by Estela L. U. Vara
Editors’ Note: A View From is a regular feature which gathers impressions and analysis of the impact of trans ideology and its effect on feminism and women’s rights across the globe. We ask for contributions from our sisters everywhere in the world to recount the situation in their nation or nations, in any manner, from reporting to personal reflection, and everything in between.
I’ll start with a disclaimer: I’m pretty new to this fight. I resisted my magic terven essence for years. My understanding of the relationship between sex and gender was always feminist, which necessarily means critical of gender. At the same time I understood that trans people need to navigate their lives here and now, and I was under the (mostly) mistaken impression that radical feminists would just scream “gender abolition” to their faces. That didn’t seem very kind—and first and foremost, let’s all #BeKind.
I went years trying to reconcile my views and values with the demands of current trans activism. This took a toll on me, increased my discomfort with “gender” and my own sexed body, because I certainly didn’t have this “gender ID,” so where did that leave me? I thought it was just my issue, though, and “who are you to tell a trans person how they feel? Just because you don’t understand it, it doesn’t mean it’s not valid.” (Funny how I was okay with them telling me how I must feel and trying to impose a “gender identity” on me.)
Then, back in January, just as the new Coalition Government here in Spain got sworn in after the last General election and promised to be the most progressive, most feminist, most mostest government in the history of Spanish democracy, I listened to detransitioned women and finally had to admit what I had probably always known (I apologize for my Platonic epistemology). By saying that being a man or a woman is a matter of gender identity, trans activists are forcing young people, many of whom have not yet found their footing, to either identify or disidentify. In their quest for inclusivity, they are all for expanding “woman” to embrace feminine males while celebrating how many females want to escape from that same category. Ultimately, it makes perfect sense. Either you think of man/woman as the words to describe the human sexes or you risk collapsing them into masculine/feminine.
Still, I was hesitant to simply become “gender critical.” I even posted into the “peak trans” section of r/GenderCritical (R.I.P.) and explained all the reasons I had to peak (including real life encounters with so-called stunning and braves, who transitioned in name and pronouns only) while stating I wasn’t really sure I wanted to peak. As if it were a choice!
Nevertheless, in one of those Kumbayá bullshit fantasies I sometimes hold, I thought I’d stay a MiddleGrounder. I kept reading and listening to as many voices I could in this debate, then in March I decided to reach out to a self-proclaimed trans-inclusive radical feminist politician from Unidas Podemos. Unidas Podemos (UP) is formed of an electoral coalition between Podemos (and its regional brands) and Izquierda Unida (IU). Unidas Podemos is now the minority party in a Government Coalition with the Spanish Socialist Party (PSOE). As my table (Figure 1) shows, when it comes to the TERF wars, the right has gone mostly quiet. So in terms of national parties, responsibility for the debate comes down to PSOE and UP, precisely the two parties in the Government Coalition. That gives ammo to those saying it’s just a Game Of Thrones.
|
Opposition |
Extreme right wingers |
Vox: Against all things LGBT, yet more enthusiastically anti-feminist and anti-immigration. Francoist nostalgics. Vox will occasionally spout some traditionalist bullshit, but they are surprisingly quiet about Self-ID. They seem to be enjoying watching lefty people fight among themselves. They first entered Congress back in April 2019 (24 seats), then more than doubled them in November. Seats at Congress: 52. Many members have ties to Hazte Oír, which are Focus on the Family types who were responsible for a controversial bus – emblazoned with “Boys have penises, girls have vulvas. Don’t let them fool you.” – back in 2017. |
|
Right wingers |
Partido Popular (PP): Main opposition party. Social conservatives. However, they’ve “evolved” and now they are best described as indifferent to LGTB issues and dutifully paying lip service to gender equality. They haven’t weighed in as to whether women exist. Seats at Congress: 88. | |
|
Self-IDing as centre |
Ciudadanos: Choicey choice liberals, in favour of all things alphabet soup. Yet they’ve voted in favor of alliances between PP and Vox in some autonomous communities so they are oftentimes booed at Pride events. They lost many representatives back in November. Seats at Congress: 10. | |
|
Coalition Gov. |
Centre-left(ish) |
Spanish Socialist Party (PSOE): They’ve voted for problematic regional laws and their electoral program insisted on the need for an Integral National LGTBI Law. However, recently a statement entitled “Arguments Against Theories which Erase the Reality of Women” was conveniently leaked to some feminists, and some important voices in the party have come out against any form of Self-ID proposal. Seats at Congress: 120. Another issue, I suspect, is that because the Spanish right can be so socially conservative (to the point of some right-wing politicians not hiding their nostalgia for the Francoist dictatorship), the response against Wokey Bullshit from people on the left hasn’t been as decisive as it has been in the UK, though that’s changing. |
