Issue One

r/GenderCritical: We Peaked. Now We’re Over It.

by womenopausal

Peak trans

Reaching peak trans starts with a gentle slope. You step, perhaps, from unease with the shifting of language, to discomfort with the way that many trans women’s version of “being a woman” relies upon sexualized stereotypes, to alarm over trans activists’ aggressive responses to any queries.

r/GenderCritical’s “Peak Trans” threads have charted hundreds upon hundreds of similar trajectories. These threads came to characterize the community. Each post told a story of how the poster reached a point where she could no longer ignore the misogyny in the current form of the trans movement. Lesbians ostracized for refusing “girldick”; mothers whose daughters had reshaped their trauma with their adolescent bodies into an identity; transwidows with their lives in tatters. Pinned at the top of the subreddit as an entryway for new users, they allowed our readers to identify the commonalities of their experiences, awakening the class awareness which is key to feminist consciousness.

Climbing towards the peak incurred the distress of becoming conscious of the societal misogyny exposed by trans ideology. Often, this was exacerbated by the crazy-making frustration of feeling alone, unheard and silenced. We didn’t radicalize anyone; we didn’t try to. We merely resolved the cognitive dissonance of women who were under pressure to deny the political significance of the colonisation of their own sex class.

All we said was yes. Yes, we understand. Yes, we see it too. Yes, it’s real. Yes.

r/GenderCritical was an online community hosted by Reddit, an aggregator site which allows users to create communities (known as “subreddits”) within their platform. Subreddits are created and organized by volunteer moderators. The community names start with r/, while usernames begin with u/. For over two years, as u/womenopausal, I had been posting updates and articles on r/GenderCritical relating to British feminists’ struggles with the Gender Recognition Act, censorship of their views, and the institutional capture of many governmental and non-governmental organizations. Like many other British radical feminists, my own peak trans was the violent attack on Maria McLachlan at Hyde Park Corner in 2018. I felt compelled to participate in the debate, but needed to do so anonymously. Online activism was the obvious choice. r/GenderCritical was right up my alley.

Just over a year ago, I was inducted onto the moderation team of r/GenderCritical. As moderators, much of the work we did was invisible: removing trolls, enforcing the rules of the community and promulgating its culture, which was based in radical feminist principles. Supporting pornography, abusive sexual practices, prostitution and surrogacy were against the rules; any people who were less than fully supportive of women’s right to access abortion were removed promptly. We didn’t want our users to dissipate their energies in an endless defence of radical feminist positions. We are constantly forced to do that outside our own spaces anyway. (We had dedicated debate subreddits for this purpose, in which some of the most brilliant — and patient — of our members participated.)

For me, the most satisfying part was seeing the development of new members. Newly peaked, still bewildered, they joined us skittish or prickly, concerned about seeking fellowship from women they believed to be “evil TERFs” and socialized into self-effacement through the male-pleasing culture of liberal feminism. Some users, new to any other feminist perspectives than the anodyne, depoliticized third wave, found radical feminism with a sense of relief – and a kind of recognition. If you look down from the peak, you can see the landscape of patriarchy spread out below you. And you begin to ask questions.

All we said was yes. Yes, you can exert sexual boundaries. Yes, you can live a good life without a man. Yes, you can stop performing femininity. Yes.

Wingardium leviosa!

Graph of r/GenderGritical’s subscribers, 2014-20

r/GenderCritical was created in September 2013 by a group of women who wanted to discuss the spread of trans ideology in a place where they would not be censored. They placed their trust in Reddit’s (then) libertarian principles – the founders had described it as a place for “authentic conversation.” Over the years r/GenderCritical expanded to cater to more and more women who felt disillusioned with third-wave feminism. A plethora of radical feminist “sister” subreddits sprung up: on porn, prostitution, male violence, feminist theory, radical critiques of Queer Theory, and more.

As the gender-identity movement grew, the counter-discourse began to spill outside radical feminist circles. Our membership grew along with it. The graph of subscribers could have been a textbook diagram for exponential growth – until J.K. Rowling’s sensitive essay on her concerns with trans ideology sent it skyward. (Amusingly, the greatest individual recruiter to our movement previously had been Contrapoints, who had made such a ham-fisted attempt at outlining so-called radical feminist ideology that several women came along to find out what our positions really were, and then found them persuasive.)

r/GenderCritical was not officially a woman-only space. We already had enough work to do without having to trawl through users’ posting history to guess at their sex. In practice, though, men were few and far between. A parallel subreddit catered to pro-feminist men. Others lurked respectfully in the main sub; a few participated sparsely. Hundreds were banned for overstepping the rules; several left of their own volition, unaccustomed to the experience of being outnumbered, and often robustly challenged, by women.

