by Allie Rogers
During World War Two, we bought sealed plastic packets of white, uncolored margarine, with a tiny, intense pellet of yellow colouring perched like a topaz just inside the clear skin of the bag. We would leave the margarine out for a while to soften, and then we would pinch the little pellet to break it inside the bag, releasing the rich yellowness into the soft pale mass of margarine. Then taking it carefully between our fingers, we would knead it gently back and forth, over and over, until the color had spread through the whole pound bag of margarine, thoroughly coloring it.
I find the erotic such a kernel within myself. When released from its intense and constrained pellet, it flows through and colors my life with a kind of energy that heightens and sensitizes and strengthens all my experience.1
That metaphor, of the bead of yellow in the packet of white margarine, glows at the centre of Audre Lorde’s essay ‘Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power.’ I have always loved it. The image of a woman’s fingers, pinching, kneading, flooding a colourless mass with bright yellow, was enough to take my breath away when first I read it. Because it is, of course, erotic in itself, perhaps especially for a lesbian reader. The idea of knowing, capable, female hands working warmth and colour into that pale margarine is so appealing. The sun shining on a scrubbed wooden table, perhaps, as she persists and persists at the task.
The whole essay, which you can hear in her own voice on YouTube,2 is a mere eight pages long. In it, Lorde sweeps, with her characteristic confidence, across the terrain of the erotic as she understands it – as a form of embodied energy that can inform many areas of our lives. I am not going to attempt an analysis of all the themes in this essay. In common with the best erotic encounters, it is initially captivating, deeply immersive, and also layered enough that it repays multiple readings. I invite you to seek out that encounter for yourself.
In this piece I am going to tell you something of the story of what this essay has meant to me as a woman and as a writer. And, since we have to start somewhere, let’s start with joy.
Again and again in this essay, Lorde comes to joy – the erotic as a sharing of joy and as the underlining of one’s own capacity for joy. Also how joy can remind us of our ability to access all forms of deep feeling. Her writing, circling and repeating in rising and falling refrains, is an example itself of what she is espousing. As you read, you are left in no doubt that Audre Lorde was certainly in touch with the erotic as a source of power.
When I feel deflated or lost from my own creative energy, I will sometimes turn to other women’s work to help me, and there are few women as inspiring and challenging as Audre Lorde. In this essay, there is not only the promise that I will find within myself that joyous energy again, but also a call to take my task in my hands. Because there is no passive waiting for the muse. The erotic brings us the power of deep feeling, and once we have known it, we can ask no less of ourselves than to honour that power through the pursuit of true excellence. There is no shirking what the erotic demands. As Lorde says,
Within the celebration of the erotic in all our endeavors, my work becomes a conscious decision – a longed-for bed which I enter gratefully, and from which I rise up empowered. (p. 24)
The idea that engaging with the erotic might lead to a desire for one’s work is not a good fit with patriarchal capitalist understanding of either. But for me, this observation rings true.
Let’s return to that image again, of a woman kneading colour through a block of margarine. The intense kernel of yellow, the topaz of the erotic, can only suffuse the pale substance of life through the kneading of the woman’s hands. There, in the conscious work, the potential is realized, to transform what is bland into a whole block of sunshine yellow.
But, much as we might recognize the need to consciously apply ourselves to our work, and indeed our lives, what is it in us that first compels us to bring our fingers to that “intense and constrained pellet”? What motivates us to reach out for the erotic inside ourselves? Desire.
Desire is both verb and noun. It is wanting. It is what is wanted. As women, our relationship with wanting is difficult from the start. To want something or someone is an active state. We learn as girls that, for those of our sex, to state or pursue our wants is taboo. We must instead endeavour to hint, to manipulate, to wait with good grace, to be patient. We must also, crucially, learn to be quietly disappointed.
For many of us, these approaches to existence often lead (along with their corollary – the endless meeting of the wants and needs of others) to a place where we simply cannot find our desires. We can become frustrated and resentful of this loss. Or, and this is perhaps more distressing still, we can settle into a life in which not just the objects of our desire become obscure to us, but the very state of desiring is lost.
She’s such a giving woman – so generous and empathic…
This is an excellent outcome, as far as a patriarchal society is concerned. And if, by any unfortunate chance, the wanting should wake up, desire should flicker in the wreckage, it can be fed some cheap and quickly combustible material – a mouthful of something ‘naughty’ to eat, a new object to hold in the reaching hand, a mass-produced fantasy in bingeable, box-set form.
To stay in relationship with our own desire is a transgressive state for women. Because of this, I believe that many of us fail to appreciate the continuing, evolving potential of the erotic in our lives as we age.
If we are tamed into desire that extends no further than meeting the desires of others, of performing that function well, we will find there is a socially sanctioned space available to us. The loving mother, aunt, or grandmother in our families, or the reliable colleague and supportive mentor in the workplace – these are the acceptable roles for older women. But should we insist on the reality of ourselves as desirous beings, we will often be vilified as selfish, greedy, arrogant or, frankly, disgusting. We are encouraged to let go of desire and, with it, our access to the erotic as a source of power.
Nearly ten years ago, in my early 40s, I wrote two novels, during a period of intense creative energy following a mental breakdown. I have sometimes jokingly characterized that breakdown as ‘being slapped by me, jumping out from an alley’ but this is, I think, a fair representation of what actually happened.
Over the preceding years, I had become far too good at suppressing the desirous, the demanding, in most aspects of myself. In my youth, I had found lesbian feminism and in it many beautiful encounters with the erotic, in both a sexual and a broader sense. But this connection to the erotic was not easy to sustain. The demands of life (earning a living, raising children), and the loss of lesbian feminist spaces and community, had quietened and misted the presence of this life-force.