| The people’s front of Judea |
The coalition of Podemos, their regional offshoots and Izquierda Unida is now Unidas Podemos. Populist, anti-austerity and (Self-IDentifying) lefty coalition. It is supposedly to the left of the Socialist Party but it’s proven to belong to the woke and the wacky. Unidas Podemos is firmly in favor of Self-ID, to the point of not being quite sure whether women exist. In other feminist issues (e.g. prostitution, surrogacy) they flip-flop. Basically, there’s no Left left. Partido Feminista Español was a part of Izquierda Unida until they came out with a manifesto highly critical of Self-ID and transitioning children back in December 2019. IU voted to expel the Feminist Party this past February. Funnily enough, Unidas Podemos is a playfully “feminist” name. Instead of using the generic masculine (Unidos Podemos) they w–ent with the feminine form. Seats at Congress: 35. |
In my conversation with the female politician from Unidas Podemos, I told her I was worried about certain transgender discourses, particularly the ones by Chrysallis, Spain’s equivalent of Mermaids, an organization similarly pushing for early medical intervention and occasionally publishing fairytales such as La Gran Equivocación, where the sex-assigning fairy (I kid you fucking not) informs the parents of a trans child that, while out and about on her usual sex-assigning business, she made a huge mistake: the day the child was born, she looked only at the body, and neglected to look inside the child’s brain. Cartesianism 3.0 is so in!
I told her I felt we were failing kids and young people, especially young females. First she was cordial, even warm. She basically admitted that the increase in trans kids was due to sexist trends in society, but she added that puberty blockers are not so bad, since they buy those kids time. I didn’t want to burn any bridges so I mildly disagreed by telling her “from what I’ve read, they are not actually as innocuous as you say, but I’ll keep researching.”
At the time I focused on medical pediatric transition, but my misgivings about so-called “social transition” have only increased. In some cases it’s not “just” social transition that’s going on either. We have some minors legally changing sex, and by minors I mean 8 year olds like Elsa getting issued ID cards that state their “gender identity” and parents changing the legal sex of their 4 year olds at the Civil Registry, as a court clerk recently told me.
A month went by in which I continued to “educate myself.” They really should stop telling us to educate ourselves. The more we do, the higher we peak. I also broadened the scope of my concerns. So I wrote to my contact from Unidas Podemos again, this time with a more decidedly terven outlook; I now added concerns about prisons, female shelters and even locker rooms. That said, I took care to be very delicate in the way I phrased those concerns. I even used the pompous line: “in certain spaces it’s not our certainly legitimate sense of ourselves that matters but just our very own corporeality.”
She immediately hit back by telling me that I showed zero empathy for trans women. She also informed me that she uses unisex toilets and locker rooms all the time and that thankfully sex-segregated spaces are disappearing. The politician didn’t seem to grasp that female-only spaces don’t exist for women who don’t care for them, but for the rest of us. It doesn’t seem very kind to celebrate the disappearance of spaces that other women need or value.
It’s now clear to me that the person in question is one of those Boundary Exclusionary Extremists (Bees). She really believes all boundaries (particularly female boundaries, I’d suspect) are violent. Back then, I didn’t have a quick comeback, so taken aback I was at the personal attack. I felt tempted to respond: where is your empathy for females? But I thought it would be unfair to say so, since my first instinct with anger is to always turn it inwards, which is as emotionally healthy as you can fucking imagine.
The point is that she didn’t give any arguments for her position, nor did she clearly state her position. Instead, this self-proclaimed feminist played armchair psychologist and told me that my own views were just fear-based, comparing them to extreme right-wingers fearing immigrants. She claimed that I have an irrational fear of “gender migrants,” just like Vox voters have an irrational fear of immigrants. Oh where to fucking start? First of all, that’s a false analogy. Females being afraid of sharing some spaces with males is not the same as racist rhetoric against immigrants.
Let’s go with that corny and emotionally manipulative simile, though. Most people don’t really want to leave/flee their homelands. I’ve taught Spanish as a second language to both immigrants and refugees. While their experiences were different, many wished they could have stayed with their friends and family and, precisely because I grew genuinely fond of them, I wished that for them, too. So if anything, her false analogy could actually work in my favour.