In the near absence of men, a woman-centric culture developed. This was the rare, gorgeous pleasure of participating in r/GenderCritical. It is hard to capture the joy of women-only spaces to women who have not experienced them. Arguments were robust, although rarely rude. Vulnerable people were supported. Women felt able to share their wit and intelligence without self-deprecation or embarrassment. There were flaws, naturally: discussions of race and faith were often under-nuanced and marked by wider societal prejudices. Issues around religion, maternity and sexuality have always been divisive within radical feminist thought, and they remained so.

At the end of June 2020, r/GenderCritical was closing on 65,000 members, with over 27,000 daily users. r/GenderCritical was not, by any standards, a large community. It was, however, tremendously active: far more so than r/feminism, despite their mainstream status and huge number of subscribers. As British feminist Maya Forstater has observed, mainstream feminism has broad support, but very low engagement. We were at the other end of the scale. An average of 40 new posts were made to r/GenderCritical every day. It was not unusual for these daily posts to attract a thousand and more comments between them. r/GenderCritical also raised thousands of dollars for women’s charities, including Vancouver Women’s Library.

We raised consciousness, seeded activism, shared strategies, learned from each other, and reached more and more women. Our main concern, on the morning of 29th June, a few months shy of our seventh birthday, was how to handle our rapid growth. We were on track to reach 100,000 before the end of the year.

The hammer

That morning, I was working through the modqueue — a list of comments and posts which had been flagged for action — when the subreddit disappeared from under me. For “hate,” said the message text, centred underneath a stylized image of a hammer — or possibly a gavel. The attempt at looking judicial was undermined by the fact there was no process followed, no evidence given, and no appeal permitted. Eerily, Spotify chose that moment to play the chorus of a song: Now, now, the lights go out. There’s no warning. Now, now the lights go out. There’s no reason. Almost seven years of content — a good deal of it insightful, witty, moving, passionate, inspirational — was immediately placed out of reach of its creators and curators. I felt dizzy.

Another moderator, u/girl_undone, was in the middle of composing a message to a user reassuring her that we would not be banned when the hammer fell. Our surprise had come from the expectation that Reddit would abide by its own standards. u/girl_undone described the measures the moderation team had taken to keep our community secure:

We’d had a conversation with the admins years ago about enforcing additional rules on their behest that weren’t documented in the Reddit rules or policies, and we did that. We took all the rules very seriously, more than any sub I know of, frankly. We didn’t allow direct links to other subreddits, except sister subreddits, because we took “brigading” seriously—but other subs frequently brigaded our sub and the admins did nothing. We manually approved many kinds of content, including images, to make sure violations didn’t get through at all. We were sent pornographic images and violent threatening images so we didn’t want our users to ever see that anyway.

(“Brigading” means inciting or allowing the members of one subreddit to leave hostile comments or make false reports on another.) Meanwhile other subreddits had barraged us with puerile anime memes, photographs of diseased penises, and, of course, ceaseless threats of death and rape. On the morning of the ban, every single post on our subreddit had been falsely flagged as child pornography. I scrolled through 80 posts upon such topics as Adrienne Rich’s writing and a profile of a lesbian politician, all marked as “sexual or suggestive content involving minors” by some anonymous saboteur. Was this merely an attempt to waste our time, or was this something more sinister, connected with the ban later that same day? We will never know.

Other large subreddits banned on the same day – all male-dominated – had long histories of intervention by Reddit’s site admins: warnings and quarantines and measures. u/girlundone stated that Reddit didn’t give r/GenderCritical “any indication that we should be concerned.” She explained that, because the team had cooperated completely with the Admins’ requirements three years prior, we had expected there would at least be further communication indicative of any concerns before a ban. Yet she could find only three communications from the Admins since that conversation – all trivial in nature. We had acted like good housewives. We cleaned up the language and tidied up the links and toed the line in our goody two-shoes. It didn’t make much difference.

The hammer shattered the feminist ecosystem we had been building. Our German and Scandinavian sister subreddits were deleted. Both of these had focussed on prostitution abolition rather than trans issues. Also banned was a subreddit created by fans of J. K. Rowling as an alternative to the existing one which had censored nuanced discussion of her opinions. r/TrueLesbians, a community for lesbians that had the temerity to exclude male-bodied “lesbians” from its membership, was initially banned, restored upon appeal, and then banned permanently.

r/TrueLesbians poster u/writerlylesbian describes the process as “a slow car crash.” After the community was restored, it went private, she explained,

to protect it from the sorts of bogus “hate” reporting that was being used as an excuse for the subsequent bans. This had the unfortunate side-effect of locking out many lesbians who were lurkers/had changed username recently/weren’t active posters. It didn’t help much anyway, and r/TrueLesbians was permanently banned again a few days later. It was pretty much on various “hit lists” that were circling on Reddit.

