Issue Five

How ‘Different’ Came to Mean ‘Inferior’: An Explanation of My Religion-Haunted American Sisters

by Erin Becker

Sometimes in the gender discourse, I encounter statements that seem maximally ridiculous, and yet at the same time it’s very hard for me to tell whether they are made in earnest or whether they are made just to be confusing and hide reality. Even when the reasoning is obviously poor despite coming from intelligent people, it can still be hard to tell, thanks to the prevalence of thought-terminating cliches—those pat answers that will end your questioning when you’d rather not question too hard, at least not when there’s such tremendous social pressure to just accept everything promoted by the bleeding edge of transactivism. I had one such moment of confusion in early March, when I saw ex-evangelical women—whose analyses I once had a lot of respect for—make these comments:

I don’t need a reason besides love to fully affirm trans people, but y’know the *biggest* thing that turned me off from ‘gender critical feminism’?

It’s just rebranded complementarianism. I became a feminist when I escaped complementarian misogyny.

Y’all have fun with that.1

•••

That Mississippi anti-trans bill just wrote it into law that men and women are fundamentally different. That’s not about equality and fairness in sports, it’s about declaring in law that anyone assigned female at birth is fundamentally inferior. Cis women should be outraged.

It’s complementarian theology masquerading as science, and using transphobia to write the fundamental inequality of women into law, all while trying to torture trans kids out of existence.

Most of the text of that bill is enumerating a long list of ways that people assigned female at birth are inherently inferior, and it’s based on that inferiority that MS wrote into law that they ban trans girls and women from playing sports. It’s a step backwards for all women.2

These are only a couple of examples of what became a thought trend on Twitter, and as someone who spent the first half of her 20s fighting an evangelical Christian movement called complementarianism, and the second half finding this fight naturally led her to gender-critical feminism, I have to say the ‘GC = complementarianism’ meme that spread through ex-evangelical Twitter really took me aback. Surely they couldn’t believe this in earnest! But with reflection, I think I can follow a certain logic in it. These terms are very ‘inside baseball,’ but I want to explain the thinking going on here, because I believe that it’s relevant to a lot of confusion, muddled thinking, and susceptibility to poor arguments going on right now for American feminists, particularly ex-evangelical ones (although probably many more women are ‘haunted’ by these religious ideas, even if they don’t know the formal names for them).

So, what is complementarianism? The word is fairly esoteric even among many evangelicals, but it’s an umbrella term for an ideology that influences a huge number of (maybe most) evangelical churches. The traditional evangelical church with an organ and stuffy clothes often believes it … the church that looks like a movie theatre and has a young male pastor with skinny jeans (and even Justin Bieber in attendance) even more often believes it in some form.3 When this year Beth Moore — the biggest female voice in evangelicalism — came out publicly against it, and then a prominent Southern Baptist megachurch openly defied it by ordaining three women over Mother’s Day, this word probably reached more rank-and-file American Christians than ever before.4 Despite its influence and prevalence, complementarianism is actually a relatively recent theological movement that dates back to a text from the 90s, Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, which billed itself as “a response to evangelical feminism” (with more than a little element of backlash to the broader American women’s movement).5 Its key innovation is that, in a departure from previous patriarchal Christian theologies, it loudly affirms that “men and women are equal in dignity and worth” but immediately tacks on that they “have different roles.” The more quietly elaborated details after this summary, however, make it clear that these different roles amount to ‘men lead, women submit,’ with the practical implication of men being able to hold any position of authority in existence but women only being able to hold some subset of these. From this starting point, there’s then a huge spectrum of complementarianisms: each is defined by which roles women in particular are excluded from, ranging from all roles of authority to a select few.6 Much of the emphasis, however, is on how men and women are equal, but just different, while the hierarchy aspect is tucked away, beyond initial sight.