I haven’t read any clear stats on Spanish trans youth, but anecdotal evidence from several friends who teach at secondary schools seems to confirm the trend seen in other countries: we have an increase in young females fleeing their homeland. They are also fleeing without exploring any other options first. One of my closest friends had a student who was a tomboyish lesbian girl at the beginning of the school year and that kid was on blockers just a month later. Educational and medical protocols in my region must follow a “gender affirming” approach. That seems like something that we should at least closely examine.
This politician also told me that my insistence on boundaries and definitions was just a form of identitarianism, specifically a form of identitarian retreat. Lo and fucking behold the absolute projection of that statement! The first time I reached out to her I told her (I shouldn’t have, that was naive) that I thought had I been born just a few years later, I might have transitioned instead of embracing my tie-wearing, head-shaving, lady-loving ways. I didn’t even self-describe as “butch,” I don’t consider myself “butch.” I’m not worried about the “butch identity” disappearing. I’m 30, I’m not nostalgic for a magical lesbian subculture that I didn’t even get to know. When I first heard about young lesbians calling themselves “genderqueer” I thought: well, it’s a bit silly, but where’s the harm? Of course new labels will sound silly, don’t mock the young folx!
The harm is in the medicalization pathway many of them take, the harm is in the lies they are fed which convince them that people will actually perceive them in the exact terms they perceive themselves (and if they don’t it’s because of hatred or transphobia). That’s what I’m worried about (though I’m sure this may be reduced to “you are just concern-trolling”). Anyway, of course Ms. Bee accused me of just being worried about my own identity as a “butch lesbian” disappearing. Because gender identity ideologues are incapable of thinking about these issues in anything other than identitarian terms, they will constantly accuse us of doing the same. I’m not worried about “identities,” I’m worried about younger women being made to feel that femaleness is not their homeland. Because it fucking is.
I still think that politician may be well-intentioned. I think she is trying to do all sorts of mental gymnastics to be inclusive because she believes that inclusivity (even inclusivity in definitions, which of course, completely defeats the purpose) is a worthy goal just by itself. It’s not, same as boundaries are not inherently violent.
I no longer feel I can build any bridges, start any sort of dialogue with her or others like her. Not because they have different ideas, but because they constantly misrepresent ours. Even so, just a few months ago, even after these disappointing non-conversations, I thought maybe we should give a chance to The Wokerati in charge of the Ministry of Equality (that Ministry went to Unidas Podemos). Maybe they would learn to listen to all voices. After all, that’s politics, isn’t it? Plus, they would all be focused on the pandemic. I was incredibly naive. Flash forward to the beginning of August.
Our Minister of Equality gives an interview in which she ponders “what is a woman? What breast size is needed to be considered a woman or a man?” At first I thought that she was just straw-terfing, mocking our supposed bio-essentialism. Then I listened to her. She was dead serious. She really can’t distinguish between men and women, which is a pretty big deal considering her position.
Spanish TwitTERF goes batshit crazy. It is the last straw. Back in June, the Ministry of Equality opened a public consultation on their intention to introduce new legislation to ensure LGBTI rights. Trans rights are already protected, by legislation passed in 2007, not to mention several regional laws, which are actually quite problematic and got passed with no real debate with the public. Name and sex marker changes at the Civil Registry are made through the 2007 Act, which establishes the following requirements: 1) To have a diagnosis of gender dysphoria, and 2) To have received HRT for at least two years. However, transgender people don’t have to meet this second requirement if there are legitimate medical and/or psychological reasons to avoid HRT.
Current efforts to extend the rights of LGTBI people in practice seek to introduce Self-ID into law and to enshrine “gender identity” as a meaningful category on its own while rendering “sex” invisible. The prevalence of “gender identity” can be seen in other Spanish law proposals. One proposal, which seeks to better tackle all sorts of sexual violence against women, defines “gender identity” in its Glossary section, recognizing it as an axis of oppression and resting only on Tumblr intersectionality when considering how some women can face “multiple discrimination.” Another one, nicknamed Ley Rhodes (Rhodes’s Law) after the sexual abuse survivor and pianist James Rhodes, seeks to protect children from every type of abuse, which is sorely needed. It’s a pity, however, that it also states that children’s “gender identity” (not their personality or their gender non-conformity, mind you) should be respected. Several feminist organizations have also criticized how Ley Rhodes fails to recognize sex-specific violence against girls.
