility for good,” preventing “perhaps life’s greatest blessing,” childbirth. Elective mastectomy is a serious procedure, and the removal of erogenous tissue and potential sterility is not negligible. Yet we should be sensitive to the ways in which these issues are framed, and the language used about pre- and post-transition bodies. The implication that girls are damaged because their femininity has been either stolen or renounced, does not sit well with me. Loss of femininity is incidental to the principle of avoiding unnecessary bodily alteration.
Shrier has a tendency, throughout the book, to reinforce the assumption that femininity in girls is “normal,” as in the story about “Julie.” In arguing it is problematic to say any girl who deviates from femininity is trans, Shrier often implies that stereotypical feminine behaviours are natural. In the closing remarks of the final chapter, she endorses a biologically essentialist view of girls, perhaps unconsciously replicating the views alienating young trans-identified girls from their female bodies and navigating the world as a woman. Her exhortation to girls to “stop taking sex stereotypes seriously” is contradicted by her claims that becoming a woman means occupying a body which is “softer, more sexually inviting.” Her assertion that girls are fundamentally different to boys in character and disposition, that “[girls] are possessed of a different set of inclinations and gifts – a whole range of emotions and capacities for understanding that boys, in general, are not,” is unhelpful. I found her dogmatic at points, such as when she asserts that “a woman’s emotional life is her strength.” Shrier argues that we shouldn’t pathologise girlhood, and she’s right, but she understands this as endorsing traditional gender roles, rather than simply contesting the current claim that teen girls are really male because they experience discomfort with their pubescent female bodies.
Suffragetti is an early career researcher based at a UK university. She works on feminist approaches to history and literature, with a particular interest in language and the body. You can follow her @Suffragetti on Twitter.