There is a heavy motte-and-bailey aspect to the strategy of complementarian ideologues.7 Any evangelical who dissents from this ideology is told, “But you’re arguing men and women must be the same to be equal! And clearly men and women aren’t identical!” Complementarians have retreated to their motte, pretending that all they’re saying is that men and women — despite being equal — are not the same. One might even call them … ‘complementary.’ These evangelicals promoting complementarianism will rely on the basic science that humans are sexually dimorphic, before quietly making the jump that the hierarchy of men over women is therefore justified by this natural difference. In spaces where they dominate the conversation, they have reduced evangelical dissenters (who often go by the label ‘egalitarian’) to people denying basic material reality.8

I think this is why women, especially ex-evangelical women, can look at the Mississippi bill referenced above that protects women’s sports and, due to language that acknowledges the physiological differences between men and women, conclude that the bill is ‘repackaged complementarianism.’ While the final text of the bill is a straightforward requirement that sports categories be based on biological sex,9 the original text of the bill started by saying that “There are ‘[i]nherent differences’ between men and women,” and that these differences “remain cause for celebration.”10 While this wording was actually drawn from a US Supreme Court case arguing against the separation of men and women in military training “without a compelling reason,” the use of “celebration” to an ex-evangelical ear does seem to echo how complementarians begin their arguments, as a celebration of the ‘beautiful’ and ‘good, God-ordained’ differences between men and women, which then justify that men are to rule, and women are to submit.11 It isn’t much of a stretch to see why this wording might appeal to complementarian conservatives in a Deep South state, who may view these ‘beautiful’ differences as part of a coherent package limiting women to a more narrow sphere. While some seemingly bad-faith activists have shouted that there are parallels between sex-segregated spaces/sports and racist ‘separate but equal’ policies in the US, a lot of ex-evangelical women can draw a much more direct parallel to the language about women (obfuscating as it is) in American evangelicalism.12

The real tragedy is that many feminist women — after leaving evangelicalism — seem to still accept that the complementarian argument would be a valid argument, were it not for the caveat that it gets certain facts wrong. Thus the way to fight it is to not to contest the argument, but instead to argue against any sexual dimorphism. The complementarian and nascent ‘feminist’ arguments then end up as sort of mirror images of each other — the internal logic is the same, but the facts are reversed — and it’s hard to tell which side is the ‘reactionary’ one (they both feed off each other and play into each other’s hands!). If men having some percent more upper-body strength on average than women makes them suited to lead, then why not argue back that the existence of intersex people means there are not clear-cut definitions of men and women — so how do we even know who should lead?13 The striking similarity about the arguments on both sides is that they primarily live in theory, with only the most tenuous overlap with material reality (some facts about sexual dimorphism, some facts about differences in sexual development). Both complementarians and the ex-evangelical women in question see the endpoint they want (patriarchal hierarchy in one case, equality in the other), and paint a pretty theory picture that they think will lead there, but both cases are so detached from the real world and reliant on leaps of logic that they end up being laughably untenable.

This last part is very important to me. I need a tenable argument for my full humanity and to defend the fact that I am not subordinate to men. One insight that has stayed with me comes from one of Jane Clare Jones’s essays on Judith Butler, where she explains that philosophers all have “wounds,” and one of the keys to understanding why Butler’s analysis ignores the female experience is that Butler’s wound primarily had to do with being a gender-non-conforming person, rather than being female.14 I’m not a philosopher, but I don’t think it’s a stretch to apply this idea of “wounds” to explain what brings women in general into feminism. My own wound comes from my experience of being female in evangelicalism, and has always incited me to push back against the claims of the inferiority of women (because despite complementarians’ claims to the contrary, it was hard to see how the natural subordination of all women to all men didn’t imply an ontological inferiority of women). My impulse, as someone who was inculcated in American evangelicalism, was for a long time to try to produce that mirror-image argument of complementarians, arguing that men and women were identical — after all women couldn’t be inferior to men if they were the same as them!15 I was always uncomfortable with sports for this reason, as they produce an extremely strong challenge to that belief.

