by Rad Fem
“I was born like this. Why should I compromise myself?”
– Anne Lister, Gentleman Jack
Like many young girls, I went through the process of asking myself: “Should I actually have been male?” In my head I have always associated more with maleness, at least as it is seen through society’s stereotyped gender roles. But also in how I viewed myself, from an internal perspective. It’s hard to explain, but I want to try, because I think other girls who are asking themselves that same question today are only getting one answer and not getting a full picture of what their feelings might mean. I’m sharing my story for them, in the hopes that they might see another way their own stories could turn out.
From a very young age I was what is now termed gender non-conforming – a tomboy, as we called it back then. I see it more as knowing what I liked and what I didn’t like. And what I hated were dresses! At just three years old I felt like I was being made to put on a costume – dressed up in an outfit I didn’t want to be seen in. I felt so uncomfortable in dresses and skirts. I didn’t want to be ‘prettified.’ I never had a single moment’s interest in playing with ponies, dressing up, combing a doll’s long hair, or messing around with makeup. Instead, I played with Action Man, helicopters, and toy guns. Of course, these are not ‘girls’ toys’ and ‘boys’ toys,’ they are simply toys!
I was a kid; it was hard to understand all the thoughts and feelings whirling around inside me. I knew I didn’t fit in as everyone expected a girl to, but I felt far more comfortable and in tune with boys than with girls – I always have! When playing with friends, I was always the male character – the plumber, bus driver, or male love interest. It never once occurred to me to play a female character. I wanted to be strong and brave. I wanted to climb trees, do wheelies on my bike, build camps in trees, wear trousers and Bermuda shorts, and play on swing ropes. Thankfully my parents allowed me to just be; they didn’t question it, didn’t direct me or my behaviour towards society’s expectations of ‘girl’ things. And I will always be thankful for that.
I had years of other kids asking if I was a boy. It was scary more than hurtful, because I didn’t even know myself. Then as I got into my mid-to-late teens I started liking girls – yes, like that! Oh boy. Even more confusion ensued, and even more questions.
I lost count of how many times I was asked if I was a lesbian. The word was almost spat at me, LESBIAN, like LEPER, as if it was the worst thing in the world one could be. Of course I always said no, because who wants to be labelled a lesbian, the most hated form of female in the patriarchal world? Plus, I already ‘stood out’ from the crowd; I didn’t need yet another reason for people to talk about me.
But I knew I wasn’t like most other girls or women I saw, and the few women I could see myself in were those that were hated – especially by men. Butch lesbian characters on TV were always bad people, who behaved horribly, if they weren’t already in prison. I found other lesbian characters unrelatable as they were femmes, and that sure wasn’t me. And so the internal confusion and questions continued.
And then puberty hit. I could no longer wear some of the tops I liked, and I had to wear bras. My god, the shopping trips with Mum for bras. Shop assistants presumed I was a boy, and that I must be the brother of the bra wearer. I just wanted the ground to swallow me up! To this day, despite my hefty chest, I walk into a shop to buy sanitary products with huge embarrassment, as if people might say, ‘Why are you buying this, you’re not a girl!’ And I still get very uncomfortable approaching a public toilet. As I walk towards the ladies’ I unzip my jacket and pull each side back so my chest is obvious, so they see I’m a woman and don’t get upset or throw an embarrassing remark at me like, ‘This is the ladies’!’ This has never actually happened, but try telling that to the voice inside my head!
I spent years hiding. Hiding away from relationships. Hiding away from even talking about relationships. Enduring questions from family and friends about whether I’d found myself a nice boyfriend yet. I hated it. I ran from a lot. For years I denied myself one of the most fundamental parts of a healthy, fulfilled life – having a relationship with another human. The constant hiding and keeping up the pretence, being careful with my words, avoiding whole subjects and conversations – it was exhausting and lonely. So fucking lonely!
I even went so far as to go on dates with males to try to put people off the scent, although I am happy to say that I never did anything that I later regretted. The dates were for show, of course, but in a way I think I was also seeing if I could convince myself I was straight. I wasn’t!
And then after all of those years of confusion and questions, something changed. Once I matured a little and had the ability to make sense of all of my feelings, emotions, and desires – then I knew what I was. I was a lesbian. A butch, gender-non-conforming LESBIAN!
When I finally had the guts to come out (because I thought I was ‘in love’ with a woman), I told my whole family and best friend on the same day. My family were surprised, but so supportive – as deep down, I always knew they would be. My best friend’s response was completely nonchalant: “Yeah, I know. Now can we go to McDonald’s?”
The sense of relief and freedom was truly liberating. I could totally be myself. No need to hide anymore, no need to be careful what I said or how I said it, no more avoiding certain topics. I had no idea just how energy consuming that had been for years.
And I fully accepted myself: my dress sense, my ‘navvy’s’ walk, my mannerisms, sitting with my legs apart, my short hair, my energy – I was free and happy – so fucking happy! I finally knew what I was, and it was not male! I was a woman, a female, a butch female lesbian woman! And I was, am, and always will be proud as fuck of that fact.
I had all those confusing thoughts when I was a kid, but now that I had grown up I had the mental capacity to process and understand it all. But most of all, I ACCEPTED and LOVED who I was, who I am!
If I’d been born now, or if I’d had parents who believed in enforcing gender roles – whether traditional or ‘woke’ – God knows what I may have been through. My story may not help some who were convinced they should have been boys and were never given another way to think about their feelings. I truly feel for those people who have already transitioned and may now regret that, those who went down a path I had the luck to avoid. But if other girls or young women can see themselves in my story, maybe it will keep them from making life-changing, irreversible decisions based on what might be a temporary inability to process their feelings and fully understand themselves. Hopefully they’ll take their time, get good counselling if needed, and maybe discover that they too are an amazing lesbian!
Rad Fem is a gender-non-conforming lesbian who hopes to help young lesbians see that they are perfect just the way they are.
