Issue Twelve

In Another’s Home

by Sneha Negi

“Many women, I think, resist feminism because it is an agony to be fully conscious of the brutal misogyny which permeates culture, society, and all personal relationships.”
—Andrea Dworkin, Our Blood: Prophecies and Discourses on Sexual Politics

It is in the most cheerful rooms, the ones filled with people I love, that I most often find myself choking on my own words, my own thoughts. A burden of conscience leaves me in such agony that it hurts almost physically: I must speak up. At the same time, the burden of love stops me from dulling the cheer on my loved ones’ faces, lest they call me a feminist killjoy. Usually, I do not mind being subjected to such labels – by strangers on the internet who disagree with me over a tweet’s reply (and believe me, I have been called much worse than a feminist killjoy), or by a classmate passing off a sexist comment as a harmless joke, or even by people in my leftist reading circles, because god forbid I comment on the glaring absence of women thinkers on the reading lists. But when a stale, run-of-the-mill wife joke passes around the coffee table at a family gathering, or a circle of my male friends laughs about women being terrible drivers over a Formula 1 race, I find myself in a quandary. I find myself tongue-tied: here, I want to be liked, more than I want to deconstruct the organization and mechanisms of the society I live in. Sometimes I do break my silence, but soon I find myself silent again. The disapproval of my loved ones converts my safest spaces into ones wherein I am the most scared to speak up, to demand for myself, to demand for other women.

My safe spaces are made out of love. I do not fear getting hurt here as long as I adhere to the elaborate instructions on what I should and should not do. I find my safe spaces to be bubbles of sorts. I may have to suppress myself every so often, but I am sheltered from just how terrible the rest of the world can be to me. These bubbles are made of many, many privileges: of class, of caste, of language, and so much more. Within these bubbles women are empowered, we are educated, we are supposedly independent; arguably we have agency and autonomy too. Empowered. It is a heavy word, and that is exactly what we are. Being empowered is a luxury which stems from excess, from not having to worry about survival; it allows us to worry so much about misogyny and whatnot. Men inside our bubbles appear to respect women; they may or may not abuse us, but at least we have some systems in place to take care of that; we have the privilege to walk away from relationships that hurt us. Our men are nicer to us, and when they are not, we have other men to take care of that as well. Moreover, we wield some kind of power over men who exist outside of our bubbles. Empowered. Exactly that, for as long as we posit women’s upliftment as a product of male benevolence and posit its ultimate goal as attaining power within male-default structures, we can only be empowered and never emancipated.

The yearning for the emancipation of women as a sex class, and of yourself as a part of it, is a yearning that default patriarchal thinking refuses to acknowledge. I do not wish to be an equal to men around me. I instead wish to be liberated such that violence no longer embodies power in my understanding. I wish to be liberated such that my father’s name ceases to hold immense importance over that of my mother, the parent who has been given disproportionate responsibility for care labour throughout my upbringing. I wish to be liberated such that the foundations of my alleviation do not rest upon the exploitation of another. I wish to be liberated such that an open display of empathy no longer embodies weakness in my understanding.

But it is also this yearning for emancipation that makes some women turn their backs on feminism. As a feminist, women who disavow feminism make me furious, but as a fellow woman, I also understand. I would be lying if I said there have not been days when I wish I had never found Dworkin or de Beauvoir or Atwood. The opportunity cost of refusing to be complicit in your own dehumanization or the denial of your complete personhood is to be constantly plagued by the consciousness of your loved ones’ failings and, even more painfully, failings of your own. I am aware of the many ways in which I do not live up to my feminist ideals. At times, I even consider myself to be a bad feminist – I shave, I sometimes laugh at sexist jokes, I fail to help other women in instances when my own safety feels threatened. I sometimes willingly comply with such norms and exhibit such behaviours even when I know these compromises are part of patriarchy working as intended.

When I’m theorizing, it’s not particularly taxing to critique societal structures or to describe empowerment, per the current popular understanding, as a mere façade within systems that still perpetuate chauvinist ideals. However, when these structures permeate my everyday life, my personal relationships, I find them so exhausting to navigate. I used to date a man who was having a hard time adjusting to life in the city we were living in at that time. But he would claim that being with me made it easier. Once, a friend of his jokingly said that it is, after all, the presence of a woman which turns a man’s house into a home. When my (then) partner relayed this to me, expecting a joyous response, he was taken aback by my reaction. The idea that it was my duty to make a man’s house a home petrified me. The seemingly affectionate statement came with such a loaded generational burden that I did not know how to process it. On one hand, I was flattered, and I felt cherished; on the other, I heard echoes of generations of women who came before me, who dedicated their lives to creating a home for a man because they weren’t allowed to build one of their own. I was tormented by the feeling of being a bad feminist because I felt flattered at the idea, while simultaneously being overwhelmed by the guilt of being a bad girlfriend because it filled me with horror to be held responsible for adding joy to my partner’s life in this way. He and I argued; he was annoyed that I couldn’t take a simple compliment without ruining it with a feminist spin. The word feminist spat out of his mouth like a curse, like an accusation, as though it was a dirty betrayal. I was empowered enough to have the autonomy to choose my partner (not to mention the privilege to write about him) and to voice my discomfort with his beliefs, yet not emancipated enough to participate in a relationship unencumbered by gendered expectations.

Months later when this man would break up with me, it would be on the grounds that he felt emasculated in my presence. I recall this with a particular disdain, because I remember wondering what was so terrible about being emasculated that it played the foremost role in his decision to no longer want to be with the woman he thought was making a home out of his alienating apartment. He could have meant simply that he felt insulted, but his deliberate choice of the term emasculate appeared to denote a distinctly male-associated experience of humiliation. Just like it is a specifically female-associated joy to create a home which is not yours out of a house which does not really belong to you, even when it might on paper. What is so bothersome about the term emasculation is that it fails to consider how, if it is humiliating for a man, it is humiliating for a woman too; it is just that, as a culture, we are so used to women being humiliated in certain ways that we do not take notice. It is only when men are subjected to such experiences, for example, being cut off, dismissed, publicly mocked in intimate circles, et cetera, that we notice the humiliation inherent to these actions. Only men can be subjected to emasculation; women come into this world emasculated.

Feminist consciousness may not always make you feel good, but it is not supposed to; it does often make you agitated, just as it should. It is not the duty of feminism to approve of all personal choices; it is also not the ultimate goal of feminism to facilitate better personal relationships, particularly with men. While grappling with this terrain of being a feminist alongside my other roles as a social being, I find myself in constant dilemmas, forcing me to choose between my feminist ideals of emancipation and the many benefits of empowerment in my safe-space bubbles. These bubbles, often camouflaged as progressive spaces, prove to be the biggest hindrances in pursuing the true emancipation of women. It is only upon deconstructing the superficiality of women’s empowerment within these bubbles, and introspecting personal dissonances, that we will be able to reach the heart of gendered discontents. It is not enough for our safe spaces to be secure houses or affectionate homes; we must strive to make them feel like our own.

Sneha Negi is an avid reader, a passionate writer, and a trained classical dancer with a deep fascination for the arts. Hailing from the beautiful valley of Dehradun, she harbours a profound love for the hills and a slow life away from the city’s chaos. In her free time, she enjoys a mean thriller. She also takes a keen interest in flowers and gardening.

a
Categories: Issue 12
a
Tags: Essay | Issue 12