Though I had, in many aspects, a happy life, the parts of me that actively desired were largely asleep. And so, in a last-ditch attempt to wake me up, my own psyche destabilized me to an extent that I could no longer deny the clamour. And out of the noise (along with undeniable pain for myself and my family) eventually came a re-negotiated relationship with my life, and two books.
The energy of that time was astonishing. Though barely sleeping, I could finish my paid job at 8pm and then go straight to a computer and write for four hours. It didn’t feel like a choice because, as I understand it now, my psyche had learned that if it were presented as a choice, I would fail to recognize my own desire. I had thoroughly learned the numbness of not wanting. I still struggle not to slip back into that state, by the way, and make a conscious demand of myself that I do not. It’s easier not to want things. It’s easier to stay tamed.
But in the breakdown, my desire had been unchained by a part of me I barely recognized, and that part said,
“I need this because you want this. And, so, this is the work you must do.”
And once seated in front of the keyboard, I sunk swiftly, and completely, into a state of creative flow. Time passed but I did not notice. Like good sex, deep creative flow buckles time. You can spend a long afternoon in rapt attention to a single scene, or pour out pages in an hour, in much the same way you can revel in the flow of physical intimacy with a lover.
Over months, this work was stormy, revealing and demanding in ways I had never experienced before. It was as intense as any affair. I could feel its connection to the sexual, the sensual, to life-force. And then I remembered, wasn’t there something Audre Lorde wrote about the erotic and creativity? So I went looking, and I re-found her wisdom. “Yes,” she seemed to be saying, “this.” Yes. This.
In feminist community, I believe that one of the roles we can play for each other is in the nurturing of the truly erotic. And, crucially, in holding a space in which the existence of the erotic is not denied or abused. The erotic, properly understood as a multi-faceted, embedded, integrated force in our own lives and in our relationships with each other, has the potential to liberate great energy. It can, of course, be expressed through sex. But also in connection of many types – the sharing of food, conversation, walking under an open sky together, collective work of all kinds, sharing our blessings and our losses.
Is this easy? No. In ‘Uses of the Erotic,’ Lorde touches on the challenges involved. These are potentially stormy waters. How could the erotic be anything else? And she identifies the need for a courageous looking that I think is as largely alien to us today as it was a quarter of a century ago. To look at the potential power of the erotic in our lives, and to continue to look honestly at ourselves as we access that power, is no small ask. We rarely have this modelled to us as we become women, and there are few safe spaces in which to discuss such things with others. Online spaces that seem to invite intimacy and honest exchange are often perilous and present further challenges that were unknown in Lorde’s day.
The deep honesty of looking, owning and staying with is part of the challenge of sharing the erotic. When we fail in this, we can cause great pain, to ourselves and to others. The stakes are high. As Audre Lorde puts it,
To share the power of each other’s feelings is different from using another’s feelings as we would use a Kleenex. When we look the other way from our experience, erotic or otherwise, we use rather than share the feelings of those others who participate in the experience with us. And use without the consent of the used is abuse. (p. 28)
The particular distortion that warps the erotic into the pornographic is touched upon several times in Lorde’s essay, and clearly there is much to be said about pornography now, when it has become so much more present in our world. It is an important topic and I do not discount it. But I do not intend to discuss it here. One of the ways the discussion of the genuinely erotic is most often disappeared is, I think, by the arrival of the topic of pornography. Like the unwelcome, opinionated man who disrupts a fruitful female conversation, so the topic of porn can drown out the nascent whispers of the erotic.
In conclusion, I realize that robbed of the full potential of the erotic, women cannot truly know what we are missing. We cannot know what it might make possible in our wider lives. Existing, as we all do, in patriarchal societies, we can only do our best to be open to its call, rising from within us and echoing in the valleys and hills of our relationships with others.
Below, I share just one experience of recognizing that call as I sit down to write. I am deeply grateful to Audre Lorde, who left words to help me understand desire and the true power of the erotic, and also to the women who have helped me to live it, in every sense.
I sit cross-legged on a window seat that looks out into a valley. A spring morning. The elms outside are cradling scores of starlings against the blue sky. The trill of their voices, like rich brocade around this moment.
My bare feet are cold, so I tuck them into the warmth of my thighs. Sit a little straighter, feel the tension in my neck, some unshed tears, some unspoken words.
Lift the laptop and lay my fingers on the keys. Breathe. The in-breath meets a pulse of pleasure, intensely sweet. Warm honey. You have time, Allie. Let it come. Let it come.
In the being, fully being. In the doing, truly doing. In the knowing, truly knowing. Now, work.
Allie Rogers is a Brighton-based writer of novels and short fiction. Her first book, Little Gold, published by Legend Press in 2017, was longlisted for the Author’s Club Best First Novel Award and shortlisted for the Polari First Book Prize. Her second novel, Tale of a Tooth, was published by Legend Press in 2018. Allie’s short fiction has appeared in a number of anthologies and magazines, including Bare Fiction, Queer in Brighton and the Salt Anthology of New Writing. She tweets as @alliewhowrites.
1 Audre Lorde, ‘Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power,’ in Your Silence Will Not Protect You (London: Silver Press, 2017), pp. 22-30. Paper first delivered at the Fourth Berkshire Conference on the History of Women, Mount Holyoke College, 25 August 1978.
2 ‘Audre Lorde reads Uses of the Erotic: The Erotic as Power (FULL Updated),’ YouTube, 1 August 2019.