The problem with this belief is of course pretty fundamental: it isn’t based in reality. And if I really wanted to get to a world where women were allowed to be the full human beings that they are (just as fully human as men), I was going to have to reckon with reality. That meant dealing with the reality of our bodies (despite the fact that I may have wanted to view myself as a brain in a jar) and seeing that different doesn’t mean inferior. It also meant seemingly changing my tack in certain circumstances — so much of the fight against complementarianism meant arguing that women weren’t in fact different (in intellectual gifts, in authority, in emotional stability), that ‘conceding’ our physiological differences felt like losing.16 I like how Emma Hilton puts it: “Sex shouldn’t matter half as much as it does, but there are … a small number of situations in which it will always matter, and where female protections are necessary.”17 And slowly I came to see that these situations were crucial to fight for if we ever were to achieve liberation. Coming to terms with the facts of our bodies meant having to accept the hard truth that women are exploited materially as resources, but how did I ever expect to heal my wound without knowing where it came from in the first place?

All this is to say that when I talk with some of my ex-evangelical friends about feminist analysis that actually liberates women, the language is a minefield. And usually I can see where they’re coming from even when their statements are obviously nonsense to anyone on the outside. “Women and men aren’t identical, but they’re still equally human” sounds a little too close for comfort to “equal in dignity and worth,” which has a silent patriarchy lurking behind it. American women have had a lot of reactionary programmes thrown at them that are cloaked in feminist language, and they’ve learned to be vigilant, albeit in very red team/blue team ways, which is unhelpful but difficult to escape. I cringe too at the bad logic thrown around by some of my American sisters, but I also sometimes feel a tug on my shirt from the ghost of my past — with its faulty reasoning but attractive fantasy — whispering “but hey … don’t they have a point?”

Erin Becker is a researcher in a computational field of science.

1 Samantha Field, Twitter, 12 March 2021.

2 Kathryn Brightbill, Twitter, 11 March 2021.

3 Julia Baird, ‘“Submit to your husbands”: Women told to endure domestic violence in the name of God,’ ABC News, 21 October 2018.

4 Yonat Shimron and Bob Smietana, ‘On the heels of her split with Southern Baptists, Beth Moore apologizes for supporting a theology that restricts women,’ Washington Post, 7 April 2021; Bob Smietana, ‘Saddleback Church just ordained three women as pastors. The Southern Baptist Convention says only men should be,’ Washington Post, 11 May 2021, .

5 Scott McKnight, ‘Complementarianism examined,’ Christianity Today, 4 January 2021.

6 William G. Witt, Icons of Christ: A Biblical and Systematic Theology for Women’s Ordination (Waco, TX: Baylor University Press, 2020).

7 Nicholas Shackel, ‘The Vacuity of Postmodernist Methodology,’ Metaphilosophy, 36.3 (2005), 295-320, .

8 Justin Taylor, ‘How should we think about watching women fight women?’ The Gospel Coalition, 30 December 2016; Robin Bunce, ‘Complementarity: The fallacy of male strength,’ Christian Feminist Network, 8 January 2019.

9 Senators of Mississippi Legislature, ‘Senate Bill 2536 (As Introduced),’ 2021.

10 Senators of Mississippi Legislature, ‘Senate Bill 2536,’ 2021.

11 Brett McCracken, ‘The beauty of complementarity goes beyond gender,’ The Gospel Coalition, 28 July 2018.

12 Zack Hunt, ‘Complementarianism: The church’s segregation problem,’ Patheos, 3 March 2014.

13 Megan K. DeFranza, Sex Difference in Christian Theology: Male, Female, and Intersex in the Image of God (Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans, 2015).

14 Jane Clare Jones, ‘Poststructuralism, Butler and bodies, part 3: All that trouble with gender,’ 18 July 2018.

15 Ironically, gender-identity ideology also seems to define men and women as different—but through personalities rather than biology. In fact, this point was what first pushed me away from it. Most ex-evangelical women who cling to a belief in gender identity seem to stop at the thought-terminating ‘it has nothing to do with personality, clothes, behaviour — it’s only an internal sense of being.’ But then why should this be of any significance to define us all? That’s where the thinking ends, as far as I can tell.

16 I’m still close to a blank-slater when it comes to the brain. I really appreciate the work Cordelia Fine does to push back against evolutionary psychology’s claims about men’s and women’s natures, but don’t ask me to be an impartial observer there!

17 Emma Hilton, Twitter, 20 September 2020.