A piquant irony was that, as we saw our sister subs get the hammer, our one and only “brother,” the pro-feminist subreddit r/GenderCriticalGuys, survived for over a week before it joined us.

Reddit was never the most likely platform for radical feminism. Our subreddit jostled alongside hateful pornography with names like r/degradingholes, r/strugglefucking (previously r/rapingwomen) and r/MisogynistFantasies. And yet, somehow, for close to seven years, r/GenderCritical had flourished despite the toxic environment. Even being cheek-by-jowl with the most scabrous denizens of the Manosphere couldn’t stem the joyous, intoxicating energy of a community run for, and by, women.

But at the end of the day, it didn’t matter who ran it or who they ran it for. It mattered who owned it.

Peak techbro

The tech industry movement remains staunchly libertarian in terms of free access to the vilest forms of pornography. Uppity women, however, seem to bring out its authoritarian streak. Twitter, Medium and WordPress have all been involved in censoring gender-critical perspectives. Reddit was merely following suit. Emily Chang’s book Brotopia exposes the arrogant geek misogyny of Silicon Valley. She outlines a culture of woman-objectifying libertinism, which allows nerds to play at being hoodie-and-sandals versions of Hugh Hefner. Feminist writer Jo Bartosch sums up the worldview of this culture as “knobjectivist” (Kate Manne can only dream of being so witty). But if techbro knobjectivism is the head of the hammer, trans activism is the handle.

On the Women Are Human blog, Tiffany Cowen described the background to Reddit’s decision to remove a huge number of “problematic” subreddits. Due to the site’s seedy reputation as a hive of incels and racists, the increasing influence of the burgeoning Black Lives Matter movement placed Reddit under pressure. This was amplified by the resignation of co-founder Alexis Ohanian, and his request that Reddit diversify its board. Co-opting this momentum, r/AgainstHateSubreddits wrote an open letter to Reddit’s co-founder and CEO, Steve Huffman (u/spez), asking for tougher measures on “hateful speech” on the platform on 8th June. (There are, incidentally, currently over 100 posts vilifying “TERFs” on r/AgainstHateSubreddits.) Our community was one of those they targeted for removal from the platform. An insider, moderator of a large subreddit, reports that she felt “sick to her stomach” at the language in the letter, and noted a concomitant rise in “violent and disturbing” language around “TERFs” within the Reddit social circles she moved in.

The letter was co-signed by the moderators of 800 subreddits, including one for fans of Taylor Swift, and of the nine-year-old video game Skyrim. It threatened a shutdown via use of a timer to close down the subreddits controlled by the signatories – intermittently, and with increasing frequency — to pressurize the admins into taking action. The same threat of shutdowns had been previously used to depose Reddit’s former interim CEO Ellen Pao in 2015. This action would cripple Reddit’s ability to capitalize on advertising. My insider contact noted that, tellingly, r/GenderCritical was banned on the Monday following the first deadline specified in the draft letter.

The letter’s demands were for a sitewide policy against hate based on “sexuality, gender identity, ethnicity, country of origin, religion, or disability.” Notably, sex is not present in this list of protected characteristics. Even the weaselly “gender” is absent. Fans of Skyrim or Taylor Swift may be happy enough for their communities’ moderators to endorse a letter against hate in the light of a massively influential and important social justice movement. It is less clear that each individual involved in those communities would be similarly invested in the removal of a niche feminist community. However, r/AgainstHateSubreddits was able to leverage the huge number of signatories to its letter to claim support in the hundreds of millions.

Pushed into a rapid response, Reddit’s new Rule 1 initially stated that “the rule [on hate] does not protect groups of people who are in the majority.” Feminists have observed that the shift from “sex” to “gender” tends to muddy understandings of sex-based oppression. Here, Reddit takes female erasure a step further, since for recorded history, women have been an oppressed majority. Every oppression counts it seems…except the first. This claim was subsequently walked back: now the rule says it “does not protect those who promote attacks and try to hide their hate in bad faith claims of discrimination.” The garbled language indicates a huge margin for interpretation: what does it mean to “promote” an attack? Whose claims of discrimination are in “bad faith” and whose are valid? And who decides?

Answers from Reddit’s Admins were unsatisfactory. The CEO clarified that their identification of “hateful content” was based “on reporting and our [i.e., Reddit’s] own filtering.” Using reporting as a metric means that what is “hateful” is elided with what users find personally offensive. A report-driven mechanism also hands control to a majority. Two-thirds of Reddit’s users are male. Clearly, Reddit’s concern with the potentially oppressive nature of majorities only goes so far.