When it comes to the new LGTBI legislation under consultation at the moment, we suspect that the Ministry of Equality has already written a proposal, but they won’t release it. They are not obligated to show us the draft yet, but the document they released when they opened the public consultation didn’t really give enough information about the proposed changes. As a result, many of us ended up arguing against a previous (and infructuous) attempt at passing Self-ID or “self-determination of the individual“ and making it even easier for kids to transition, even when parents oppose it. (Such is the case in the Valencian LGBTI Equality Law, passed back in 2018 and hailed as the most progressive in Spain.)
Naturally, our arguments were met with the response: you don’t yet know what the Law will say! Show us the proposal, then. Silence on their end again. Feminist organizations repeatedly tried to meet with the Minister. She ignored them, while meeting with numerous trans activist organizations. We kept insisting: #IreneWeHavetoTalk.
Then we listened to the Minister pondering whether big boobies made one a woman (incidentally, maybe fat men are women then, #FMAW) and that was just tragicomic. The Minister must think “woman” is a matter of degree, because that’s where you end up when you buy into clownfishery spectrumy bullshit. Anyhow, #IreneDimiteYa—“Irene, please resign”—was a trending topic that day. Some extreme right-wingers joined in the “fun” because for them it’s just another culture war, and many of them openly celebrate the possible end of sex-based protections in the law (such as our law against gendered violence which tackles domestic violence directed at women, and which rests on a feminist understanding of “gender,” not a Glittery Identitarian one). Then all the wokebros rushed to defend the Ministry. This tweet by Pablo Echenique, the Unidas Podemos spokesperson, takes the cake:
#IreneRepresentsMe because she knows that our moral compass is always always always about protecting and giving rights to the most oppressed (in this case trans people, who are brutally discriminated against) and that is feminism because feminism is taking care of others.
It’s really that easy and that simple.
We are being asked to be everyone’s mother, nothing sexist there. Moreover, we are asked to be particularly sensitive to a subset of male people, who are now killing it at the Oppression Olympics. But of course, male people who declare they are women are no longer male people. We are no longer allowed to perceive them as male, let alone feel wary around them in certain situations.
When Ms. Bee chided me for my terven fears she didn’t grasp the irony in the fact that just weeks before she had retweeted the following slogan: “Drunk and alone at night, I just want to arrive home.” So she understands fear and she understands female people being afraid of male people. Well, so long as male people don’t declare they are no longer male. We are supposed to soul-gaze into the male-bodied person who seems to be following us at night. *She might just be a fellow sister.
Surprisingly enough, wokebros telling us what feminism is didn’t abate our anger. Soon, the same people who were telling us “there’s no debate” changed their tune to “ladies, there’s no need to be so angry. Let’s just discuss things calmly, you are only helping right-wingers with your histrionics.” Previously they had just called us right-wingers, or reduced the debate to PSOE feminists being angry at having to give away the Ministry of Equality to Unidas Podemos. That this very same fight is happening globally, well, it must all be the work of Carmen Calvo, VP of the PSOE.
I could say this is all gaslighting and it is. But it’s also even more tragic. Because of the way they understand not just “gender identity” but “identity” itself, to disagree about the way someone perceives themselves is to deny their existence. It’s a contradictory combo of absolute solipsism (only I can decide who I am) and a demand of absolute validation (once I tell you who I am, you must perceive me as such).
Back in January, when I was still resisting my peak, I was meekly defending a Spanish feminist icon and an acquaintance of mine told me: “well, of course she has a right to express her ideas, but to question that trans women are women at this point in time?!?” Apparently ideas have an expiration date, which has a lot to do with thinking everything new and shiny is automatically good and progressive, even if it’s not really new but repackaged sexist and homophobic BS.
Before our favorite minister pondered how big the tits must be for one to be considered a chick, she said something along similar lines: it is true there’s a debate going on and I will go into that debate; however, trans people exist (female people on the other hand? Perhaps we don’t!) and there cannot be a debate around that. She then went on to define being “transgender” as “someone whose gender doesn’t match the one they were assigned at birth.”
That’s just it. We are being asked to accept their beliefs as facts before even being allowed to discuss anything, but the entire conflict rests on this one irreconcilable difference: we, the banished terven feminists, have a forbidden definition of what a woman is, one that doesn’t include gender souls.
Estela L. U. Vara. 30. Studied Philosophy, then did a master’s in Teaching Spanish as a Foreign Language. She taught Spanish for a short while, then English for a longer while. Currently studying to become a civil servant. She is a lefty and a feminist and is only sorry she took so long to peak. She enjoys singing and misses choir practice and karaoke nights. She’s never out of tune, she just engages in some stunning creative tuning 😉