Online spaces are no less vulnerable to policy capture than those with swanky premises in Westminster, with the benefit that there’s no need to leave the house. A committed activist can make a disproportionate impact. A Redditor named u/bpwpb gave an interview to LGBT magazine them taking credit for the ban of r/GenderCritical. u/bpwpb moderates over 30 communities, including r/LGBT, which has over 530,000 users. A post made on 4th June to r/transtimelines reveals u/bpwpb to be the trans activist formerly known as Aimee Challenor – notorious for creating the #terfblocker list which comprised over 50,000 British feminists, for finagling the Twitter banning of gender-critical ally Miranda Yardley, and for repeated attempts at gaining influence within political parties.

u/YoureNotAClownfish, moderator of our sister subreddits critical of pornography and prostitution, challenged the Admins of Reddit directly, participating in a long post of responses to the decision. She drew attention to the abrupt removal of r/GenderCritical whereas “male-run subs that reddit itself has issues with are let run for years, and then merely quarantined, if that,” and the persistence of misogynistic subreddits. There was no answer. Admins dismissed questions about the rights clash at the heart of feminist concerns with a ritual intonation of Trans Women Are Women. In the same conversation, u/bpwpb requested that the term “trans-identified” and “trans-identifying” should be filtered on Reddit, because of their association with the r/GenderCritical community. This would represent a chilling delimitation of any remaining feminist Redditors’ freedom of speech and thought, if introduced into policy.

Tellingly, posters in r/AgainstHateSubreddits outlined their motivation in targeting r/GenderCritical along with the other subreddits: “r/GC functioned as a major pipeline, particularly for younger ones,” stated one. “It’s about scattering the ideology so that they can’t organize and fall into the TERF blackhole,” another responded.

We were becoming too successful. They had to bury us.

Oocyte

Our users, disoriented and grieving, drifted to various platforms. Many participated in a #RedditHatesWomen Twitter campaign to draw attention to Reddit’s posturing. They tweeted titles of the most misogynistic pornography still available on the platform, alerting advertisers and media outlets to Reddit’s hypocrisy. Within hours, a replica of r/GenderCritical surfaced on Saidit, a “free speech” alternative to Reddit. It had attracted nearly 2,000 new subscribers within a week of the ban. Some users triumphantly posted archives they had found of our content – including the iconic Peak Trans threads which had been rescued as a priority. However, the advantage that Saidit did not allow pornography was undermined by the presence of anti-Semites and so-called “race realists” on the platform. Meanwhile, the independent feminist social media platform Spinster, founded by M K Fain, gained 2,000 new subscribers in a week.

What was noticeable to me was the number of women online who were suddenly vocally regretting our demise, while acknowledging never having posted on the subreddit while it was available. They had been gathering their courage; now they had lost their chance. This, more even than the anger at the abrupt and unjust nature of our ban, is what made me realize how necessary it was that we rebuild the community. We needed to do it for the women who had yet to find their voice.

We were never going to give up. We were never going to compromise. We were never going to leave ourselves vulnerable again. We felt responsible for our users and for maintaining the momentum of the community we had built. We also wanted to show those smug techbros and transactivists they might think they could pound us into the ground with their hammer, but really they were helping us spread our roots wider, so we could grow taller, wider and stronger.

Within days, a working group of more than a dozen tech-savvy feminists and pro-feminists had rolled up. I had to turn off my Discord notifications: the chirruping sound of updates was constant, and the jargon impenetrable to me. Spinster’s M K Fain and her partner joined the support team, providing real-life experiences of building a feminist platform and receiving massive anti-feminist backlash. Meanwhile, we struggled with keeping our former members, now dispersed and demoralized, in the loop. But the work of liberating oneself is eased by the vision of liberation. We would no longer suffer the insecurity of our fate being in someone else’s hands. We would no longer chafe against Reddit’s arbitrary restrictions on what we could and could not post. We could kick off our goody two-shoes and dance. And if we were going to dance, why not throw a party?

Moderator u/heidischallenge spoke for us all when she explained why she had devoted many years of her life to the subreddit: “I do it for the sisterhood.” We made her statement our hashtag, #ForTheSisterhood. We decided we weren’t just going to recreate r/GenderCritical within a safe, secure radical feminist space to protect ourselves and carry on as before. We weren’t aiming to replace r/GenderCritical – we were aiming to replace Reddit itself, and restore the feminist eco-system that had once flourished there. A poster in our Discord dubbed it Ovarit. The name stuck (dare I say implanted?) immediately.

Reddit? Nah, we’re Ovarit. Yes, you can join us. Yes.

womenopausal is a radical feminist with an interest in global violence against women. She is a former mod of r/GenderCritical and currently an admin of Ovarit.com, a project dedicated to women’s liberation that provides a platform for women-centered communities. You can find her @WomenAreOvarit on Twitter and @Ovarit on Spinster.